Doctor Strange
I'll Lock Up
- Messages
- 5,246
- Location
- Hudson Valley, NY
I finally saw Red Tails on a library DVD. Though kind of a mess, it was nowhere near the Pearl Harbor-level abomination I was expecting.
Yes, the old HBO film The Tuskegee Airmen did a much better job telling the dramatic story. Yes, an awful lot of the dialog and performances reflected attitudes that were far too contemporary. Yes, the continual dogfights with the same German flier "Pretty Boy" were absurd. Yes, some of the subplots (the POW sequence, the romance with the Italian woman) were so undercooked they seemed like mistakes. Yes, in general the writing/acting/direction were much weaker than the production design, CGI, and effects work.
I constantly had the feeling that the film's storyboards were probably better than the film itself: it played much more like a silver age comic book than a movie. This isn't necessarily a bad thing, but they could have aimed a lot higher.
Of course, the P-40s, P-51s, A-2s, B-10s, etc., were all gorgeous!
Yes, the old HBO film The Tuskegee Airmen did a much better job telling the dramatic story. Yes, an awful lot of the dialog and performances reflected attitudes that were far too contemporary. Yes, the continual dogfights with the same German flier "Pretty Boy" were absurd. Yes, some of the subplots (the POW sequence, the romance with the Italian woman) were so undercooked they seemed like mistakes. Yes, in general the writing/acting/direction were much weaker than the production design, CGI, and effects work.
I constantly had the feeling that the film's storyboards were probably better than the film itself: it played much more like a silver age comic book than a movie. This isn't necessarily a bad thing, but they could have aimed a lot higher.
Of course, the P-40s, P-51s, A-2s, B-10s, etc., were all gorgeous!
