Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Five Star Leather Jackets

Canuck Panda

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,652
Just arrived today. Cossack in cream Shawn “CXL”. The leather feels nice and a little sandy. Nice character and marks where we scratch it. The color is not as I expected though. And for some reason even having let a few cm here and there for a comfortable fit, my arm movement is restricted forward and up and it pulls the jacket up. Perhaps needs to break in? I’m really annoyed by the restrictions. For the rest I’m happy.

The Horween/Aero Natural CXL feels sandy too. But I am more anxious about how Shawn's CXL will actual show the pull up effect. I am hoping it will have multi tone color variations like the Horween. Fingers crossed.
 

Grasp loo paper

One of the Regulars
Messages
212
Well here are some pictures if I believe it’s multi toned
 

Attachments

  • image.jpg
    image.jpg
    2.8 MB · Views: 263

Dionysus

New in Town
Messages
15
5star has zero knowledge about the pattern that allows arm movement, and now they are launching the thicker leather .....
 

MrProper

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,287
Location
Europe
Just arrived today. Cossack in cream Shawn “CXL”. The leather feels nice and a little sandy. Nice character and marks where we scratch it. The color is not as I expected though. And for some reason even having let a few cm here and there for a comfortable fit, my arm movement is restricted forward and up and it pulls the jacket up. Perhaps needs to break in? I’m really annoyed by the restrictions. For the rest I’m happy.

I like it very much. Much better than the sloppy Cossacks.
I almost have to think about whether I have to be a bit more generous with this leather with my measurements. Actually, I assume that my standard dimensions + 5mm should also fit, since the leather is "only" 0.5mm thicker than my usual mid-weight leather. But if it's very stiff, maybe more is needed?


5star has zero knowledge about the pattern that allows arm movement, and now they are launching the thicker leather .....

What exactly makes your opinion?
I'm not exactly the specialist, but I claim that jackets from 5* are in no way inferior to other manufacturers in terms of fit. In fact, I would say that my most comfortable leather jackets are from 5*.

In my opinion, a jacket moves a lot upwards when the interplay between shoulder width, armhole and P2P is not right. Pointed shoulders add to the problem.
 

Canuck Panda

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,652
I like it very much. Much better than the sloppy Cossacks.
I almost have to think about whether I have to be a bit more generous with this leather with my measurements. Actually, I assume that my standard dimensions + 5mm should also fit, since the leather is "only" 0.5mm thicker than my usual mid-weight leather. But if it's very stiff, maybe more is needed?
Hey MrProper, FWIW, I went half inch up for the thicker leather built with Shawn. I am just pulling this outta my arse though, as I have no idea how it will turn out.

My previous jackets from Shawn (in goat) specs:
Shoulder 19"
P2P 23"
Waist 19" - 19.5" (where the half belt is, I got sewn in elastics instead of side straps)
Hem 20"
My upcoming CXL thick leather with Shawn:
Shoulder 19.5"
P2P 23.5"
Waist 19.5"
Hem 20.5"
I kept the back length and sleeve length the same.

I have also read somewhere on this forum that Field Leathers suggest going up 0.25" for thicker leather. This would translate to your +5mm.

Mr. Graspe loo Paper's new jacket looks exact like how a new Aero CXL jacket would drape though, so that's a big positive!
 

Riu

Practically Family
Messages
703
Location
UK
Just arrived today. Cossack in cream Shawn “CXL”. The leather feels nice and a little sandy. Nice character and marks where we scratch it. The color is not as I expected though. And for some reason even having let a few cm here and there for a comfortable fit, my arm movement is restricted forward and up and it pulls the jacket up. Perhaps needs to break in? I’m really annoyed by the restrictions. For the rest I’m happy.

Looking great! I'm sure more qualified people know more about this but maybe a smaller armhole could help with that? How does the leather feel?
 

Grasp loo paper

One of the Regulars
Messages
212
Looking great! I'm sure more qualified people know more about this but maybe a smaller armhole could help with that? How does the leather feel?
The leather feels good, softer than the goat, but I still think it can become softer. It’s very thick, when I fold my arms my elbows hurt a little. Overall it’s very nice leather. If I can get the a little more mobility from the arms by breaking it in, I’d be perfect! I regret not making the waist tighter though don’t like the boxy belly.
 

Riu

Practically Family
Messages
703
Location
UK
Looks fine to me, I hope it will feel more comfortable after it will mould around your body a bit more, I'm also curious how it will look after some rain and wear. Congrats and enjoy it :)
 

navetsea

I'll Lock Up
Messages
6,836
Location
East Java
I gave 44 cm shoulder (I am 43)
Gave 108 chest (I’m 96)
And gave armhole 25cm (50cm) I have extra space everywhere. It feels it’s tightening my forearm when lifting my arm up (sleeve slips up) but I have let extra cm everywhere perhaps the pattern?
your measurement seems close to my size,
but my armhole in that size is 19cm (38cm around) or 20cm (40cm around) and don't add to much on the chest if you are 96cm around chest I think between 100cm or 104cm on the jacket is maximum, seems your problem is that your arm hole is too low and the chest is roomy, so rather than forcing the sleeve to crease up as you lift your arm, the whole jacket rather move up since it has less resistance to do that, eventually it will settle once broken in, try to wear backpack on top of the jacket, wet your upper sleeve and lift your arm up and down several time, do swimming arm movement, driving movement while the sleeve is wet to make the jacket's sleeve learn where to crease without lifting the whole body up.
 

MrProper

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,287
Location
Europe
I once had fun taking pictures of some of my jackets while raising my arms.
As you can see, there is no jacket that doesn't raise the hem at least a little. Only the one with the football on her armpits hardly moves at all.
By the way, the jeans are low rise.
For me, this freedom of movement fits perfectly, because I tend to never walk around with my arms stretched to the side or forward. The exception might be a zombie walk.

5* Cossack, pointy shoulders
tempImage0qPVte.png
tempImagew2ynVg.png
tempImageF7TiIt.png


5* Cafe Racer, rounded shoulders
tempImagey7FoUa.png

tempImageU1z4G9.png
tempImageFDdmsh.png


Aero Sheene
tempImagebf8Lxh.png
tempImageXW1JMW.png
tempImagePgEH0h.png
 

MrProper

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,287
Location
Europe
cool vest, I think either make the patch pocket a little bit smaller so the edges not covering the brown leather edge or have the patch canvas pocket sandwiched under that brown edge trim.
You're absolutely right ... if the pockets were made of canvas. Unfortunately, as far as I know, Shawn doesn't have a heavy canvas, Just the heavy cotton drill and that doesn't satisfy me.
So my idea is to use the seal-colored steerhide instead of canvas.
With canvas bags for me it would looks so:
F886941C-2D99-413C-A2E0-D371A5D78089.jpeg
 

Riu

Practically Family
Messages
703
Location
UK
You're absolutely right ... if the pockets were made of canvas. Unfortunately, as far as I know, Shawn doesn't have a heavy canvas, Just the heavy cotton drill and that doesn't satisfy me.
So my idea is to use the seal-colored steerhide instead of canvas.
With canvas bags for me it would looks so:
View attachment 335493

I've asked him about the canvas too, the only way to have it done is to provide him the fabric.
 
Last edited:

Hh121

Banned
Messages
3,004
That is very helpful @MrProper, in some pictures I can see no difference between rounded shoulder and pointy shoulder, it looks same, can you enlighten me what exactly is rounded shoulder?
Vanson B has pointy shoulder but won't bunch up when raising your arm from side.
 

Grasp loo paper

One of the Regulars
Messages
212
your measurement seems close to my size,
but my armhole in that size is 19cm (38cm around) or 20cm (40cm around) and don't add to much on the chest if you are 96cm around chest I think between 100cm or 104cm on the jacket is maximum, seems your problem is that your arm hole is too low and the chest is roomy, so rather than forcing the sleeve to crease up as you lift your arm, the whole jacket rather move up since it has less resistance to do that, eventually it will settle once broken in, try to wear backpack on top of the jacket, wet your upper sleeve and lift your arm up and down several time, do swimming arm movement, driving movement while the sleeve is wet to make the jacket's sleeve learn where to crease without lifting the whole body up.
Thank you for the in-depth explanation, the combination of Chest & low armhole might have added to the problem, driving is difficult with it.
How do you determine your armhole size? Also anyway I can try to fix this jacket?
 

Carlos840

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,944
Location
London

I'm not sure how helpful this is...
You are basically comparing a bunch of jackets with poor mobility trying to figure out which is best.
Aero has IMO horrible patterns as far as mobility is concerned, FL patterns suffer from similar issues, and 5 Star can be all over the place.
IMO it's a bit like comparing McDonalds, Burger King and Wendy's looking for the best burger, odds are you are not going to find it there...

If you took the same pics comparing a Langlitz Columbia, a Lewis MkII and a Vanson Model E you would see basically no movement of the jacket when changing position as these jackets have patterns designed for free movement.
 

navetsea

I'll Lock Up
Messages
6,836
Location
East Java
Thank you for the in-depth explanation, the combination of Chest & low armhole might have added to the problem, driving is difficult with it.
How do you determine your armhole size? Also anyway I can try to fix this jacket?
just using measurement tape around my shoulder under my arm, slide in a finger or two for extra space.
just break it in so the upper sleeve is softer and will crease there first as you lift your arm, if we are talking real fix then probably underarm gusset/ football as it raise your underarm and add extra expansion panel there, rotating the sleeve forward a few degree also helps a lot. pattern wise, I think for a jacket without gusset the lower back need to have some space to make your forward arm movement unhindered, if you taper the lower back too close to your spine, while the jacket will look neater viewed from behind, but it will limit forward rotation of your arm.
 
Last edited:

Forum statistics

Threads
109,031
Messages
3,073,071
Members
54,037
Latest member
GloriaJama
Top