Not a great fan of either (but then mixed leather/wool jackets don't appeal, nor do leather/hair grizzly jackets).
If pushed, I'd go for the Canuck, but probably ask for the leather trim to be replaced.
That one is either Worf's or one of my early GW A-1s. The hide is good, but looks better in the images - it can look a little '80s distressed leather in some lights.
I've had a lot of capeskin A-1 jackets (many from ELC and Good Wear and one from BK) and the ELC .50cal A-1 is quite different from the conventional A-1. The 'time worn' treatment toughens and strengthens the capeskin so that it's more like a light horsehide IMO. I's my 'go to' jacket during...
When we worked up my BK A-1 together, Platon and Andy (of Bill Kelso) were an extremely easy team with which to work. They were prompt with replies to e-mails, responsive to requests for changes to pattern/configuration and the workmanship on the resulting jacket was really top notch.
As Mark...
I have a Buzz Rickson N-1 with alpaca lining (I've previously had several ELC B-10 and B-15 jackets). I'm in the South of England and the N-1 really only gets significant daytime use from October through to February (or on the occasional cold/wet evening). I wear a shirt and a thin sweater...
Glad you persevered with the posting process, Mark - they both look superb and suit your body shape really well. Both A-1 and the derivatives certainly look best in the 36/38 range and they look more shirt-like.
That Victory capeskin is a really warm, comfortable and pliable hide to wear.
I...
BigJ, are we talking about the same Paddy?
He can speak for himself of course, but he has never struck me as a follower of any particular brand. He's obviously a connoisseur of 30s and 40s styling and original Irvins (and clearly appreciative of different repro manufacturers whether Good Wear...
Paddy Middleton? You heard his thoughts on the matter (very succinctly and eruditely put, as ever) when he locked the thread before the comments were deleted and the thread re-opened.
Hi Paul
If I recall correctly, my N-1 seawater wash did have a stronger aroma than the corresponding regular N-1.
I can't tell you whether it fades - I couldn't get on with the incredibly itchy lining and had to trade it for a regular BR N-1 instead (which is a keeper for me).
Hope it fades for...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.