Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Footwear to go with our jackets

Mich486

One Too Many
Messages
1,690
@Mich486 Do you mean that you can hardly see a difference with bare eyes between Clinch and Attractions and that the horsehide used is similar/almost equal (also black overdyed, leather thickness, no flaws, etc.)? If so, I think I made my decision because I don't want to pay 1000€ more for the fact that they are welting the sole by hand whereas the others are doing goodyear welting by machine. When looking at the pictures I can't really see big differences between both

Both horsebutts are vegetable tanned, similar thickness and hand but different finishing.

The pair of Clinch I had was in black overdyed Horsebutt. By putting them under the sun you could clearly see they were hand painted in black and looked almost brown. This goes along with the “handmade” vibe of the Clinch. (That said I’m not sure whether this is still what they offer today, mine were purchased 2 years ago).

Picture of the Clinch:

FB4103E5-9942-44A3-800B-2B9B8C2869A1.jpeg



The Attractions Horsebutt is also tea-core but not hand painted. They do age beautifully too (not my pair):
CCEF1E89-57AA-4076-8AAF-D6AAC63EE7A4.jpeg
 

Mich486

One Too Many
Messages
1,690
Oh and one big difference. The Clinch were CN last soft toe. The soft toe seemed like a nice idea before purchasing them but then I found that after some wear my big toe was poking through. Wasn’t a massive fan of that. (Clinch can be spec’ed in different ways of course with a toe box too and potentially thicker leathers they offer don’t suffer from this).

Attractions have a more traditional toe box which retains the shape of the front.
 
Messages
16,842
Oh and one big difference. The Clinch were CN last soft toe. The soft toe seemed like a nice idea before purchasing them but then I found that after some wear my big toe was poking through.

Is there something I can do about that? Got the same problem with the Vibergs and it's something I've never seen before. Trying to find some info online but there's no mention of the problem.
 

Mich486

One Too Many
Messages
1,690
I’m really not sure if anything can be done. Probably storing them after every wear with a shoe tree? I suspect it will only delay and slow down the crease from forming but eventually it will show.

If they fit fine I’d say just go along with it, it’s a feature of an unstructured toe. I suspect it happens to most people.
 

Robbie79

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,163
I was close to buy the Attractions horsebutt Engineer boots but as my wife likes both more elegant/classic or modern designs (Italian makers) on me I've just decided to order Clinch Jodhpur boots made of black Horsebutt. As I can wear them for more opportunities (job and leasure) and as I really like Clinch's Jodhpur boot design a lot, I think this is the right decision for me. Since it will be my last pair of high quality shoes/boots for at least 1-2 years or even longer (I bought my last high quality boots about 2-3 years ago), I was thinking about "the right choice" over and over again knowing that Clinch boots won't get out of my head anyway. I was just fascinated by the fact that the boots are 100% hand-sewn/handmade (@dudewuttheheck inspired me also) like the business shoes I already own from Vass, Budapest which are by far the highest quality business shoes I own - I will have a good comparison between Clinch and Vass. Clinch Jodhpur boots will likely arrive around middle/end of August.

upload_2020-7-13_11-46-58.png


upload_2020-7-13_11-47-8.png


upload_2020-7-13_11-47-17.png


upload_2020-7-13_11-47-27.png


upload_2020-7-13_11-47-36.png


upload_2020-7-13_11-47-44.png
 

Attachments

  • upload_2020-7-13_11-59-43.png
    upload_2020-7-13_11-59-43.png
    1,004 KB · Views: 514
  • upload_2020-7-13_12-0-30.png
    upload_2020-7-13_12-0-30.png
    1.1 MB · Views: 514
  • upload_2020-7-13_12-1-9.png
    upload_2020-7-13_12-1-9.png
    602.3 KB · Views: 519

Mich486

One Too Many
Messages
1,690
Up to the ankle they are the same as their engineers. They are nice boots I hope you’ll be happy and most importantly they fit your feet well.

That said... I’m itching for you Robbie, how can a man live in peace without a pair of engineers?! :) I’d be surprised if you can last a few months after you’ll receive these without scratching that itch.
 

Edward

Bartender
Messages
25,081
Location
London, UK
Problem with using CXL for engineer boots is you can't rest one boot over the other because the strap buckle will leave permanent impressions in the hide. Happened on mine and wish I could fix it somehow because the boots still look new...

Try rubbing the bakc of a hot spoon over it, often gets rid of marks easy. Only problem I've ever had crossing my ankles like that is with a waxy hide leaving a deposit on my cuffs.

I can't remember the last time I even so much as wore sneakers.

View attachment 246532

This one made me chuckle - reminds me of one of those kid's pictures where you can change to top half and the bottom half, you know what I mean? Fashion wheel or something. It's the combination of the leather and the flipflops!

I had a pair of "modern" sandals years ago, but I've never seen a pair I actually like. These days I graduate more towards penny loafer in hot weather; also considring picking up some perforated, 50s -style Oxfords. I've found I'm usually good with aleather shoe in hot weather as long as it is true leather - breathable, in a way synthetics aren't.
 

red devil

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,954
Location
London
I was close to buy the Attractions horsebutt Engineer boots but as my wife likes both more elegant/classic or modern designs (Italian makers) on me I've just decided to order Clinch Jodhpur boots made of black Horsebutt. As I can wear them for more opportunities (job and leasure) and as I really like Clinch's Jodhpur boot design a lot, I think this is the right decision for me. Since it will be my last pair of high quality shoes/boots for at least 1-2 years or even longer (I bought my last high quality boots about 2-3 years ago), I was thinking about "the right choice" over and over again knowing that Clinch boots won't get out of my head anyway. I was just fascinated by the fact that the boots are 100% hand-sewn/handmade (@dudewuttheheck inspired me also) like the business shoes I already own from Vass, Budapest which are by far the highest quality business shoes I own - I will have a good comparison between Clinch and Vass. Clinch Jodhpur boots will likely arrive around middle/end of August.

View attachment 246866

View attachment 246867

View attachment 246868

View attachment 246869

View attachment 246870

View attachment 246871

I had been looking at these! They look very nice! :)
 
Messages
16,842
I was close to buy the Attractions horsebutt Engineer boots but as my wife likes both more elegant/classic or modern designs (Italian makers) on me I've just decided to order Clinch Jodhpur boots made of black Horsebutt. As I can wear them for more opportunities (job and leasure) and as I really like Clinch's Jodhpur boot design a lot, I think this is the right decision for me. Since it will be my last pair of high quality shoes/boots for at least 1-2 years or even longer (I bought my last high quality boots about 2-3 years ago), I was thinking about "the right choice" over and over again knowing that Clinch boots won't get out of my head anyway. I was just fascinated by the fact that the boots are 100% hand-sewn/handmade (@dudewuttheheck inspired me also) like the business shoes I already own from Vass, Budapest which are by far the highest quality business shoes I own - I will have a good comparison between Clinch and Vass. Clinch Jodhpur boots will likely arrive around middle/end of August.

View attachment 246866

View attachment 246867

View attachment 246868

View attachment 246869

View attachment 246870

View attachment 246871

These are stunning. Super classy.
 

Psant25

One Too Many
Messages
1,607
971C8E0B-5DC7-4EF9-87E7-F8F448370B4B.jpeg
Still enjoying these honcho boots. So much so I ordered a pair of custom honcho boots in brown horse. About 60 day make time. Made in el paso tx. 385 bucks. crazy to me that price compared to prices of other boots i am used to and prices floating around the forum. Ill post when I get and what specs in case anyone is interested. Never thought I would be wearing cowboy boots lol. But with a lower heel i think they look great.
 

TheOldFashioned

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,179
Location
The Great Lakes
View attachment 246992 Still enjoying these honcho boots. So much so I ordered a pair of custom honcho boots in brown horse. About 60 day make time. Made in el paso tx. 385 bucks. crazy to me that price compared to prices of other boots i am used to and prices floating around the forum. Ill post when I get and what specs in case anyone is interested. Never thought I would be wearing cowboy boots lol. But with a lower heel i think they look great.

Confession time. I never thought I'd wear cowboy boots either, but I just picked up my third pair a week and a half ago and am looking for more. Scored a pair of Black Jack that flew under the radar listed as unbranded on eBay. I reached out to their customer service rep after receiving them and sent her some pictures. She confirmed the make as being genuine (and then ever so conveniently let me know they offer full refurb services when the time comes). Goatskin (burgundy) shaft with bison (chocolate) vamp:
IMG_20200703_120043645.jpg IMG_20200703_120256851_HDR.jpg
 

Robbie79

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,163
I feel like I could live my life without ever looking at another pair of boots if I had these Jodhpurs.
@Monitor First of all thank you for the positive feedback. I had the same feeling when I looked the these Jodhpur boots for the first time as they just look perfect for me. IMO they can be worn for most occasions without feeling over- or underdressed.
 

Edward

Bartender
Messages
25,081
Location
London, UK
View attachment 246992 Still enjoying these honcho boots. So much so I ordered a pair of custom honcho boots in brown horse. About 60 day make time. Made in el paso tx. 385 bucks. crazy to me that price compared to prices of other boots i am used to and prices floating around the forum. Ill post when I get and what specs in case anyone is interested. Never thought I would be wearing cowboy boots lol. But with a lower heel i think they look great.

It's interesting how the lower heel totally transforms the look of the boot - that, the slightly rounder toe, and the more subtle decoration. THose are motre a boot I ould imagine myselfv wearing - perhaps with a nice, subtle harness - whereas my more traditional cowboy boot days are very definitely long behined me.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,248
Messages
3,077,241
Members
54,183
Latest member
UrbanGraveDave
Top