Aside from the color, though, that hat DOES seem to be close to what I outlined in my description. That price seems unreasonable, and I've heard too many horror stories about Baron Hats to even consider them.
Thanks for the link, though. I recall this hat in particular being the one that got me interested in western hats in the first place, though I was never crazy about the brown color. I've got some thinking to do!
If you don't like that color, and you want a curled brim, model it after this one.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0b5cd/0b5cd9b5cea4c5d9da1d46276ec43186301a4dc2" alt="good-bad-ugly.jpg"
This is just about what you described.