Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Shirt collars over lapels?

Just adding an Australian view - I've just gone through family pics from the 20s, 40s and 50s taken in England, Western Samoa and Australia, and the collar over the jacket crops up in all of these decades in all of these places.

I'm quite taken with the look, when it's done well ;)

I'll add the photos to this post, when I've made enough posts to be allowed images.

-Irene
 
Thanks for correcting me on that, Tomasso.

Ok, first one is a photo from the late 1930s/early 1940s, taken in Western Samoa. The gentleman in trousers and a white shirt is my great-grandfather, while the three men in shorts and rope belts are the crew of an aeroplane that had been used in previous years to set across-the-world records. Note that the crew are Australians, and my great-grandfather was a dual Australian/Samoan citizen - may have some bearing on the fashions worn.

JGSTHNCROSSCREWAPIALONDBRIS0001.jpg
[/IMG]

Second photo is my maternal grandad, in England in the early-mid 1950s. He's looking rather casual, but in a good way!
AlaninEngland2.jpg
[/IMG]

And my grandad again, same time period, out cycling.
AlaninEngland.jpg
[/IMG]


Hope these are some help.
 
Thanks for the kind welcome, Derek.

Widebrim - My family has been in Samoa since the mid 1800s, owning/running a plantation farm. We still have relatives living on the same plantation now, although on my side of the family, my grandfather was the last one to actually grow up in Samoa. As was common for any white family living in the Pacific islands throughout the 1800s and the first half of the 1900s, childbirth and children's higher education took place in Australia (NZ, for some families) where facilities were of a much higher standard. Hence my grandfather eventually settling in Australia for good.

Anyhoo, it makes for some interesting photos of the end of the colonial period in the Pacific.
 

acl1

Familiar Face
Messages
52
Location
Southern California
In those pictures, it looks great, though it is a different time. Personally, I don't think collars over lapels looks right 99% of the time, but your picture is in the other 1%.
 

sinatra66

New in Town
Messages
21
Location
canada - southern ontario
hello all, i'm new.
love the fact there is some one like me. so i'm not crazy? i've been collecting square bottom sport shirts. that led to wearing pleated baggy trousers. that led to hats. just purchased a biltmore 2" c crown senator. any way, in the army we wore collars out on jackets in summer (winter wear a tie). my thoughts are, the army holds on to traditions the longest. things i was doing in the 80's/90's, my father did in the 50's/60's/70's, his father and brother was doing in the 30's/40's. so if it is ok with them it's ok.
 

Big Man

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,781
Location
Nebo, NC
How about two shirts with a jacket ...

Here's a picture of my Dad (on the right) and a couple of his friends taken in 1940. Not only did my Dad have his collar outside his jacket, but apparently wearing two shirts was also in style at the time.


DSC04431.jpg
 

Big Man

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,781
Location
Nebo, NC
My Dad must have liked the collar over the jacket lapel style because here he is again ten years later in 1950. That's my Mother with him.

DSC03590.jpg
 

Geronimo

One of the Regulars
Messages
119
Location
Texas
thunderw21 said:
It can be a good look.

me144-1.jpg
Very nice. That blue suit is a thing of beauty - do you know what (besides blue) that color is called? I've been wanting one like that since seeing the original Maxwell Smart wearing one.
 

reetpleat

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,681
Location
Seattle
Mario said:
I just got this shirt today with comparatively long, pointy collars. Just had to try wearing it with the collars over the lapels - and I have to admit that I like it. [huh] :D

mallory_09_07_10.jpg

I like this shirt with the over the collar look, as it is slightly informal due to color and texture. But not sure about with the ascot. I tend to think open neck, over collar, but with ascot, looks best tucked in under collar. But great suave look all the same.
 

reetpleat

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,681
Location
Seattle
I am surprised no one has addressed this more technically. The first part is speculation on my part. But it seems in the twenties and thirties, in hot climates, and summer, when a tie would be too much, the style developed as a sporty look. With the thin fabric of collars back then, it looked pretty sharp in a sporty casual way only men back then seem to pull off just right.

In the thirties, probably mainly due to this trend and the "california look" of unstructured jackets with point collars, the convertible collar was invented. Not sure if it was called that at first, but it was marketed as that in the forties. This is the traditional "loop" shirt, and was intended for a more casual look, or working professionals such as an engineer or architect who would have to go out in field (this is how I have seen it marketed) This collar, to be technical, had no collar band. A dress shirt has a band then a collar sewn into it. this is hat makes a shirt look not as smooth open and over the collar, but can work when it lays right and has the right fabric and shape.

the thirties convertible collars, in contrast, had one piece collars, as mentioned above. They often had long points, that would match casual jackets so they lined up, but also were worn over traditional collared sport coats and suits. Looks great.

By the 40s, they were very popular in gabardine, in wool, rayon, cotton or blends. They would not be worn with a tie under a suit, but, to respond to the baron, were often worn with the loop buttoned and a flashy tie, often in interesting color combinations. or, buttoned with no tie (mostly black guys) either under a jacket, or no jacket. This was also a popular look for zoot suited latinos in the 40s, with no tie. Interestingly, it is not unusual to see p[ics of old farmers in dress shirts and no ties, buttoned up to the neck. often under overalls. amongst latinos in Califas, the look eventually evolved into an interesting affectation involving buttoning just to top button over a tank style undershirt. But I digress.

In the 50s and 60s, most sport shirts were designed with this fold over one piece collar, although not always loop style. Many of them were designed to not be buttonable, often not even having a top button. these were commonly worn over a jacket or sport coat or suit jacket, with an open collar, although as the lapels got thin, they seem to be more casual looking. Also, it was not unusual for banded collar sport shirts to be worn open collar over the lapel, but it would be quite unusual to see a person wearing a white dress shirt open collar under a suit or sport coat, as if by now it was not acceptable unless it was a sport shirt.

So, there are my observations on the look. I am often torn because i like the look and find it much more comfortable, but then I do not get to wear one of my great ties.
 

Flat Foot Floey

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,220
Location
Germany
reetpleat said:
(....)but then I do not get to wear one of my great ties.
:arated:

But my brother doesn't like flashy ties but a sporty 40s/ 50s style. This collar over lapels thing might be the best idea for him.

Whats the difference between 40s Open Collar shirts and 70s? (except polyester)
Does the collar still have a curve?
 

Forum statistics

Threads
108,955
Messages
3,071,504
Members
54,013
Latest member
Nikolaus23
Top