Some opinion needed.

[handymike]

No, just a little long IMHO

 

[Sloan1874]

I'd go with the strap, anything else will look odd, imho.

 

[thor]

I'd go with the strap, anything else will look odd, imho.

+1

 

[ProteinNerd]

Could they just replace the entire sleeve at a reasonable cost?

 

[zhz]

Could they just replace the entire sleeve at a reasonable cost?

They could replace the entire sleeve, but the cost is high, according to Andy, the sleeves contribute 40% of the jacket, so you can image the cost.