Doctor Strange
I'll Lock Up
- Messages
- 5,252
- Location
- Hudson Valley, NY
Oh, the 1938 Hollywood version is lame, bordering on unwatchable. The Patrick Stewart TNT version is okay (not surprisingly, Stewart himself is very good), but it can't hold a candle to - IMHO - the two four-star adaptations of A Christmas Carol:
The 1951 Alastair Sim film is a concise, noirish b/w masterpiece that hits all the right notes. And Sim is just a magnificent Scrooge, a wonderful interpretation!
The 1984 George C. Scott TV version is an outstanding adaptation - so good that you don't even notice that Scott is the only guy in the cast with an American accent. Among other reasons, it features my all-time favorite Bob Cratchit: David Warner, absolutely heartbreaking in a rare good-guy role. Actually, the whole cast is splendid: Roger Rees as Fred, Frank Finlay as Marley, Edward Woodward as Christmas Present...
I also give high marks to a nostalgic favorite, Mr. Magoo's Christmas Carol. Though it's a limited-animation cartoon, it captures the bulk of the story accurately in a very short timeframe, and it has much better songs than the 1970 musical Scrooge with Albert Finney.
The 1951 Alastair Sim film is a concise, noirish b/w masterpiece that hits all the right notes. And Sim is just a magnificent Scrooge, a wonderful interpretation!
The 1984 George C. Scott TV version is an outstanding adaptation - so good that you don't even notice that Scott is the only guy in the cast with an American accent. Among other reasons, it features my all-time favorite Bob Cratchit: David Warner, absolutely heartbreaking in a rare good-guy role. Actually, the whole cast is splendid: Roger Rees as Fred, Frank Finlay as Marley, Edward Woodward as Christmas Present...
I also give high marks to a nostalgic favorite, Mr. Magoo's Christmas Carol. Though it's a limited-animation cartoon, it captures the bulk of the story accurately in a very short timeframe, and it has much better songs than the 1970 musical Scrooge with Albert Finney.