Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Vintage Fedoras by Decade

Dinerman

Super Moderator
Bartender
Messages
10,562
Location
Bozeman, MT
A rough guide for dating vintage fedoras.

Remember- details varied manufacturer to manufacturer, price point to price point, and country to country.

Having a hat with stylistic elements that are common from a particular decade does not necessarily mean that your hat is from that decade. For example, a feathered trailing bow edge is common on hats from the '20s and '30s, but you'll see it on Cavanagh hats through the '60s. Unreeded sweatbands were common on earlier manufacture hats, as were taped sweatband seams- but you still see these details show up much much later, again, depending on manufacturer, price point, model, and country of manufacture.

So don't take anything in this guide as a hard and fast rule, but hopefully it will be useful as a start towards further research.

THE 1920s

Sweatbands - You see a lot of variation in the sweatbands found in early hats. Some companies were using reeded sweatbands, others were using unreeded. In general, you see wide embossing at the top of the sweatband. Sweatbands from the 1920s-early 1930s period are generally wider than later sweatbands. Stitching is generally closer spaced than on later hats. Sweatband embossing is usually intricate, deep, and highly detailed, though this is not always the case.

For reference, here are photos of hats dating from the c.1920s period. There may be some overlap to the early 1930s, as things change gradually and there are generally not industry-wide immediate changes made in materials or processes.

IMG_1799.jpg

Genuine Velour. Note unreeded sweatband and sweatband texture.

IMG_4512.jpg

Marshall Field. Note reeded sweatband and blind embossing.

IMG_2827.jpg

Mallory dated 1923. Unreeded. Blind embossed logo.

IMG_4666.jpg

Stetson. Incredibly detailed embossing. Reeded sweatband.

IMG_2179.jpg

Stetson. Note sweatband texture and high level of quality of embossing.

IMG_4439.jpg

Stetson. Blind embossed. High level of detail.

DSCN6540.jpg


IMG_4391.jpg

Solferino. Italian hat. Unreeded
 
Last edited:

Dinerman

Super Moderator
Bartender
Messages
10,562
Location
Bozeman, MT
THE 1920s

Common Ribbon Styles

Wider ribbons on soft hats seem to have been dominant, though you do see narrower ribboned hats as well. The intensionally frayed trailing edge of the bow was popular, but not universal. Twisted bow knots were also common, but also, not universal by a long shot.

IMG_4437.jpg

IMG_4389.jpg

IMG_1797.jpg

medalist_3.jpg

IMG_2064.jpg

P1070658.jpg

P1070620.jpg

IMG_2176.jpg
[/QUOTE]
 
Last edited:

Dinerman

Super Moderator
Bartender
Messages
10,562
Location
Bozeman, MT
THE 1920s
You see a mix of reeded and unreeded sweatbands. You see a mix of stitched and taped sweatband seams. You see fancy detailing on some liners- pleats, ruffles, but not across the board (and you do see see these details on later hats as well, depending on manufacturer and price point). As with sweatband imprints, generally on these earlier hats, the quality of the imprint is of higher quality than on later hats.

Liners
P1070659.jpg

Note taped seam of sweatband and sticker size tag. High level of detail to liner logo. Fancy detailing to seams.

IMG_2060.jpg

Sewn sweatband seam. Reeded Sweatband. Gray leather sweatband. High level of detail to liner logo. Pleated detailing.

IMG_4388.jpg

Unreeded sweatband. Sticker size tag. High level of detail to liner logo.

IMG_2825.jpg

Unreeded sweatband, sewn sweatband seam

IMG_1126.jpg

Embroidered.
 
Last edited:

Dinerman

Super Moderator
Bartender
Messages
10,562
Location
Bozeman, MT
THE 1920s

Exterior Styles. You see a lot of high, straight sided crowns and deep creases, pushing the front and back out, creating a "reverse taper" when viewed from the side. Long napped finishes were common, as was the transitional fedora/homburg hybrid soft hat, with an overwelt brim edge and flanging somewhere between the two as we think of them now.

IMG_1796.jpg


IMG_4458.jpg


IMG_4386.jpg


IMG_4435.jpg


ParkwayFrontAft.jpg
 

Dinerman

Super Moderator
Bartender
Messages
10,562
Location
Bozeman, MT
THE 1930s

Sweatbands
Sweatbands are still wide. Early in the decade, the widely spaced large or intricate embossing at the top edge of the sweatband is still present, later in the decade the embossed line begins to get smaller. Unreeded sweatbands are more common on 1930s hats than on later ones, though they do still pop up, and some manufacturers or different models were using unreeded sweatbands in this timeframe. It is more common to see a taped back sweatband seam on hats from the 1920s and 1930s hats(no stitching- taped from behind), though many were stitched. Brown is the predominant color of sweatband leather, though there is still variation. Sweatbands are generally not made from leather with as much texture as you see on earlier hats.

IMG_1386.jpg


IMG_0921.jpg


IMG_2798.jpg


IMG_3056.jpg


IMG_2964.jpg


IMG_0964.jpg


IMG_2127.jpg


Out of the ordinary sweatband colors shouldn't throw you, though.
IMG_4591.jpg
 

Dinerman

Super Moderator
Bartender
Messages
10,562
Location
Bozeman, MT
THE 1930s

Brim Flanging and crown shape. Straight sided crowns are a hallmark of 1930s hats. The mostly flat brim was common.

IMG_1381.jpg


IMG_0920.jpg


IMG_7168.jpg


IMG_7955.jpg


IMG_2796.jpg


IMG_3652.jpg


But it was not the only style available. This Knox, for instance, has a heavily curled brim, especially in the back
IMG_2853.jpg
 

Dinerman

Super Moderator
Bartender
Messages
10,562
Location
Bozeman, MT
THE 1940s
Wide brims are more common. The short brim/tall crown combo of the 1930s had all but disappeared. Tall crowns with little taper are still the most common.

Exterior
IMG_8909.jpg


IMG_7949.jpg


IMG_7382.jpg


IMG_7332.jpg


IMG_4275.jpg
 

Dinerman

Super Moderator
Bartender
Messages
10,562
Location
Bozeman, MT
Sweatbands
Though unreeded sweatbands are still around, especially on hats made in the early part of the decade, and by smaller makers, reeded sweatbands are the most common.
Brown is the color of the decade, though, as always, from maker to maker, there is variation in color and texture.

IMG_1473.jpg


Early 1940s Stetson
IMG_4396.jpg


IMG_4419.jpg


IMG_6031.jpg


IMG_6053.jpg
 

Dinerman

Super Moderator
Bartender
Messages
10,562
Location
Bozeman, MT
The 1950s

Brims started getting skinnier as the decade progressed. Crowns started becoming more tapered and shorter. Towards the end of the decade, "stingy brim" hats started appearing, which will be discussed more in the 1960s section. Remember that none of these changes occurred with the change in decade, that it was a fluid change over the years. Some manufacturers held on to older styles for longer, and a manufacturer would probably be producing hats for a younger market and a more conservative market at the same time.

IMG_2092.jpg


IMG_5076.jpg


IMG_5090.jpg


IMG_7233.jpg


IMG_7286.jpg


IMG_7404.jpg


IMG_8963.jpg


P1120692.jpg


IMG_3876.jpg
 

Dinerman

Super Moderator
Bartender
Messages
10,562
Location
Bozeman, MT
THE 1960s

For the most part, brims shank down to somewhere in the 2 inch region, though in some cases it was much less. You do see hats with brims greater than 2-1/4", but they are not the majority they once were. Ribbons grew proportionately wider. Crowns lowered and tapered.
The welt edge seems to have overtaken other edge finishes.

IMG_0218.jpg


IMG_0230.jpg


IMG_0236.jpg


IMG_4379.jpg


IMG_6320.jpg


IMG_4326.jpg


IMG_7431.jpg


Extreme Stingy brim
IMG_4393.jpg


More conservative style.
IMG_6330.jpg
 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,278
Messages
3,077,749
Members
54,221
Latest member
magyara
Top