Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Shaving brush

What type of shaving brush do you recommend?

  • Badger bristle

    Votes: 20 80.0%
  • Boar bristle

    Votes: 5 20.0%
  • Synthetic bristle

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    25

Mid-fogey

Practically Family
Messages
720
Location
The Virginia Peninsula
Think...

dhermann1 said:
Yes, that really makes a difference. I have to confess that there is one nagging thought about the badger in the back of my mind. The badgers all come from China. Now I've read that they use the whole badger, not just the fur. But the Chinese are infamous for unspeakably cruel methods of killing fur animals. Just saying. If they're trapped wild it's probaby some sort of quick kill. But if they're farmed, well I don't wanna know.

...they make them listen to rap?
 
Hercule said:
One review I read likened badger bristle to a mop.

This has had me stumped since I read it a couple days ago. In what way/sense was badger bristle compared to a mop? What point was the "reviewer" trying to make? That it holds water (good for lathering) and the water is quite easy to get out (good for storage)? It seems like such a weird comparison.

bk

p.s. I don't know that I know enough to recommend it, but I use a badger bristle brush.
 

Edward

Bartender
Messages
25,111
Location
London, UK
dhermann1 said:
Yes, that really makes a difference. I have to confess that there is one nagging thought about the badger in the back of my mind. The badgers all come from China. Now I've read that they use the whole badger, not just the fur. But the Chinese are infamous for unspeakably cruel methods of killing fur animals. Just saying. If they're trapped wild it's probaby some sort of quick kill. But if they're farmed, well I don't wanna know.

The hair used in badger brushes does indeed come from the Asian badger, which is not endangered, and which is, as you are aware, used as a food source, making the hair a by product which would otherwise be wasted, as opposed to the animal being killed for the hair. I did do some asking around on this issue myself before I bought one. My brush is made in England, and all vendors I queried insisted that there are very strict rules on the import of animal products to England, requiring that the animal has not been treated cruelly. Not sure how they guarantee this, mind. I have a badger and a "pure bristle" (which I think is boar). The badger is by far superior; the bristle I use as a travelling brush and it's fine enough for that.
 

Hercule

Practically Family
Messages
953
Location
Western Reserve (Cleveland)
I can only surmise that he felt it became over saturated with lather and simply slid around like a mop, consequently he preferred a boar bristle brush. From an amazon review: "I used the badger-hair shaving brushes but found they turned into a mop rather than a brush. Bristle works the cream around the base of the hair better as it's a bit stiffer. Nothing remarkable about this particular brush except it's a good brush at a good price."
 

Ed13

Familiar Face
Messages
65
Location
Toronto
I used a boar brush many years ago and once I switched to badger I never switched back. I have 10 or eleven in search for my most preferred.

The lower grade badger brushes will often feel firmer (stiffer) than the best silver tip but may not hold as much water. It also won't feel as smooth and gentle to the skin.

The density of the bristles will also make a big difference. The more dense the bristles are packed the firmer the brush might feel. If the brush is too dense it could become more difficult to load with soap.

The shorter the bristle length the firmer the brush will feel. Longer bristles can feel floppy on your face. This may be the "mop" effect alluded to earlier.

The shape of the bristles is also a factor. A bulb shape will feel firmer while a fan shape may feel more floppy. This is mostly due to the shorter bristle length on the outside of the brush with the bulb shape but it is an easily seen distinction.

The ideal brush is different for everyone. There are many characteristics to consider with the bristles. Don't forget to also consider the handle shape. We all have different size and shapes to our hands and a comfortable brush will increase the pleasure of shaving.
 

Highlander

A-List Customer
Messages
473
Location
Missouri
Shaving Brushes

I am a fan of Badger Bristle Brushes. For years I purchased Boar Bristle brushes, also thinking I liked the "firmer" bristles, and they were considerably cheaper. Mostly I'd purchased cheaper brushes from the drug store etc. Then I found Col. Conk, and really like their products. A photo of my brushes, many from over the last 30 or so years of shaving. The Badger brushes are the darker bristles on the right (with the exception of the one that matches my shaving mug, it's Boar)...
ShavingBrushes-vi.jpg


About once a month I take my good brush (the one in front with the black handle fuller head of bristles) and clean it good with Borax.. I then fill it with Borax and let it set over night then rinse it out. It cleans out all of the soap scum that does build up. I find that the brushes last a considerable time if you really take care of them.
 

Chainsaw

Suspended
Messages
392
Location
Toronto
I'm new to this, but I use badger. I prefer to use the least amount of water as possible to make a thicker foam, with my col. Conk cake.
 

Undertow

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,126
Location
Des Moines, IA, US
Baron Kurtz said:
This has had me stumped since I read it a couple days ago. In what way/sense was badger bristle compared to a mop? What point was the "reviewer" trying to make? That it holds water (good for lathering) and the water is quite easy to get out (good for storage)? It seems like such a weird comparison.

bk

p.s. I don't know that I know enough to recommend it, but I use a badger bristle brush.

They must mean because badger is softer, it's necessarily more pliable and less like a toothbrush against your skin. [huh]

I prefer badger over boar, and I do own both. Badger is softer, and if you're doing it right, the stiffness shouldn't necessarily be an issue so much as water retention. I can understand if you like the feel of a stiffer bristle - that's subjective. But otherwise, badger is better and most definitely holds more water.
 

Feraud

Bartender
Messages
17,188
Location
Hardlucksville, NY
The lather ends up in the bowl and can be applied well enough with a boar brush. It is in the making of the lather where the differences in boar and badger appear.
 

fiddletown

New in Town
Messages
48
Location
California - S. F. Bay Area
Actually, according to the makers of the brushes I've been using for the last 40 years, I'm using badger hair, not badger bristle. I favor silver tip badger and have just treated myself to a new Plisson brush made from what they call high mountain white badger. I bought a Plisson brush in Paris in 1979 and used it until about five years ago. The then went to a brush by Kent of London, which has been excellent. I just decided it was time for another Plisson.
 

Swamp_Fox

New in Town
Messages
44
Location
Indiana/Kentucky
I started out with a boar bristle brush and soon switched to badger. It's an Art of Shaving brush--can't remember what model. I've been using it for over a year and have been very happy with it.

I have a pretty coarse, thick beard and I've still found the badger to be much better than boar bristle.
 

JimWagner

Practically Family
Messages
946
Location
Durham, NC
I have all three kinds of shaving brush and prefer and usually use the badger. The boar is ok, but as others have noted a little stiffer. I really don't care much for the synthetic brushes I've tried. Maybe one day they'll make a satisfactory synthetic one, but as long as my boar brush continues to hold up there's really no incentive for me to try another one.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,638
Messages
3,085,450
Members
54,453
Latest member
FlyingPoncho
Top