Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

The Fedora Lounge Guide to Mackinaw coats

Dinerman

Super Moderator
Bartender
Messages
10,562
Location
Bozeman, MT
The history of Mackinaw coats.


Mackinaw fabric, as well as mackinaw coats, trace their name back to blankets used in the fur trade by the Mackinaw Fur Company, headquartered at Fort Mackinac. As with the point blankets made by the Hudson's Bay Company, Mackinaw blankets were made in an array of bright colors and garish patterns. Originally favored by native Americans and fur traders in the area, the coats gained near immediate acceptance among lumberjacks in that area's logging industry. Whether cut from Mackinaw blankets, Hudson's Bay Blankets, or from Pendleton Blankets, these coats shared several important features. In a time when men in cities wore overcoats nearly exclusively in cold weather, these coats were cut short, generally with a length of 35 or 36 inches, to allow for freedom of movement. The short cut allowed for extremely heavyweight, warm fabric without the weight associated with a long coat. The bright colors and loud patterns of the blankets favored among these loggers soon found their way throughout the country, first as souvenirs, later as part of nationwide marketing.


Examples of other fabric styles worn by early lumbermen. Left: Pendleton. Right: Variant of Hudson's Bay Company point blanket. Lumberjacks of the turn of the century period also favored sheeplined canvas "box coats", which would come to be known, post-war, as mackinaws as well.

Though lumberjacks were primarily of French-Canadian or Scottish-Canadian ancestry, mackinaw cloth owes its origins to Norwegian immigrants. The original cloth was homepun from wool from northern sheep. The early fabric was relatively coarse, and heavyweight, around 40oz. After it was woven, was "stumpfed", or danced upon with soap and water with wooden shoes, usually accompanied by music and celebration. This process felted the fabric, shrinking it dramatically, and making it thicker, denser, warmer, and resistant to rain and further shrinkage. Commercially produced mackinaw cloth later mimicked this process mechanically. After weaving, the fabric was shrunk and felted (the stumpfing or fulling process) , then napped to give it a thick and fluffy texture, further increasing its insulation value.


Mackinaw Cloth available from Patrick-Duluth.

The F.A. Patrick Company, proprietors of the Patrick-Duluth Woolen Mills of Duluth, Minnesota were responsible for taking the Mackinaw coat out of lumber camps of western Canada and introducing them to students, workmen and athletes across the United States. Early on, the Patrick Company were jobbers, making dry goods, primarily for clients in the Northwest of the United States in Canada. In 1901, Patrick began buying fabric from a Scandinavian mackinaw cloth factory in Fosston, Minnesota. In 1906, seeing potential, Patrick bought that factory and began making their own Mackinaw cloth, eventually becoming one of its leading producers. The fabric and the coats made from it were popular with miners, fur trappers, lumberjacks and hunters.


Patrick Coats- 1912

In 1912, Patrick launched a new, refined mackinaw design. It was double breasted, belted and sported a collar described in the ads of the period as a "nansen" collar. Though the term also existed then, we now refer to this style as a shawl collar. The coat was 35" long and was available in 24 and 32 oz wool mackinaw cloth, in a wide variety of colors. Salesman Harry Harrington began to pitch the Patrick Mackinaw to clothiers in college towns. "It was not long after that that mackinaws became a fad with students generally, and as the college student invariably sets the styles for young men's clothing, it quickly spread over the whole country". The early mackinaw trend was marketed in a similar way to the current workwear trend, trading on the rugged associations of the workers for whom the garment was originally designed. The mackinaw fad boomed, and shortly, a number of other manufacturers sprung onto the scene, producing mackinaws of varying quality from a variety of cloths. Large quantities of Patrick mackinaws were sold through such high end stores as Brooks Brothers, Rogers Peet, Wannamaker, Abercrombie and Fitch, Brokaw Brothers, and A. Raymond.

It is around this 1912-1913 period where the name "Mackinaw" begins to be more associated with the short, double breasted, shawl collar style, and less with the mackinaw cloth material from which it was made. The fad lasted about a year and a half. Patrick could not keep up with the growing demand caused by the collegiate fad, and the fabric quality of some competitors led to its downfall.


Coats from other makers. L: 1915 Wulkote by the Wisconsin Garment Company (later WisGarCo). R: 1912 by Tilton Bros, Chicago

Seeing the end of the craze, Patrick-Duluth re-branded its mackinaw once again, refining its pattern and marketing it to farmers, children, hunters and outdoorsmen, workers, and sportsmen. Its durability, warmth, low price compared to comparable overcoats or sheeplined coats, made it an easy sell to these markets. Alongside sheeplined canvas coats, Patrick Mackinaws became the de-facto winter coat of railroad employees. To further expand the market, patterns were made for men and women, boys and girls. Patrick intensified their national advertising, placing ads in the Saturday Evening Post, Country Gentleman, Farm Journal, Woman's World, American Boy, Youth's Companion, Boy's Life, and many more. The name of the product was shortened from "Patrick-Duluth Woolen Mill Mackinaw" to simply "Patrick", in a bid to make their brand name the generic trade name on the market, thereby foiling the business of competitors. Their slogan "Bigger than Weather" was penned by Elbert Hubbard. Ads were illustrated by Peter Newell and Clare Briggs. In the years between 1911 and 1914, Patrick had quadrupled its production, expanding from their two story mill to a six story mill on Duluth habror, a garment factory in Duluth, and knitting and spinning mills in Mankato, MN.





Patrick mackinaws were worn and endorsed by the New York Giants, the Chicago Cubs, and the White Sox


Patrick also secured the contract to be the official coat of the Boy Scouts.
 
Last edited:

Dinerman

Super Moderator
Bartender
Messages
10,562
Location
Bozeman, MT
Army Mackinaws.
Some sources incorrectly cite WWI as the origin of the shawl collar mackinaw in fashion. The shawl collar mackinaw saw service as a short officer's overcoat in a kersey wool. Later on, the shawl collar was dropped in favor of more standard overcoat style lapels. The 1st pattern m1938 kept the mackinaw styling but was done with a cotton shell and wool lining.

m1926 at left. Privately tailored WWII era example at right


In ads postwar, the coat at right, and other coats similar to the style, were referred to as "mackinaws", despite not having the mackinaw styling nor mackinaw cloth.

In the post-war period, the Mackinaw name was used to describe a variety of styles of coats. It was used to describe shawl collar coats, wool or sheeplined. It was used to describe hunting coats made of heavyweight wool plaid fabric, like those made by Woolrich. It was used to describe short, double breasted wool coats, belted or no.


All of these postwar examples were advertised as mackinaws.
Top Row: Plaid zipper-front cossack, plaid belted double breasted, solid shawl collar railroad coat, plaid belted double breasted
Bottom Row: mouton collared sheepskin lined canvas coat, plaid belted double breasted, belted shawl collar, plaid belted double breasted



This style of coat, generally advertised in the period simply as "plaid hunting coats" began to be called mackinaws or hunting mackinaws post-war.
 
Last edited:

Flat Foot Floey

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,220
Location
Germany
Whoa that's a lot of valuable information and history. Thank you for the research. I have often wondered why some plaid hunting coats are labelled "mackinaw" too. I favour the belted and double breasted versions myself. I have said it before: You are the reason why I bought my blanket coat. Maybe a shawl collar will be next ;-)
 

Dinerman

Super Moderator
Bartender
Messages
10,562
Location
Bozeman, MT
Whoa that's a lot of valuable information and history. Thank you for the research. I have often wondered why some plaid hunting coats are labelled "mackinaw" too. I favour the belted and double breasted versions myself. I have said it before: You are the reason why I bought my blanket coat. Maybe a shawl collar will be next ;-)

It's interesting how the meaning of words change over time. Even in the '30s, there were companies like Carrs who were making blanket coats like yours and calling them mackinaws. Their signature cut was single breasted with a fold down collar and caped shoulders (not a "classic" mackinaw cut), made of striped blanket material (not "classic" mackinaw cloth). The name meant some very specific things, but came to encompass so many cuts and styles. Though they didn't share cuts or materials, one thing all the styles that came to be called "mackinaw coats" had in common was a common lineage going back to Canadian and Pacific Northwest lumberjacks.
 

Edward

Bartender
Messages
25,081
Location
London, UK
I love the shawl collar shape. I've been eying this one from River Junction for some time. Maybe this Winter...

thumbnail.asp
 

pipvh

Practically Family
Messages
644
Location
England
Very interesting - thanks for all the work!

Where does the Canadienne fit into the picture? Is it essentially the same thing?
 

rocketeer

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,605
Location
England
Can you still buy these coats in the traditional plaid wool new rather than second hand 'vintage' items?
I recently visited Toronto, Canada, visited a few gents shops in the Downtown area but no one really knew what I really wanted.
J
 

Dinerman

Super Moderator
Bartender
Messages
10,562
Location
Bozeman, MT
Very interesting - thanks for all the work!

Where does the Canadienne fit into the picture? Is it essentially the same thing?

The Canadienne was originally known as a "sheeplined coat", or a "sheeplined box coat". The style is virtually unchaged since the turn of the last century. They were often advertised alongside mackinaws in the same advertisements, but did not go by that name.
When the definition of the "mackinaw" name broadened after WWII, it eventually came to also encompass these shawl-collared sheepskin and canvas coats. So calling them mackinaws is not incorrect, it's just more of a 1950s and 1960s term applied retroactively to the style.

You can order them here. It takes six to eight weeks to make them up:

http://www.riverjunction.com/Coat--...ol-Outer-and-Lining--Heirloom-Brand_p_69.html
The fabrics which that one are available in are kind of interesting, historically. Mackinaws produced in the period its supposedly replicating were known for, some would say defined by, their brightly colored, garish plaids.
This coat is using fairly muted hunting plaids, appropriated from hunting coats which wouldn't be known as "mackinaws" until the 1950s or 1960s. That's not to say it'e entirely inaccurate, the cut looks nice enough, it's just interesting how words and styles change.

If you're looking for one which is truly accurate, I would recommend this one, by Freewheelers.

BritishColumbia_00001.jpg
 
Last edited:

rocketeer

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,605
Location
England
You can order them here. It takes six to eight weeks to make them up:

http://www.riverjunction.com/Coat--...ol-Outer-and-Lining--Heirloom-Brand_p_69.html

By complete coincidence, I came across this just now: http://doursoux.com/product.php?id_product=670

The Canadienne was originally known as a "sheeplined coat", or a "sheeplined box coat". The style is virtually unchaged since the turn of the last century. They were often advertised alongside mackinaws in the same advertisements, but did not go by that name.
When the definition of the "mackinaw" name broadened after WWII, it eventually came to also encompass these shawl-collared sheepskin and canvas coats. So calling them mackinaws is not incorrect, it's just more of a 1950s and 1960s term applied retroactively to the style.


The fabrics which that one are available in are kind of interesting, historically. Mackinaws produced in the period its supposedly replicating were known for, some would say defined by, their brightly colored, garish plaids.
This coat is using fairly muted hunting plaids, appropriated from hunting coats which wouldn't be known as "mackinaws" until the 1950s or 1960s. That's not to say it'e entirely inaccurate, the cut looks nice enough, it's just interesting how words and styles change.

If you're looking for one which is truly accurate, I would recommend this one, by Freewheelers.

May have to investigate these:) But maybe nearer winter. Thats probably only about six weeks away haha.
John
 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,256
Messages
3,077,413
Members
54,183
Latest member
UrbanGraveDave
Top