I've always hated the "lid" analogy too & never use it myself.
The first cool, crisp fall-like morning calls for the first black hat of the season, a 1900's - 1910's Stetson Boss Raw Edge with Fray sweat/red bow.
View attachment 260902
View attachment 260903
View attachment 260904
View attachment 260905
View attachment 260907
What a hat!