MrBern
I'll Lock Up
- Messages
- 4,469
Jovan said:Bern: Yes, I read that in Takei's biography. But he wasn't convinced that was really Shatner from his past experience with him (convincing directors to centre shots on him, cut out other expository stuff with other characters, etc.). He was more convinced that it was him acting like the nurturing, caring director for his own ends. Interesting how karma made it turn out to be the bad apple of the TOS movies. lol
New Voyages' and CBS Digital's presentations of the original Enterprise are far better than the attempts by Abrams' teams so far, IMHO. While I don't care for some of the acting in New Voyages -- not to mention the special effects shots in "In Harm's Way" -- they, overall, get the spirit of original Trek down really well.
Actually I heard Koenig bitch about it a lot.
The flip side of all this is...Shatner was the star of the show. Nimoy made a power play on the series, but the producers told them that Shatner had top billing.
So Shatner had a great sense of what made scenes work. And he wanted it all to revolve around Kirk as Hero.
Takei wanted his character written over to a new ship. Made no sense to SHatner to have Sulu elswhere. So he railed against that, probably not realizing that Takei was hoping for his own franchise.
And really, I dont doubt the reports that the directors jsut never felt confident in the co-stars to deliver more than a few lines.
But then again, in looking at how well MajellBarret didnt on ST:TNG, they have admitted that she had much more to work with & arose to the occasion.