Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Indiana Jones: Bane of Vintage Enthusiasts

Speedbird

A-List Customer
Messages
359
Location
London, UK
Mr E Train said:
Hey, Roy Rogers was real!

Sorry Mr E Train ... no disrespect intended ... I should have held at the Lone Ranger ... that'll teach me to be a smart alec!



PS I like your signature ... I've been wondering where it's from?
 

Speedbird

A-List Customer
Messages
359
Location
London, UK
Thanks Mr E Train!

My observation directly to the topic is that I am sure 'Indiana Jones' is at times a bane of vintage enthusiasts - just as 'Memphis Belle' is a bane to WW2 aviation enthusiasts and 'Titanic' is to Golden Age enthusisasts. I personally think that on balance it works out favourably on our side of the fence eventually.

Lord alone knows how many hats, jackets, DJ's, scarves and ball gowns might be in land fill tips if it wasn't for those movies making people stop and think that the old stuff in the attic might be worth saving.....

I got into wearing hats, trenchcoats, silk scarves, DJ's and detachable collar evening shirts from watching 'Casablanca' in my teens. I was a little unusual in northwest England in the 80's but oddly enough, I think it wasn't considered as unusual as might be today. Mind you, Britain was just emerging from Punk and the New Wave of British Heavy Metal and the New Romantic scene was flourishing - so my look was quite conservative!

The beauty of a forum like this is people will take inspiration from Hollywood and then develop a more accurate account from learning as they participate. So all hail the screen legends and welcome the opportunity to learn more and do it better!
 

Edward

Bartender
Messages
25,082
Location
London, UK
StetsonHomburg said:
Ha ha, Well.... At least Churchill is Real. :cool2:

And at least Indy, fictional or no, was a nice person - something to which Churchill can in no way lay claim. But that another argument for another day, suffice it to say I wear my Homergs despite, not because of, Churchill. ;)
 

Panache

A-List Customer
Messages
344
Location
California Bay Area
Speedbird said:
...The beauty of a forum like this is people will take inspiration from Hollywood and then develop a more accurate account from learning as they participate. So all hail the screen legends and welcome the opportunity to learn more and do it better!


B R A V O !!! :eusa_clap

Very well said

Cheers

Jamie
 

Yeps

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,456
Location
Philly
Edward said:
And at least Indy, fictional or no, was a nice person - something to which Churchill can in no way lay claim. But that another argument for another day, suffice it to say I wear my Homergs despite, not because of, Churchill. ;)

I got my homburg because of the new sherlock holmes movie, then realized he was not wearing a homburg, but the hat has stayed as my signature look anyway.
 

Mr E Train

One Too Many
Messages
1,050
Location
Terminus
Yeps said:
I got my homburg because of the new sherlock holmes movie, then realized he was not wearing a homburg, but the hat has stayed as my signature look anyway.

A homburg is definitely the type of hat I could see Holmes wearing, although I'm not sure if he ever did. What was he wearing in the movie, a bowler? I haven't seen it yet, although I want to. When the movie came out I was kind of ticked off that Downey Jr. wasn't wearing a deerstalker cap, but it was actually more faithful to the character for him not to, because Holmes only wore one on limited occasions, usually when out in the country.
 

Yeps

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,456
Location
Philly
Mr E Train said:
A homburg is definitely the type of hat I could see Holmes wearing, although I'm not sure if he ever did. What was he wearing in the movie, a bowler?

This was the subject of quite a debate (part of the reason I joined up on the lounge), because he appeared to be wearing a fedora which everyone said was too modern for the 1890s, but, it also kind of looked like a really beat up homburg which would have been period. However, a Montgomery Ward & co catalog popped up on another thread from 1890, and there was an illustration of a hat called "the Fedora" which looked just like Holmes's hat.
1890p278.jpg

Which is kinda cool, because that makes his costume possibly period.
sherlock_holmes_004.jpg


oh, and you should see the movie. The plot is a little lacking, but the characters and atmosphere are fantastic, even if Holmes is a bit scruffier than described.

sorry to hijack the thread, but this is kinda related.
 

cptjeff

Practically Family
Messages
564
Location
Greensboro, NC
According to behind the scenes info posted in the sherlock holmes thread, it's a Lock and Co homburg that was intentionally abused.
 

MisterCairo

I'll Lock Up
Messages
7,005
Location
Gads Hill, Ontario
Burton said:
MisterCairo, I get what you are saying and agree. This is a pertinent topic.

In 1982 I went on my first expedition to New Guinea. I wore a brown fedora type hat that was sold by the "old" Banana Republic company. Upon my return the hit movie playing that summer was Indiana Jones, Raiders of the Lost Ark. I was critical of the movie at that time but years and many more adventures of my own now love the IJ series. I have had moments though when I wish the movies had never been made like a trip to Petra years ago where I remember approaching a group of tourists and having then break into the IJ theme song. Good fun really.
:eusa_clap :eusa_clap :eusa_clap

There is good and bad in anything becoming "iconic". On the one hand, in this case the Indy movies showcased the styles of the 30s to a broad audience, many of whom joyously adopted the look.

On the other hand, it didn't become "the fashion", so to many the look looks like an affectation. Hence the Indy "name calling".
 

Speedbird

A-List Customer
Messages
359
Location
London, UK
MisterCairo said:
:eusa_clap :eusa_clap :eusa_clap

There is good and bad in anything becoming "iconic". On the one hand, in this case the Indy movies showcased the styles of the 30s to a broad audience, many of whom joyously adopted the look.

On the other hand, it didn't become "the fashion", so to many the look looks like an affectation. Hence the Indy "name calling".

I don't think the general public is that sophisticated. If they are deriding it as an affectation, they don't know that's what they are doing. It takes some knowledge to recognise and know what a particular look originates from and then to judge whether it is an affectation or not. Simply knowing a brown hat is from Indy isn't sufficient knowledge base to determine its origin and then whether it is an affectation or not. The person on the street who shouts "Indy" is working on a more primitive, uncontrolled base level of call and response. It's Pavlov's dogs - they just don't know it. If I wore a deer stalker and cape I would be labelled Sherlock. A bowler hat and a cigar - Winston. There's nothing wrong in that. It's human nature. We if anything are the odd ones because we study and love this stuff enough to know one brown hat from another, one leather jacket type from another; one cut of suit from another? I mean, honestly, who here knows anyone apart from their immediate pals in vintageness who could identify a 30's suit from a 40's suit by the cut of the lapel and shoulders? An A-2 from an A-1? A Correspondent from an Oxford? Ok, that last one is a bit extreme.

The Indy, Sherlock and Winston name callers just do it because they see an instant trigger and they feel like they want to share that out loud - and not always in a nasty way. It has been said many times, people go "hey Indy! Nice hat by the way" and they are sincere - if a little confused and socially challenged.

;)
 

MCrider

A-List Customer
Messages
360
Location
hills of West Virginia
cptjeff said:
Why not do it? If it's not to your liking you can change it back yourself, it's not as if it'll permanently damage the felt.

Maybe not if you steam your hats, but I have an older Stetson that was given the tight Indy crease and even though I keep working on it, the faint outline is still there. Yeah maybe if I wasn't so lazy or born all thumbs I could have it steamed and finished in an afternoon, but the forementioned affliction keeps me from trying that.
;)
 

Speedbird

A-List Customer
Messages
359
Location
London, UK
Yeps said:
I think that the thread on the subject established that it would be nearly impossible to take out the curl so completely.

That's interesting, I did think it looked a bit more like a couple of the other Lock & Co offerrings. The crown height and crease gives it a sense of a Homburg but.... anyway, obviously there's another thread to read; but I think it's fair to say we can add Sherlock to the name calling quite soon! lol

And I had my eye on a English made Black Poet too! :rolleyes:
 
Messages
17,524
Location
Maryland
Yeps said:
This was the subject of quite a debate (part of the reason I joined up on the lounge), because he appeared to be wearing a fedora which everyone said was too modern for the 1890s, but, it also kind of looked like a really beat up homburg which would have been period. However, a Montgomery Ward & co catalog popped up on another thread from 1890, and there was an illustration of a hat called "the Fedora" which looked just like Holmes's hat.
1890p278.jpg

This hat has a lot of curl. Similar to a Homburg but doesn't appear to have the typical height or taper of a period Homburg (see Edward VII). Not sure there was a strict definition for a Fedora (soft felt - less formal) or European styles didn't always translate properly across the pond.
 

Yeps

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,456
Location
Philly
mayserwegener said:
This hat has a lot of curl. Similar to a Homburg but doesn't appear to have the typical height or taper of a period Homburg (see Edward VII). Not sure there was a strict definition for a Fedora (soft felt - less formal) or European styles didn't always translate properly across the pond.
When I was looking at it, it looked like it would be more easy to abuse a hat of that shape and softness into the hat that Holmes wears then a homburg. Also, it is just cool because it is a hat called a fedora in 1890.
 
Messages
17,524
Location
Maryland
Yeps said:
When I was looking at it, it looked like it would be more easy to abuse a hat of that shape and softness into the hat that Holmes wears then a homburg. Also, it is just cool because it is a hat called a fedora in 1890.

Both Homburgs and Fedoras go back farther than the 1890s. Both are soft felt hats so could be a cross use of terms at times and the styles being European. It is hard to tell from the catalog drawing how much the brim could be minipulated. Regardless a really cool hat that we can only dream about (would be an amazing rare find) at this point.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,310
Messages
3,078,590
Members
54,243
Latest member
seeldoger47
Top