I am dreading this film because often my favourite books are massacred in their move to film. Ask the Dust is a good example. Also, Sam Mendes covered similair territory in his first film (suburban angst - though of the more overwrought, Douglas sirk variety - in American Beauty), and although The Road to Perdition looked good (and is highly regarded around here), I found it a very slight, unconvincing, Disneyfied piece of dinner-theatre.
Yates has a sharp eye and well-tuned ear for the telling detail - traits that anyone who can cast Tom Hanks as a feared mob assasain probably doesn't have. I'm afraid it's going to be all about the costumes and the art direction again.
I've been excited about this movie since first hearing about it. Though it is from my favorite book and it's more about internal dialog than action, I think it might turn out well. Sam Mendes is directing, and he's done a great job with those movies that are all about the struggle within the charaters' minds.
See Jarhead (which I thought would be terrible, until I saw it), Road to Perdition, and American Beauty for exactly this type of work.
My wife is reading the book now, and the movie looks good so far. Just by coincidence they will probably get a little momentum from the popularity of Madmen.
They'll also be collecting on the hype of the Titanic-star reunion. The preview even seems to have a steamy scene in a car that is reminiscent of the boat movie.
I enjoyed this movie. It was a little depressing, but well done. Thomas Newman, as always, provided some great music. The clothing and back drops were well thought out IMHO.
I saw the preview over the summer while watching Mad Men, so I got the book and read it. It is a depressing story so I do expect the movie to be as well. It isn't playing here until this coming weekend but I am looking forward to it.
Wow! This is a good one. Kate Winslet is incredible, Leo is no slouch, and the director (Kate's husband, Sam Mendes) made my day by staying true to such a wonderful book. Thai food and the saddest movie I can remember seeing have made for a great Saturday.
I saw the movie first, then read the book, then bought the DVD.
So much of the sets, etc., were right on, but did anyone else notice modern-looking fluorescent lights in the school scene at the beginning? They paid so much detail to every other scene, I thought it was strange they couldn't find a school with vintage lights.
As far as time period, this movie was a little late for me. I enjoyed it, but I wouldn't rent it again, which is how I know if I really like something. The ending was just too depressing.
One of the worst movies I have seen. I wanted to get my money back and wash my brain of it all. I was so depressed after watching it. I knew nothing about it going in and paid for my lack of knowledge.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.