Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Homburg into fedora/fedora into homburg?

Naphtali

Practically Family
Messages
767
Location
Seeley Lake, Montana
I bought a Dobbs Twenty with 2.5-inch brim with Cavanaugh rolled edge and slotted crown. To my untutored eye it looks to be a homburg as it sits. But it also appears to become a fedora with snap brim as I choose. The only obvious difference I can discern between it an my Borsalino fedoras is stiffness of its brim.

If possible from my description, please identify which it is.
 

moehawk

I'll Lock Up
Messages
5,836
Location
Northern California
Cavanagh or otherly-named felted edge makes it a fedora. Homburgs have a deeply curled brim edge that is asymmetrically bound in grosgrain ribbon.

Felted or Cavanagh edge

20230610_180503.jpg

Homburg brim with curl and bound edge

20230610_180610.jpg
 
Last edited:
Messages
19,001
Location
Central California
I bought a Dobbs Twenty with 2.5-inch brim with Cavanaugh rolled edge and slotted crown. To my untutored eye it looks to be a homburg as it sits. But it also appears to become a fedora with snap brim as I choose. The only obvious difference I can discern between it an my Borsalino fedoras is stiffness of its brim.

If possible from my description, please identify which it is.


John @moehawk is right. A defining characteristic of a homburg is the ribbon bound brim edge. The edge also has to be curled to be a homburg, but fedoras also can have curled brim edges. You can’t have a Cavanagh edge on a homburg.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,119
Messages
3,074,533
Members
54,102
Latest member
TXG8R
Top