mikespens
Call Me a Cab
- Messages
- 2,913
- Location
- Tacoma, Wa
This comparison can only be described as drool worthy.
-
The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.
Side By Side/ Hat Comparisons
- Thread starter alanfgag
- Start date
Garrett
My Mail is Forwarded Here
- Messages
- 3,782
I concur :eusa_clap
Brad Bowers
I'll Lock Up
- Messages
- 4,187
As much as I love the blue Dobbs, the shade of green on that Mallory has me turning all shades of green with envy! That's just about the perfect green hat. Wow.
Brad
Brad
- Messages
- 15,060
- Location
- Buffalo, NY
Thanks... glad you enjoyed the side by side. The heather felt is good at masking minor stains such as drool. 
ManofKent
My Mail is Forwarded Here
- Messages
- 3,039
- Location
- United Kingdom
Thanks... glad you enjoyed the side by side. The heather felt is good at masking minor stains such as drool.
Good to know as I'm drooling too
randooch
I'll Lock Up
- Messages
- 4,869
- Location
- Ukiah, California
Mystic
Practically Family
- Messages
- 882
- Location
- Northeast Florida
Like the Sound of Music song, "Something Good" says....
Somewhere in my youth or childhood, I must have done something good.....
Alan, you must have done something REALLY good to acquire those hats, in that condition, in your size.....
Fantastic!! The blue Dobbs is my favorite....but, it would be tough to pick one if I had them in hand.
Somewhere in my youth or childhood, I must have done something good.....
Alan, you must have done something REALLY good to acquire those hats, in that condition, in your size.....
Fantastic!! The blue Dobbs is my favorite....but, it would be tough to pick one if I had them in hand.
g.durand
One Too Many
- Messages
- 1,896
- Location
- Down on the Bayou
These can't match Alan's rare showing today, but it's worth a comparison of two hats that are similar in many ways.
L: Stetson Stratoliner R: Borsalino, Alessandria style. There is nothing stamped on the sweat to indicate the model, but all indications are that's what it is. The Borso is lighter and the felt is just a bit thinner. The Strat has a reeded sweatband and the Borso is unreeded. They are very similar with regard to pliability and hand. Crown heights are very close, about 5 1/2-5 3/4 inches, brim widths are the same at 2 3/4 inches.
Top: Borsalino Bottom: Stratoliner
L: Stetson Stratoliner R: Borsalino, Alessandria style. There is nothing stamped on the sweat to indicate the model, but all indications are that's what it is. The Borso is lighter and the felt is just a bit thinner. The Strat has a reeded sweatband and the Borso is unreeded. They are very similar with regard to pliability and hand. Crown heights are very close, about 5 1/2-5 3/4 inches, brim widths are the same at 2 3/4 inches.
Top: Borsalino Bottom: Stratoliner
Last edited:
splintercellsz
I'll Lock Up
- Messages
- 6,140
- Location
- Somewhere in Time
Alan, absolutely gorgeous. That green is on point!
G, great post! Both hats are stunning
G, great post! Both hats are stunning
Mystic
Practically Family
- Messages
- 882
- Location
- Northeast Florida
Really nice pair of thin ribbons, GD
ManofKent
My Mail is Forwarded Here
- Messages
- 3,039
- Location
- United Kingdom
:arated:
- Messages
- 15,060
- Location
- Buffalo, NY
Very nice post, G.D... it would be a great comparison to expand to other manufacturers too.
- Messages
- 15,060
- Location
- Buffalo, NY
The Model T
The derby (bowler) hat might be compared to the Ford Model T. It was a style of universal acceptance, worn by every man as a civilian uniform during the era of the Model T (1908 to 1927). Any color you need, as long as it's black (not exactly, but close). If you've ever found a derby that fits you well, you know that it is a hat of uncommon comfort. No soft floppy parts to catch the wind, in fact a derby cuts through a stiff breeze without needing a wind cord to keep it from taking flight. A beautifully balanced design and a pleasure to wear.
I've owned quite a few - sold some, given others to my wife's costume shop. The five that remain in my collection are favorites and though only one is a perfect fit, I can wear them all. A quick glance shows them to be identical, but of course, in closer examination one can enjoy the subtle nuances of changing fashion. I've ordered this display by the amount of curl in the brim - from least to most. Dating is guesswork only, but I believe this order is roughly chronological as well. The first hat is the latest - 1930s somewhere and the last is the oldest - perhaps made near the introduction of the model T. The others are most likely from the 1920s. The Lord & Taylor private label has a 2 1/8" brim, the Brown & Batchelder 1 5/8". The others all sport a 1 7/8" brim. Crown heights on all are similar - close to 5". The early B&B has no ribbon bow and uses a different method of brim binding than the others. The C&K has a suspended sweatband design that is an inventive attempt to simplify a good fit in a hat that cannot be tweaked on a stretcher. But all in all, they follow a classic form that was a workhorse and worked beautifully.
The derby (bowler) hat might be compared to the Ford Model T. It was a style of universal acceptance, worn by every man as a civilian uniform during the era of the Model T (1908 to 1927). Any color you need, as long as it's black (not exactly, but close). If you've ever found a derby that fits you well, you know that it is a hat of uncommon comfort. No soft floppy parts to catch the wind, in fact a derby cuts through a stiff breeze without needing a wind cord to keep it from taking flight. A beautifully balanced design and a pleasure to wear.
I've owned quite a few - sold some, given others to my wife's costume shop. The five that remain in my collection are favorites and though only one is a perfect fit, I can wear them all. A quick glance shows them to be identical, but of course, in closer examination one can enjoy the subtle nuances of changing fashion. I've ordered this display by the amount of curl in the brim - from least to most. Dating is guesswork only, but I believe this order is roughly chronological as well. The first hat is the latest - 1930s somewhere and the last is the oldest - perhaps made near the introduction of the model T. The others are most likely from the 1920s. The Lord & Taylor private label has a 2 1/8" brim, the Brown & Batchelder 1 5/8". The others all sport a 1 7/8" brim. Crown heights on all are similar - close to 5". The early B&B has no ribbon bow and uses a different method of brim binding than the others. The C&K has a suspended sweatband design that is an inventive attempt to simplify a good fit in a hat that cannot be tweaked on a stretcher. But all in all, they follow a classic form that was a workhorse and worked beautifully.
Last edited:
- Messages
- 15,060
- Location
- Buffalo, NY
ManofKent
My Mail is Forwarded Here
- Messages
- 3,039
- Location
- United Kingdom
That's a great comparison Alan. It shows how a bowler is a bowler, but they're not all the same nicely
splintercellsz
I'll Lock Up
- Messages
- 6,140
- Location
- Somewhere in Time
Wonderful write up, Alan!!
- Messages
- 15,259
- Location
- Arlington, Virginia
Alan, that is a phenomenal post. Those bowlers are in excellent shape!
countryclubjoe
Banned
- Messages
- 1,184
- Location
- NJ/phila
WOW Alan, super!
I want a bowler in my collection and real soon.
Thank you and best regards.
CCJ
I want a bowler in my collection and real soon.
Thank you and best regards.
CCJ
TheDane
Call Me a Cab
- Messages
- 2,670
- Location
- Copenhagen, Denmark
Magnificent comparison - and not least hats! Great work, Alan. I so wish I had the testosterone factories to wear a bowler [huh]
- Messages
- 15,060
- Location
- Buffalo, NY
