-
The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.
Goodwear Jackets why the attraction
- Thread starter jonbuilder
- Start date
Brettafett
One Too Many
- Messages
- 1,353
- Location
- UK
I'm one of those passionate guys... But honestly, if you are a 38 or 40, get one of Platon's Dubows. I wear a 40 long ELC and GW, a 42 original and funny enough... a 42 in Platon's Dubow and BK's A-2s (Dubow and Roughwear). My Dubow from Platon sits side-by-side with any GW I have owned.
jchance
A-List Customer
- Messages
- 334
- Location
- Los Angeles
Could someone help me understand why GW preowned’s command such a higher price compared to those of LW, Aero, Eastman, or Johnson Leather of SF, for example?
Canuck Panda
I'll Lock Up
- Messages
- 4,713
GW jackets are rare. And they're good.
I paid similar price for my used GW and LW, around 1300 from the classifieds. I would do it again for both. If you are size 38 look for LW jackets on the Japanese used market, great deals there, but no big sizes, and no newer models.
At 1300 I would get the Johnson brand new and that money can also get a brand new Aero. Don't know about Eastman, the opportunity never came up, they also seem to increase the price too fast and too much, used to be around Aero price and now pushing RMC pricing, product didn't really change did it?
I paid similar price for my used GW and LW, around 1300 from the classifieds. I would do it again for both. If you are size 38 look for LW jackets on the Japanese used market, great deals there, but no big sizes, and no newer models.
At 1300 I would get the Johnson brand new and that money can also get a brand new Aero. Don't know about Eastman, the opportunity never came up, they also seem to increase the price too fast and too much, used to be around Aero price and now pushing RMC pricing, product didn't really change did it?
jchance
A-List Customer
- Messages
- 334
- Location
- Los Angeles
I’m indeed a size 38, 5’ 8 1/2 at 150 lbs, 17.75” shoulder, 38 chest, 31 waist, 15/33 shirt. I like Cossack/a1/37j1 style (button only, no zipper) and want it in a veg-tanned lighter hide, preferably unlined. The RTW options (mister freedom campus/randall, RMC dillinger) seem pretty boxy/look like bat wings with short arms, but I like a tailored slim fit with high armholes (like how a TOJ/Falco Garments jacket fit). Should I just go with GW to get the fit right, or what are my other options (I’m good with preowned for a better deal)?
Last edited:
I am not sure that GW will offer you the fit you are after.
I only ever owned one of their jackets (bought used), and I found the cut pretty boxy, with low armholes. My attempt on discussing a custom fit failed with John consequentely ignoring my attempts at making contact (others seem to be more lucky, though).
In any event, I´d try to buy used first, instead of investing a chunk of money and unforseeable time (which may wary between 3 month and nothing after 5+ years) in a product that may not be to your liking eventually.
I myself go OTR whenever I can, and there are many makers out there with slim patterns and high armholes. As for the Coassack style, I recommend having a look at Thedi leathers. You being based in the US, why don´t you have a look at the Thurston Bros. website. They offer pre-fabricated Thedis (basically OTR) and ca sort you out should you want to go custom in the end.
I used to recommend Himel Bros. too. Their Cossack is called the "Heron" and offers a wide range of stunning hides and a great silhouette. However, Dave´s conduct re unhappy customers has been so bizarre lately, that I find it too much of an adventure, paying over USD 2.5k. I´d still maintain that his jackets are tops if the stars aline, and I am a happy customer of his.
Here´s my Thedi...
Attachments
- Messages
- 16,843
What's the wait on these now?
jchance
A-List Customer
- Messages
- 334
- Location
- Los Angeles
A week ago, John told me 12-14 months but I’ve read recent stories of 3-5 years
Brandrea33
One Too Many
- Messages
- 1,091
Canuck Panda
I'll Lock Up
- Messages
- 4,713
Take the private elevator and go straight to the penthouse:
About 750 landed, add another 250 for getting all new knits, it should be about a grand, for a like new condition FW. This particular jacket has a bit more taper down to the waist than the other type A-1.
https://item.rakuten.co.jp/goldragstation/rc_itedgnnkc3k1_r1fk/
jchance
A-List Customer
- Messages
- 334
- Location
- Los Angeles
Thanks, I’ll consider that FW and do some research.
I was looking at this LW jacket for about $230, but it being chrome-tanned means I’d never see any patina in my lifetime. I also heard about LW’s tube-arm issue.
https://page.auctions.yahoo.co.jp/jp/auction/d1094869307
Canuck Panda
I'll Lock Up
- Messages
- 4,713
I got a LW A2 used from Japan. They run a size smaller. And the hides were thinner than the current LW stuff, a bit different finishing too. But the value (return on $) is right up there. I do think given your measurements and weight you also need a 40 in the LW. There are a lot of good deals on them on the Japan used market.
2nd street take crappy photos. you can blow up my LW A2 to see the leather. I think it's the same as the A1 youre looking at. They're pigment finished and there is a squeak.
morrison2951
Practically Family
- Messages
- 688
- Location
- F-V, NC
I've got one GW, and it's a rare Admiral Byrd beauty. It's a keeper.
El Marro
My Mail is Forwarded Here
- Messages
- 3,602
- Location
- California
Give him a call and send an email every day until you get on his radar And he responds. I have had four jackets made for me by John since 2018 and the average wait time was around 14 months. The trick is to get his attention and once you get the ball rolling things happen pretty fast if he has the leather you want to work with in hand.What sorcery did you perform?!?
My Hercules deposit was made in 2018.
Brandrea33
One Too Many
- Messages
- 1,091
I’m not sure … lol.What sorcery did you perform?!?
My Hercules deposit was made in 2018.
I just placed the order on line and he acknowledged receipt with a brief note saying thanks and that it would be between 12-14 months. I followed up with an email at about the 12 month mark and he replied saying he was ready to begin. We had a telephone conversation the next day and voila.
What sorcery did you perform?!?
My Hercules deposit was made in 2018.
John used to send me emails about developments with his Hercules pattern. I was with him when he bought the original from Damian Monsivais at Inspiration, so I don't know how I might have "fallen off the radar". Honestly, I have bigger issues in my life at the moment, and I really don't care about leather jackets right now... but, still...
Bfd70
I'll Lock Up
- Messages
- 4,327
- Location
- Traverse city
Thedi
Featured products
-
Alden 403 Moc Toe Boot - Brown Chromexcel - $680 The classic "Indy" style Alden Boot in the classic Horween brown Chromexcel. -
Grant Stone Diesel Boot Dark Olive Chromexcel - #395 Goodyear welted, Horween Chromexcel, classic good looks. -
Himel Bros. - The Ross Mk. 1 Leather Jacket Classic D-pocket motorcycle/aviator style jacket.
El Marro
My Mail is Forwarded Here
- Messages
- 3,602
- Location
- California
I’m sure it is not personal, if you know John then you know that he is one of the nicest people out there. I did find in my dealings with him though that he always had too much on his plate and the squeaky wheel gets the oil, or the attention in this case.
On another note, I own one of his Hercules jackets and it is my least favorite, and least comfortable to wear. If I were you, I would have him build your jacket off the Ventura pattern and incorporate the Hercules details you like into the jacket. It will still look like a Hercules, but it will actually be a pleasure to wear.
