Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

The Bowler or Derby Hat

The Wiser Hatter

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,765
Location
Louisville, Ky
Al yes I hope to pick one up one day.What I love is the difference. Sort of like when I sit my Disney hats next to my Mallory hats. You can see the difference in the blocks used on the hat as well as the curve of the brim. each hat maker hat their own blocks.
 
Messages
17,514
Location
Maryland
Steve: I appreciate your kind remarks, thank you. Love your Brüder Böhm Melone. Can you clarify why the name used is 'Brüder' versus 'Gebrüder'? An expedient contraction, perhaps? Your Hut-Schick Melone is incredible as well.

Al, Thanks! I have no idea why 'Brüder' versus 'Gebrüder' so I checked online. It appears Gebrüder would be all brothers Böhm. Brüder in this case would be brothers Bernhard and Naphtali who formed the company. Maybe a native speaker (Manfred, Mario, Dieter ) can verify / clarify?
 
Last edited:

Chepstow

I'll Lock Up
Messages
5,406
Location
Germany/ Remscheid
Al, Thanks! I have no idea why 'Brüder' versus 'Gebrüder' so I checked online. It appears Gebrüder would be all brothers Böhm. Brüder in this case would be brothers Bernhard and Naphtali who formed the company. Maybe a native speaker (Manfred, Mario, Dieter ) can verify / clarify?

Al, Steve This could be help. In English Brothers Grimm and Brothers Grimm no difference in the pronunciation

Why do you say "Gebrüder Grimm" and not "Brüder Grimm"?

The public is the archaic term "Gebrüder Grimm" indeed more popular than the simpler version of "Brüder Grimm". However, most Germanists use the word "brothers". Also, the Grimms themselves preferred the term.

This may be because they wanted to avoid the association of company names. For "Gebrüder" was about 100 years, 1850-1950, a very common word in company name.

The meanings of words in any case allow the use of both words. And as far back as Jacob Grimm (1785-1863) and Wilhelm Grimm (1786-1859) were both applied to them.

The Grimms' German Dictionary "shares at the beginning of the article" Gebrüder "with that this is an old, emphasizing the unity of plural formation" Brüder ". Regarding the relationships there are between "Gebrüder" and "Brüder" no difference, and also a highlight of two brothers over the other siblings in the word's meaning is not created. It can also act well by three, four or more "brothers".
 
Last edited:
Messages
17,514
Location
Maryland
Thanks for the clarification. The info I presented came from a discussion relating to the Brothers Grimm. Interesting the Böhm's went with "Brüder" for their company (1848) name.
 

delectans

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,335
Location
Minnesota
Many thanks for the illuminating discussion, Chepstow. Perhaps then, the use of 'Brüder' was an intentional means of conveying a less formal, more progressive, familiar and accessible tone to the company name than the traditional and pedantic 'Gebrüder'.
 

Joshbru3

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,409
Location
Chicago, IL
Late 1890's/Early 1900's Champion Hat Derby (Keith Brothers & Co) (Chicago)

DSC06746.jpg


DSC06747.jpg


DSC06748.jpg


DSC06750.jpg


DSC06752.jpg


DSC06753.jpg


DSC06754.jpg


DSC06755.jpg


DSC06758.jpg


Here's an advertisement for Keith Brothers & Co (1898) which shows the "Champion" logo if you look close. Out of all the American Hatter publications, there is only several mentions of this brand and only 1898 had any actual advertisements. I do have a couple more besides this one.

1898KeithBrothersCoTheChampionHat.jpg
 
Last edited:

TheRomanhistorian

New in Town
Messages
7
Location
Renton, WA
Hello everyone!

I'm a bit new here but I saw you had a thread on bowlers (my favourite hat ever since I was a kid growing up in E. Washington and N. Idaho). I finally managed to acquire one and it is a Christys' black bowler (I've pondered a brown one for use with my brown tweed suits) which I wear with my navy and grey suits. I apologise for the poor picture quality and lighting but here is a photo:

newsuitandbowler.jpg


The curl reminds me quite a lot of Captain Mainwaring from Dad's Army (when he's in his banker's uniform) and the hat draws me a lot of compliments (and odd stares, I do live in the Seattle area and the combination of hat and three piece tweed suits does draw attention). Usually, it's quite positive since women will often say how nice the hat looks and once, whilst I was attending a Mass, a young woman and her mother remarked on how 'dapper' I looked. I should probably find more reasons to wear it!
 
Last edited:

newturnofphrase

One of the Regulars
Messages
251
Location
Canada
Hello everyone!

I'm a bit new here but I saw you had a thread on bowlers (my favourite hat ever since I was a kid growing up in E. Washington and N. Idaho). I finally managed to acquire one and it is a Christy's black bowler (I've pondered a brown one for use with my brown tweed suits) which I wear with my navy and grey suits.

The curl reminds me quite a lot of Captain Mainwaring from Dad's Army (when he's in his banker's uniform) and the hat draws me a lot of compliments (and odd stares, I do live in the Seattle area and the combination of hat and three piece tweed suits does draw attention). Usually, it's quite positive since women will often say how nice the hat looks and once, whilst I was attending a Mass, a young woman and her mother remarked on how 'dapper' I looked. I should probably find more reasons to wear it!

Is that a new Christys' Bowler (as in, not vintage)? I recently purchased a new one myself, I was really pleased with the stylish brim curl and the quality of the felt/brim binding. Looks great on you man! Bringing it back...
 

TheRomanhistorian

New in Town
Messages
7
Location
Renton, WA
Hi newturnofphrase,

It is indeed a new Christys . Whilst I can appreciate a vintage hat I am just not keen on wearing a vintage hat (I like the process of having it mould to my own head when new). I've had it for a year now and it is my most formal hat (I don't own a homburg yet nor would I have many occasions to wear it since most of my suits are tweed and I only have three city suits). I'm pondering a brown bowler from Christys, too but I have no clue how often I'd wear that. Still, how can one go wrong with more bowlers? :)
 
Last edited:

newturnofphrase

One of the Regulars
Messages
251
Location
Canada
Hi newturnofphrase,

It is indeed a new Christy's. Whilst I can appreciate a vintage hat I am just not keen on wearing a vintage hat (I like the process of having it mould to my own head when new). I've had it for a year now and it is my most formal hat (I don't own a homburg yet nor would I have many occasions to wear it since most of my suits are tweed and I only have three city suits). I'm pondering a brown bowler from Christy's, too but I have no clue how often I'd wear that. Still, how can one go wrong with more bowlers? :)

you can't. It is indeed a great hat, and I recommend it for anyone who has a larger head size and doesn't want to shell out for a hit-or-miss ebay hat. The felt is extremely stiff, and the style is as good as Lock at a fraction of the price. Another reason to get a new Christys Bowler is that it's a bit more contemporary looking with a low crown and small brim, than high crowned older styles.

Did you get the fur or the wool, and if the wool, how stiff is the felt? I got a fur felt one as the price difference was relatively minor and fur felt attracts less dust.
 

TheRomanhistorian

New in Town
Messages
7
Location
Renton, WA
I got the fur, if memory serves. I picked it up from a UK retailer online last year and it was a good stiff fur felt. I wonder what the difference is between the wool and fur felt. The retailer I purchased it from didn't really have any options besides fur felt (this was the standard model, not the Devon riding bowler which I hope to buy one day). I like the shorter crown, I've never been keen on some of the models with a very high crown.

I'll let you know if I pick up the brown Christys bowler. I believe that and the grey are wool felt and I've often wondered what the difference must feel like.
 
Last edited:

newturnofphrase

One of the Regulars
Messages
251
Location
Canada
I got the fur, if memory serves. I picked it up from a UK retailer online last year and it was a good stiff fur felt. I wonder what the difference is between the wool and fur felt. The retailer I purchased it from didn't really have any options besides fur felt (this was the standard model, not the Devon riding bowler which I hope to buy one day). I like the shorter crown, I've never been keen on some of the models with a very high crown.

I'll let you know if I pick up the brown Christy's bowler. I believe that and the grey are wool felt and I've often wondered what the difference must feel like.

My understanding (from reading about the difference and having owned both fur and wool felt hats) is that fur felt is denser and thus more durable and long lasting. It is also more aesthetically pleasing relative to wool, with a smoother finish.
 

RichardH

One of the Regulars
Messages
252
Location
Bergen, Norway
Here's my new Moores bowler hat, It's a size 7 1/2 & 1/16th (weird sizing), it's fairly rigid, you can dent the crown with some effort, but it's not as soft as the "fashion" bowlers we see today. Anyone got an idea about how old this one is?




The images are clickable..
 

RichardH

One of the Regulars
Messages
252
Location
Bergen, Norway
The "Tween" hat refers to the size being inbeTWEEN 7 1/2 and 7 5/8. This was a bit of a gimmick but it allowed them to sell a lot more hats. Your model looks like 1930s-1950s era. Try not to dent it at all, it's a Bowler!

Here's a link to some useful info I found on Moore's hats:
http://www.pittdixon.go-plus.net/denton/moores.htm

Thanks a lot! Heh, I may end up not keeping it, I want a smaller brimmed bowler. But since I just got it, I'm going to give it some time, maybe I'll feel different about it in a month.
 

bowlerman

I'll Lock Up
Messages
6,294
Location
South Dakota
My dark moss/ wide Petersham ribbon bowler (Baron Hats) was made for my buzzed head a few years ago, and all attempts to stretch it with a hat jack have ended up deforming the crown where the jack ends. I found this earlier today, and I have to say already that the wider form makes all the difference in the world!
0032copy.jpg
 

newturnofphrase

One of the Regulars
Messages
251
Location
Canada
Here's a Dunn & Co bowler I bought. It came yesterday in the mail. Took a gamble on this eBay sale as it didn't feature many photos and the description was sparse: http://www.ebay.com/itm/350511830577?ssPageName=STRK:MEWNX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1439.l2649#ht_852wt_1189

Glad I did, as it takes the cake as the best quality bowler I've owned or seen in person. I'm not sure of the date, but it's very fine, extremely high quality fur felt. Quite stiff felt, but also very light. The sweatband is magnificent. It was pretty dusty, but after I cleaned it off it appeared to be incredibly well made and in excellent condition, such that you can still see a slight spiral pattern to nap of the fur felt. Given the brim curl and crown height, I thought it might be from mid-20th century, but it might be later (definitely not earlier than the 1940s). Anyone know much about the changing Dunn labels? Anyway this one was clearly top of the line, and it fits quite comfortably on me at a British size 7 1/2 or 7 5/8 US.

dscn1473.jpg

dscn1495.jpg

dscn1496.jpg

lining-bowler.jpg
 
Last edited:

Forum statistics

Threads
109,253
Messages
3,077,324
Members
54,183
Latest member
UrbanGraveDave
Top