Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

The Cavanagh Club

Brad Bowers

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,187
I dug back through my research to find an article on the '59 derby revival, and a couple of things jumped out at me. One was the comment that the '59 derbies were more of a British-styled bowler, with a belled crown and billycock roll to the brim. I can't tell if this one has the belled crown, but it definitely has the billycock roll. The article said that the new derbies were lighter and more flexible, and it looks like this one does have a more flexible crown.

Another hat that was part of this revival was what they called the "demi-bowler," in that it was like a derby, but had a center crease like a homburg.

Sales of the derby pretty well died out during the early years of the Depression. To give you an idea of the scope of this revival, Hat Corporation of America sold around 800 derbies per year throughout the 1940s and 1950s. By the summer of '59, though, they were putting out about 3,000 derbies per week! One thing that helped sales was that women were buying them to wear, not just men. It became a unisex item. The revival was short, but I don't quite know when it ended. I think it was only a year or two, though.

It's interesting that Cavanagh appears to have kept the $15 price point for a very long time - three decades, at least. What I find amazing is that hat prices held pretty steady over that time period. Sure, the top end prices for Cavanagh rose from $40 to $100, but their bottom prices stayed consistent. Even factoring in a reduction in quality to help cover the cost, hats seemed to have maintained an anti-inflationary stance until the 1970s.

Brad
 

rlk

I'll Lock Up
Messages
6,100
Location
Evanston, IL
Chocolate Milk Brown Cavanagh

3682237802_dc64610a3d_b.jpg

3682237602_4228d8ac82_b.jpg

3682237256_ab6c7d865d.jpg
3681423773_b5fb2623dd_b.jpg

Fresh from ebay. Looks like new. Full 2" sweatband, 2-1/4" brim. Price marked down from $25.00 to $14.90. Originally sold by The Metropolitan Co. Dayton, Ohio.
 

rlk

I'll Lock Up
Messages
6,100
Location
Evanston, IL
1959 Derby Ad

Brad Bowers said:
I dug back through my research to find an article on the '59 derby revival, and a couple of things jumped out at me. One was the comment that the '59 derbies were more of a British-styled bowler, with a belled crown and billycock roll to the brim. I can't tell if this one has the belled crown, but it definitely has the billycock roll. The article said that the new derbies were lighter and more flexible, and it looks like this one does have a more flexible crown.

Another hat that was part of this revival was what they called the "demi-bowler," in that it was like a derby, but had a center crease like a homburg.

Sales of the derby pretty well died out during the early years of the Depression. To give you an idea of the scope of this revival, Hat Corporation of America sold around 800 derbies per year throughout the 1940s and 1950s. By the summer of '59, though, they were putting out about 3,000 derbies per week! One thing that helped sales was that women were buying them to wear, not just men. It became a unisex item. The revival was short, but I don't quite know when it ended. I think it was only a year or two, though.

It's interesting that Cavanagh appears to have kept the $15 price point for a very long time - three decades, at least. What I find amazing is that hat prices held pretty steady over that time period. Sure, the top end prices for Cavanagh rose from $40 to $100, but their bottom prices stayed consistent. Even factoring in a reduction in quality to help cover the cost, hats seemed to have maintained an anti-inflationary stance until the 1970s.

Brad
Saw this ad:
3691386787_03cbec7c0b_b.jpg
 

XPLSV

One of the Regulars
Messages
215
Location
Colorado Springs
feltfan said:
That panama looks to be treated/painted with something?
If memory serves, Dinerman recently cleaned up such a panama.
You might ask him what that was all about before sending it
on to Optimo.

It arrived at Optimo this past week for cleaning and reblocking--I asked about whether it had been treated or sprayed with something...they said it was a sulfer bleaching.
 

rlk

I'll Lock Up
Messages
6,100
Location
Evanston, IL
XPLSV said:
It arrived at Optimo this past week for cleaning and reblocking--I asked about whether it had been treated or sprayed with something...they said it was a sulfer bleaching.
I saw your hat while at Optimo and it was pointed out as an example of poor cleaning(bleaching) in the past. Graham has just gone on vacation so if it wasn't completed it may take a bit. The hat I dropped off on Friday won't be ready until July 24.
 

feltfan

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,190
Location
Oakland, CA, USA
XPLSV said:
It arrived at Optimo this past week for cleaning and reblocking--I asked about whether it had been treated or sprayed with something...they said it was a sulfer bleaching.
Ah, an awful lot of vintage panamas were treated that way.
Some of mine, for sure. It's not too bothersome, at least to me.
I don't really understand why they did it, though. It doesn't really
bleach the hat. But I think it does coat it, perhaps making it
possible to brush the panama?
 

XPLSV

One of the Regulars
Messages
215
Location
Colorado Springs
rlk said:
I saw your hat while at Optimo and it was pointed out as an example of poor cleaning(bleaching) in the past. Graham has just gone on vacation so if it wasn't completed it may take a bit. The hat I dropped off on Friday won't be ready until July 24.

They told me up front about the vacation, so I'm not too worried about turn around time. Heck, I've been waiting on an Adventurbilt from Nov 2007 and a Randall Made Knife from Dec 2005...the joke around here is my son will never know what he might get in the mail should I kick the bucket :)

(We've got the same name).

Bernie
 

rlk

I'll Lock Up
Messages
6,100
Location
Evanston, IL
Jumbo Grey Cavanagh

3709671155_5c7ffd22fc_b.jpg

3709673321_e0b20d967b_b.jpg

3710481888_b4f4b1f5a1_b.jpg

3709673939_49e0bc7bd4_b.jpg

3710484810_188e4dfcd3.jpg
3710485494_ecf08ca831.jpg

Much bigger than expected. Brim is 2-3/4" front and back, 2-5/8" on the sides. 5-3/4" crown. Size 7-1/2 XLO. Overall condition would be excellent but for numerous moth nips, which are all individually small and shallow(probably could make them nearly vanish with some work). Underside is near perfect. I won't be wearing this one. Originally $20.00 fromL. Strauss Co. Inc. Indianapolis. and owned by J. Wayne Ebert M.O.
 

Brad Bowers

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,187
A rare beauty there, even with the critter damage. Tall crown and really wide brim, wow. Nice one, rlk!

It's hard to tell from the photo, but it looks like the sweatband is NOT marked "Cavanagh Edge." Is that right?


Brad
 

rlk

I'll Lock Up
Messages
6,100
Location
Evanston, IL
Brad Bowers said:
A rare beauty there, even with the critter damage. Tall crown and really wide brim, wow. Nice one, rlk!

It's hard to tell from the photo, but it looks like the sweatband is NOT marked "Cavanagh Edge." Is that right?


Brad
Yes, Brad, no "Cavanagh Edge" on the sweatband and the Park Ave. address on the liner.
 

Garrett

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,782
So, given the absence of the cavanagh edge stamp and the address presence on the liner what is the dating of this one?
 

Brad Bowers

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,187
Garrett said:
So, given the absence of the cavanagh edge stamp and the address presence on the liner what is the dating of this one?

No idea. It's interesting that it doesn't say Cavanagh Edge. I can't imagine why they wouldn't have stamped it.

I haven't been able to discern the significance of the Park Avenue address on the liner, either. I once thought it was used on hats that were retailed from the store itself, but I've seen enough Cavanaghs that were sold through their retail network with the Park Avenue liner to discount that idea. My best guess is that it was used for a period of time, but no clue when that might have been. The only thing I can say with certainty is that it's pre-1964, as that is when the shop was forced to relocate from 247 Park Avenue.

You see a lot of L. Strauss & Co.-marked hats from Cavanagh and Dobbs, as their relationship with the department store chain stretched way back into the C&K days.

rlk, is there any sign of a union label underneath the sweatband or liner? That might help date it.

Brad
 

rlk

I'll Lock Up
Messages
6,100
Location
Evanston, IL
Brad Bowers said:
No idea. It's interesting that it doesn't say Cavanagh Edge. I can't imagine why they wouldn't have stamped it.

I haven't been able to discern the significance of the Park Avenue address on the liner, either. I once thought it was used on hats that were retailed from the store itself, but I've seen enough Cavanaghs that were sold through their retail network with the Park Avenue liner to discount that idea. My best guess is that it was used for a period of time, but no clue when that might have been. The only thing I can say with certainty is that it's pre-1964, as that is when the shop was forced to relocate from 247 Park Avenue.

You see a lot of L. Strauss & Co.-marked hats from Cavanagh and Dobbs, as their relationship with the department store chain stretched way back into the C&K days.

rlk, is there any sign of a union label underneath the sweatband or liner? That might help date it.

Brad

No sign of a Union tag or that there ever was a size tag or tape behind the stitched sweatband seam. Its a different sweatband than any of my other Cavanaghs. Smooth outer surface. 7-1/2 inked stamp on underside of band. in middle of side.
 

rlk

I'll Lock Up
Messages
6,100
Location
Evanston, IL
Optimo renovated Gray Cavanagh

3710027637_53753d3b39_b.jpg

3710027389_d8e37af6bc_b.jpg

3710838504_24859e6b52_b.jpg

3710842172_7a69afc2d2.jpg
3710031463_5a19b2a4fb.jpg

Never did show this post renovation. It has a 2-7/16" brim all around. The cardboard size tag was behind the sweatband seam double loop tie rather than triple. Unfortunately it had no liner.
 

Dreispitz

One Too Many
Messages
1,164
Blue Onyx 7 3/8

Here is the little thingy that was described as some black bowler and went for under 10 USD. I must say, a good deal for a rare item in this condition. lol :rolleyes:

From the rather unclear auction pictures, I put it somewhere 60ies. Now it is here, and I have got to revise my estimate. It is a phantastic darkish blue onyx felt of Cavanagh´s best. 2 1/4 brim and high crown. The silk ribbon is very fine quality, cavanagh edge and the embossed ribbon that is usually present in hats up to the beginning fifties. Therefore, I put the hat in that time frame.

Concerning it´s purpose, it still shows virginity in terms of absence of wear and has kept all it´s tags. The inside is still a bit dusty. It was obviously not kept in a box.

Enjoy the pictures!







 

Brad Bowers

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,187
That is one sweet Cavanagh, Dreispitz!:eusa_clap

Blue Onyx is one of their best colors, in my opinion. I need to get one in that color one of these days. Maybe once my paychecks start rolling in again at the end of September I can run across one.

I'm almost tempted to say that your hat is pre-1946, since there is no evidence of a Union label. Considering how "virgin" your hat is, it should, theoretically, be there if it's later than '46. The perforated price and size tag is also slightly different from others we've seen.

[EDIT: I just remembered that the Union label could be glued to the felt underneath the liner.]

Can you make out anything at all of the stamp on the sweatband next to the tag in this photo? Most of the time these are illegible.

Brad

Dreispitz said:
 

Dreispitz

One Too Many
Messages
1,164
Brad Bowers said:
That is one sweet Cavanagh, Dreispitz!:eusa_clap

Blue Onyx is one of their best colors, in my opinion. I need to get one in that color one of these days. Maybe once my paychecks start rolling in again at the end of September I can run across one.

I'm almost tempted to say that your hat is pre-1946, since there is no evidence of a Union label. Considering how "virgin" your hat is, it should, theoretically, be there if it's later than '46. The perforated price and size tag is also slightly different from others we've seen.

[EDIT: I just remembered that the Union label could be glued to the felt underneath the liner.]

Can you make out anything at all of the stamp on the sweatband next to the tag in this photo? Most of the time these are illegible.

Brad

Thank you, Brad!

Yes, the hat has some properties, that are typical, jet different from other Cavanaghs. I had a closer look under the sweatband. I did not find a union lable - even not after thorough palpation - but another tag. That might be the giveaway. Do you have record of similar lables of the time or does the code give any evidence?

The fold in the liner and the border of the centre medallion are certainly noteworthy. The stamp on the sweatband si not really legible, I must regret.



 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,253
Messages
3,077,348
Members
54,183
Latest member
UrbanGraveDave
Top