LizzieMaine
Bartender
- Messages
- 33,757
- Location
- Where The Tourists Meet The Sea
I watched an old Roscoe Arbuckle short the other day and it came off as a little lame, contrary to what I've read about him. Shemp Howard happened to be in it, too, and there were some funny gags, but it was basically one long joke.
But on the other hand, it's hard not to watch something like that and remember that at one time, it was new and fresh. Everything was new once. That particular short had some wonderful accents, by the way.
That Arbuckle was one of his "comeback" shorts, made at the Vitaphone studio in Brooklyn in 1932 -- he hadn't made a screen appearance since 1921 as a result of The Scandal, and while he had kept his hand in as a director, he was rusty as a performer and a decade past his prime besides. Shemp was actually the bigger star at the time -- he had his own series at Vitaphone, and also appeared in supporting roles in various other comedies around the studio.
To see Arbuckle at his best, look for the silent shorts he did for his own studio in 1918-1919. His sidekicks in that series were Buster Keaton and Al St. John, and what they lack in plot, they more than make up in sheer comic energy. Arbuckle had a lot in common with Curly Howard as a big man with an immense and graceful collection of funny moves.
Whatever their defects, the Vitaphone talkie shorts landed Arbuckle a contract to make features for Warner Brothers, and it looked like he was headed back to the top of the pile -- but he died of a heart attack the night after signing the deal.