Gable vs. Bogart

[MissAmelina]

Bogart.....even though I find Gable charming. To me, Bogart has greater sex appeal and is more exciting to watch.
I also read that Gable's dentures always smelled really bad and Vivian Leigh had problems kissing him during GWTW. ewww......[huh] That sealed the deal for me.
Bogart's eyes make my tummy flip.

 

[Tomasso]

I also read that Gable's dentures always smelled really bad and Vivian Leigh had problems kissing him during GWWW. ewww......[huh]

That's unfounded gossip. She actually stated that she greatly enjoyed kissing, hugging and humping him. (She was a nympho after all)

 

[HadleyH]

He was rough, he was sexy, he was the working class hero during the Depression years. There is a ... greatness ,lurking somewhere in Gable that never fails to impress me! [huh]

 

[MissAmelina]

That's unfounded gossip. She actually stated that she greatly enjoyed kissing, hugging and humping him. (She was a nympho after all)

You just said HUMPING! lol Sorry.....very tired. Potty humor is making my giggle. Sleepy time!

 

[Tomasso]

Humphrey and Clark:

Studs..................lol

 

[dr greg]

All pro

OK Bogart played it tougher, but he was limited, Gable could do it all

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ACGHxR7pH_c

 

[HadleyH]

OMG Tomasso!!!!! Why do you love posting that horrible thing/ photo of Clark Gable? Nooooooooooo :rage:

This photo taken very close in time to the horror photo you posted, well, this is how he really looked!!!!!!! Get that in your mind Tomasso please! lol lol

 

[Tomasso]

Don't get so excited, Had.

 

[HadleyH]

Don't get so excited, Had.

Who's excited? Moi?

You don't know what excited means then Tomasso! lol

 

[Tomasso]

Happy now?

 

[HadleyH]

^
^
^
Yes I am!
Thank you Tomasso!

 

[Grant Fan]

Oh goodness that is hard to say, I love them both, and they are in my favorite movies, so that makes it even harder. When I was 18 I named my parents dog Bogart, and when I get my own dog I intend to name him Rhett, because I don't like Clark or Gable for a dogs name. So honestly they are tied, but they can't beat Cary Grant [huh] .

 

[MissAmelina]

Studs..................lol

LOL LOL LOL. Thank you thank you. Oh my gosh my stomach hurts. Those are awesome, seriously.

 

[John in Covina]

Bogart wins for me as he seems to be an ordinary man that becomes extraordinary in response to what has to be done.

Gable seems a bit more rarified personality that doesn't seem to reach to become more.

 

[Benny Holiday]

Bogie. His screen persona comes across as tough, street-smart, down-to-earth, and cool. And the way he wore a Fedora . . . :arated:

 

[cecil]

This one is really hard for me because I love them both. I loved Gable as Rhett, no one better could have played that character in my opinion but when I look over their acting careers as a whole and not just on one particular performance, I am going with Bogart.

.

I reckon Coop would have made a good Rhett. Pity he turned it down, the silly bugger.

I'm going with Bogart too. Something about Gable irks me. Too smarmy.

 

[scotrace]

Yeah, but Lombard had quite a mouth on her...

Yes. She was great fun!

I like both these guys too much to choose. But if I had to pick either Gable or Bogart, I'd pick Grant.

 

[Brian Sheridan]

I used to be of the "always Bogart - never Gable" camp until I started watching some of his MGM work from the 1930's. My recollection was that Gable only make period films which I don't like. After seeing films like Too Hot To Handle, I
began to more appreciate Gable and his ability to do comedy.

It is hard for me now to say who is better Gable or Bogie.

I agree with Scot though - Grant over both of them.

 

[Elizabeth.F]

I'm 100% for Bogart.

 

[topango]

No matter what the game... Bogart wins