Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Repro 1930s Sears Original Hercules jackets; whose is best?

Whose is the best Sears Original Hercules repro?


  • Total voters
    69

schitzo

Suspended
Messages
1,472
Location
London
Thanks zhz, obviously I respect Chinese law and so am not using freegate myself. But FWIW I hear that one isn't so great and that people who have it still can't upload pics , or even view them half the time.
 

Sloan1874

I'll Lock Up
Messages
8,427
Location
Glasgow

bretron

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,519
Location
NW
Going with BK. Really dig how they went to such lengths with the accuracy. Including the trademark infringing label :D

I like how they did with a civvy jacket what other makers do with A2s.
 

ProteinNerd

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,902
Location
Sydney
Without knowing exactly what makes one Hercules jacket more accurate than another hercules jacket, I think the pictures of the GW show the jacket off better and it looks better (or more appealing too me) so my vote goes for that one.
 
Messages
11,164
Location
SoCal
OriginalHerc1.jpg
 

nick123

I'll Lock Up
Messages
6,371
Location
California
And here's the original:

If that's the original Aero did a nice job. Their take captures the spirit of that jacket. On the site I remember reading they recommended getting the Hercules with tumbled black horsehide. Probably because it looks like this!
 

tropicalbob

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,954
Location
miami, fl
I had to go for the Aero: first, because I drool over that jacket on a daily basis and, second, because somewhere in the back of my mind I honestly believe that one day Holly and/or Ken (we wear the same size) will remember all the nice things I've said about them and send me a free one.
 

BuzzTheTower

New in Town
Messages
39
Location
Seattle, WA
Gents,

The Good Wear copy is definitely not an accurate version of the originals we handled. I actually didn't like the original pattern very much. The details are a lot of fun, and I like the cloth rain flap on the back of the inner side of the collar. But, if you look at this size 46 original, it's got a very strange pattern. It may be that it's a big version of a jacket that looks better in a size 38, but on me, this wasn't a very flattering jacket. So, I chose to use a pattern that I like much more.

Original_Hercules.jpg

Hercules_Label.jpg

Also, the jacket was definitely made by Monarch Mfg. of Milwaukee, WI. They had about 400 employees in 1939, and this jacket would have been a contract from Sear-Roebuck. I wonder if other companies had been contracted to make the jacket as well, as we do see differences, or if Monarch was the sole contractor.

This pocket tag is only seen on Monarch jackets. Obviously, I have no legal right to use the name Sears-Roebuck, and I like the Californian label more anyway.

Hercules_Tags.jpg

It's a very cool jacket, but to me, the pattern left some to be desired. I'm very thankful to the fellow who sent me the original to copy (yes, I did take a pattern from it). He is a master of original jackets.

p.s. - I didn't vote!
 

zhz

Practically Family
Messages
890
Location
China, London and Coventry UK
Gents,

The Good Wear copy is definitely not an accurate version of the originals we handled. I actually didn't like the original pattern very much. The details are a lot of fun, and I like the cloth rain flap on the back of the inner side of the collar. But, if you look at this size 46 original, it's got a very strange pattern. It may be that it's a big version of a jacket that looks better in a size 38, but on me, this wasn't a very flattering jacket. So, I chose to use a pattern that I like much more.

View attachment 19986

View attachment 19987

Also, the jacket was definitely made by Monarch Mfg. of Milwaukee, WI. They had about 400 employees in 1939, and this jacket would have been a contract from Sear-Roebuck. I wonder if other companies had been contracted to make the jacket as well, as we do see differences, or if Monarch was the sole contractor.

This pocket tag is only seen on Monarch jackets. Obviously, I have no legal right to use the name Sears-Roebuck, and I like the Californian label more anyway.

View attachment 19988

It's a very cool jacket, but to me, the pattern left some to be desired. I'm very thankful to the fellow who sent me the original to copy (yes, I did take a pattern from it). He is a master of original jackets.

p.s. - I didn't vote!

Thanks for sharing John, I think that original just looks big on you, otherwise, it looks amazing.
 

Sloan1874

I'll Lock Up
Messages
8,427
Location
Glasgow
It looks lovely, but the pockets on GW's are on the large side and slightly awkwardly placed for my taste .
 

tmitchell59

I'll Lock Up
Messages
7,747
Location
Illinois
Also, the jacket was definitely made by Monarch Mfg. of Milwaukee, WI. They had about 400 employees in 1939, and this jacket would have been a contract from Sear-Roebuck. I wonder if other companies had been contracted to make the jacket as well, as we do see differences, or if Monarch was the sole contractor.

that is interesting. I have thought about the makers of all these store labeled jackets, Sears, Penneys, Wards. There is a huge variety, styles. I have a 40s Hercules labeled long coat with the makers label, A Pritzker and Sons. I don't see many tags or markings on most. I have a couple of Monarch sport jackets, they are very nice.
 

schitzo

Suspended
Messages
1,472
Location
London
p.s. - I didn't vote!


That's dignified. But it seems you don't need any extra votes.

For me this is an interesting poll and what it shows if nothing else, is that this type of poll absolutely has to be public. This way you can see who has voted twice for their own jacket for example! You can also see and subtract from the final total votes that you know to be completely partisan. In addition, you can see who has actually opened an account just to cast a vote!
 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,248
Messages
3,077,241
Members
54,183
Latest member
UrbanGraveDave
Top