I clean my face without any tensides at all, using alternately Lush's "Angels on Bare Skin" and Dr. Hauschka's "Cleansing Cream". It was one of the best decisions I made concerning skincare.
Before that I used cleansers with organic ingredients, based on mild tensides made of coconut or sugar. But even those were too drying for my skin and it produced more and more oil (and therefore impurities) to compensate. It was like a vicious circle.
Concerning the use of soap, I'd say: Go for it! Look for a hand-crafted soap with lots of cold-pressed vegetable oils, maybe from your local Whole Foods Market. I'd look for one that has a certain amount of oil which is not saponified (maybe an oil surplus of about 10%).
Oh, and to answer your question: I guess, soap has got such a bad name as a facial cleanser today, because many soaps are fabricated in mass production and contain cheap oils. Plus, the positive effect of pH-balanced products is overrated and good ol' soap has been stigmatized as something old-fashioned and unhandy.
Before that I used cleansers with organic ingredients, based on mild tensides made of coconut or sugar. But even those were too drying for my skin and it produced more and more oil (and therefore impurities) to compensate. It was like a vicious circle.
Concerning the use of soap, I'd say: Go for it! Look for a hand-crafted soap with lots of cold-pressed vegetable oils, maybe from your local Whole Foods Market. I'd look for one that has a certain amount of oil which is not saponified (maybe an oil surplus of about 10%).
Oh, and to answer your question: I guess, soap has got such a bad name as a facial cleanser today, because many soaps are fabricated in mass production and contain cheap oils. Plus, the positive effect of pH-balanced products is overrated and good ol' soap has been stigmatized as something old-fashioned and unhandy.