Same Jacket Different Color Which One Would You Choose

[jonesy86]

Just curious, If you had to choose which jacket would you keep, black or brown?
I don't have many black jackets, and I think I like the brown one better, not sure why.

 

[ton312]

This is the absolute worst and I’ve faced this dilemma before myself. There is no right answer. But I’d keep (and prefer)the brown, particularly if they fit the same.

 

[photo2u]

What a beauty. I love old school brown jackets. But THAT black is quite something. My vote goes to brown.

 

[jonesy86]

This is the absolute worst and I’ve faced this dilemma before myself. There is no right answer. But I’d keep (and prefer)the brown, particularly if they fit the same.

Pretty much exact same fit. The black may be 1/2 inch longer and has no storm cuffs. I am considering removing the storm cuffs on the brown one anyway.

 

[nick123]

The answer is that whichever you decide to sell, PM me

 

[Leather Walker]

I'd go with the brown one. Both are beautiful, but the brown has more charm. Maybe I associate the style with the color, or it's just I don't have many brown jackets, so when I see a cool one, I really like.

 

[Guppy]

Brown.

 

[El Marro]

I would keep them both, not a doubt in my mind that that is the right answer.

 

[marker2037]

Brown is the right answer.

 

[JMax]

Both for sure. Keep’em and let the occasion and color of flip flop determine which you pick for the night.

Gun to my head— black. It’s the coolest, baddest color. Everyone knows that.

 

[Seank]

Oh man. I can never make these decisions. It’s why I have like 10 jackets in my closet and just ordered 2 more. I really need to thin the herd myself.
I am partial to black. If I only had 1 leather jacket, no question, it would be black.
But that style really looks great in brown. What are those…Aero original Hercules?
I think with regards to this style and if you have another black jacket in the quiver…I’d keep the brown.

 

[Monitor]

Black. Always. Not that I dislike brown - I often prefer it but black leather jacket is like an LBD; It's an essential piece, one that completes your entire wardrobe meaning you automatically have more ways to get more use out of a black jacket.

 

[jonesy86]

Oh man. I can never make these decisions. It’s why I have like 10 jackets in my closet and just ordered 2 more. I really need to thin the herd myself.
I am partial to black. If I only had 1 leather jacket, no question, it would be black.
But that style really looks great in brown. What are those…Aero original Hercules?
I think with regards to this style and if you have another black jacket in the quiver…I’d keep the brown.

They are GW Hercules.

 

[MrProper]

Brown or both

 

[Jin431]

brown seems right for this pattern and I think half belts in general.

 

[nickv]

brown seems right for this pattern and I think half belts in general.

i like both, but agree with Jin's comment above.

 

[Jimmy Shinki]

Keep both. If I had these two, I think my search would be over. Stunners.

 

[Carlos840]

Both for sure. Keep’em and let the occasion and color of flip flop determine which you pick for the night.

Gun to my head— black. It’s the coolest, baddest color. Everyone knows that.

This is the correct answer, keep both or keep the black one.

 

[Al 916]

'Leave the gun' but keep the brown Hercules

 

[Peacoat]

If you can keep both, do so. If not, I would go with the brown. Hard choice, though.