tropicalbob
My Mail is Forwarded Here
- Messages
- 3,954
- Location
- miami, fl
My father was with the very first USMC communications units to land on Japanese soil. They had very strict orders not to harass the natives in any way. Despite this, he found a couple of his guys (he was a sergeant in charge of the unit) calling and harassing the locals and he had to discipline them. He told me there was a lot of bad feeling about it, as they had served together on Okinawa and in other combat zones and the men felt they were just getting a little of their own back. He thought that orders were orders and, besides, it was a matter of honor. That was his number one consideration in life. He was an ungodly pain in the ass, but an honorable one.@Edward, interesting post. I always find re-enactment/living history of things within living memory to be somewhat in poor taste. WWI living history without the trench foot and rats, just for one night? WWII living history; well no one wants to reenact the people interned in concentration camps.
It's all just a big excuse for dressing up really, and then creating systems to rationalize that IMHO. By contrast, we have good Roman records of how the Roman Army was equipped and operated on the march, so reenacting that could have value since we could learn something that wasn't recorded and no one is alive to tell us.
But our records of modern conflicts are complete enough with first hand accounts that I doubt there is anything to be learned by trying to 'live' the less dangerous parts of it for 48 hours or so.
@rocketeer, that's also a good post. A few years ago I researched crimes reported during the first six months of the US occupation, and compared them to crimes in Kobe after the massive earthquake there, and found that the corresponding increase in reported rapes was staggering. It didn't seem to be so much about race or culture or winning the war, but opportunity. When the lights go out, the veneer of civilization vanishes, and your neighbors will do terrible things to you. AND society will deny your experience and create 'we all stuck together myths' so they don't have to look the problem in the face.
Speaking of the U.K. in WWII, there was that serial rapist/murderer. Tim Roth played him in a TV Mini-series, he was really nasty.