Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

moehawk

I'll Lock Up
Messages
5,841
Location
Northern California
I was so looking forward to receiving this one. Listed as a green 30's Penney's Marathon Extra Quality 7 3/8. It sat for over a month in my watch list, finally I ordered it after I let thst beat up Whippet go last week. It got here a few minutes ago, I pulled it out of the box only to find that it's a size 7.
:(
Here's pics anyway.

37dc32ddfc63b5bacaf7e8f2da447890.jpg
2c09fbbea31d1a49e97348e6c01e73bc.jpg
ff357720b191e11563ad50fa46a73817.jpg
22ca0c5aeb5a9627faa3028a0bfc3b97.jpg
b5deb0edc1e35e8dafcdf193f3a15884.jpg


I was so stoked to see the spiral stitched brim, then I put it on....sent in a return request. Hope it doesn't turn into a huge hassle.
 

ofcoursemyhorse

Practically Family
Messages
859
Location
United States
Thats a shame it ended up being so small. You might consider just putting it up for sale on the lounge though, its a beautiful old hat and i'm sure theres a size 7 on the lounge, myself included who'd happily take it off your hands.
 

Bob Roberts

I'll Lock Up
Messages
11,201
Location
milford ct
I was so looking forward to receiving this one. Listed as a green 30's Penney's Marathon Extra Quality 7 3/8. It sat for over a month in my watch list, finally I ordered it after I let thst beat up Whippet go last week. It got here a few minutes ago, I pulled it out of the box only to find that it's a size 7.
:(
Here's pics anyway.

37dc32ddfc63b5bacaf7e8f2da447890.jpg
2c09fbbea31d1a49e97348e6c01e73bc.jpg
ff357720b191e11563ad50fa46a73817.jpg
22ca0c5aeb5a9627faa3028a0bfc3b97.jpg
b5deb0edc1e35e8dafcdf193f3a15884.jpg


I was so stoked to see the spiral stitched brim, then I put it on....sent in a return request. Hope it doesn't turn into a huge hassle.
So sucks! I couldn't stand the let down which is exactly why I won't deal wit these A-holes.
 

Dlaniger

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,314
Location
Philadelphia PA
I was so looking forward to receiving this one. Listed as a green 30's Penney's Marathon Extra Quality 7 3/8. It sat for over a month in my watch list, finally I ordered it after I let thst beat up Whippet go last week. It got here a few minutes ago, I pulled it out of the box only to find that it's a size 7.
:(
Here's pics anyway.

37dc32ddfc63b5bacaf7e8f2da447890.jpg
2c09fbbea31d1a49e97348e6c01e73bc.jpg
ff357720b191e11563ad50fa46a73817.jpg
22ca0c5aeb5a9627faa3028a0bfc3b97.jpg
b5deb0edc1e35e8dafcdf193f3a15884.jpg


I was so stoked to see the spiral stitched brim, then I put it on....sent in a return request. Hope it doesn't turn into a huge hassle.
Wow size 7. That stinks. Hope you can return it!
 

40Cal

One Too Many
Messages
1,689
Location
California
I was so looking forward to receiving this one. Listed as a green 30's Penney's Marathon Extra Quality 7 3/8. It sat for over a month in my watch list, finally I ordered it after I let thst beat up Whippet go last week. It got here a few minutes ago, I pulled it out of the box only to find that it's a size 7.
:(
Here's pics anyway.

37dc32ddfc63b5bacaf7e8f2da447890.jpg
2c09fbbea31d1a49e97348e6c01e73bc.jpg
ff357720b191e11563ad50fa46a73817.jpg
22ca0c5aeb5a9627faa3028a0bfc3b97.jpg
b5deb0edc1e35e8dafcdf193f3a15884.jpg


I was so stoked to see the spiral stitched brim, then I put it on....sent in a return request. Hope it doesn't turn into a huge hassle.
That's a cool hat Moe.... I love the concentric stitching. How disappointing.... sorry man. Looking at the listing I would guess the mis-measurement was an honest mistake. He's probably not a hat guy.I doubt you will have any trouble returning it.
 

moehawk

I'll Lock Up
Messages
5,841
Location
Northern California
Thanks for the sympathy, guys. It is a mega bummer. I had wanted a spiral-stitch for a while, seeing it on this hat just made it worse.
Yeah, the upsizing was just a thought, although my old Young's was a 7 and my OR was a 6 7/8, the Young's was thrashed and the OR is a late 60's. This one is just too old and in nice shape to take apart. If the seller balks I'll just try selling it here.
 

Knotten

Practically Family
Messages
829
Location
Salt Lake City
My new Stetson Stetsonian arrived today. Kudos to Delmonico Hatters for good service. They made it a long oval, as I requested, and the fit is perfect.

Hat1.jpg

Hat2.jpg
The felt was a bit stiffer and thicker than I had expected, much more so than the Premier Stratoliner I bought last year. It took a bit of work with a steam kettle to get it to take shape. I stuck a quick version of a diamond bash in it.

Hat3.jpg
This is a good, substantial hat with classic proportions. I like it a lot.

Hat5.jpg
Hat6.jpg
 

Knotten

Practically Family
Messages
829
Location
Salt Lake City
Thanks, Bama. This hat feels like it would stand up well to bad weather. I may try it out in the snow we're expecting tomorrow.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Dlaniger

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,314
Location
Philadelphia PA
My new Stetson Stetsonian arrived today. Kudos to Delmonico Hatters for good service. They made it a long oval, as I requested, and the fit is perfect.

View attachment 42103

View attachment 42104
The felt was a bit stiffer and thicker than I had expected, much more so than the Premier Stratoliner I bought last year. It took a bit of work with a steam kettle to get it to take shape. I stuck a quick version of a diamond bash in it.

View attachment 42105
This is a good, substantial hat with classic proportions. I like it a lot.

View attachment 42106
View attachment 42107
Congratulations! That Stetsonian is a real big, thick, strong hat. I got one from Delmonico last year and it took me a long time to work it and block it to satisfaction. It looks great on you! Enjoy....
Dlan


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Dlaniger

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,314
Location
Philadelphia PA
Adding to the new hat Stetson hit parade, my new lid arrived this afternoon as well. I was looking to replace a hat that I passed on to my lawyer and life long buddy some years ago. It was a common Caribou Temple. While surfing the web, much to my surprise, I found that Stetson made the exact same hat in beaver felt. They named the beaver version the "Pinnacle"
0957e6b96379195bc11601af1dcf109a.jpg
3dc02433ba838b6a7cdd6f79e46c4d98.jpg
2e5aa58d0fac3771bb091fd04b30519f.jpg
7d6fc8522a11cbfd34b87f57dc42b08d.jpg

224cb87e2f60a74065da2bca82bcb86f.jpg

The beaver is very nice. I am quite impressed with the weight and general construction of this hat. A nice upgrade to an old standard.
9aaedc9e02f2deca12d999e6439acbe7.jpg
939deb7d4347f2b555fc44f5b28f7fd0.jpg
014733392c98c99dd5f1bf58eea2b3a2.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,249
Messages
3,077,283
Members
54,183
Latest member
UrbanGraveDave
Top