Carlisle Blues
My Mail is Forwarded Here
- Messages
- 3,154
- Location
- Beautiful Horse Country
"Anachronist"
LizzieMaine said:Maybe make the point that the Atavist generally makes use of elements of modern technology as a means to an end, rather than embracing them as an end in themselves
LizzieMaine said:A key difference between Atavism and other "retro" subcultures is that the Atavist generally avoids, and often disdains a detatched, ironic view of their specific chronological era -- and therefore will often appreciate on their original merits elements of popular culture that are more often viewed by contemporary observers thru the lens of camp.
Senator Jack said:That is going in the manifesto :eusa_clap.
And, of course, we have to address this issue:
A general point of attack on the Atavist subculture is that by celebrating the culture of a bygone era, there is an inherent celebration of a culture that is ethically and morally undeveloped. Critics believe Atavists would like to revive a world where women and minorities are subjugated, where discrimination is the norm, but even a cursory study of the Atavist will show that these charges are wholly unfounded.
Needs more.
anon` said:I second anachronist. True, it may not be a proper word, but unlike atavist it isn't as likely to send people away puzzled, or rushing for their dictionary.
Fletch said:we're guided by – something. Taste? Common experiences? Common lack of experiences? Society's quiet voice whispering, "no, you can't"? What? FWIW, I like to think of myself as "post-generationalist." Meaning you choose your culture, rather than have it foisted on you by your cohort or your era.
dhermann1 said:Senator: In your article, I assume you'll stress that there are all degrees of the phenomenon, from just wearing vintage ties or hats, to living a total lifestyle at home or abroad.
I'm sure that there are some 1970's ones out there, somewhere.
Senator Jack said:
Senator Jack said:I think the term has to definitely conjure up a 20th century lifestyle, whether it's 20s, 30s, or even 70s. (yes, there are people out there who live a completely 1970s lifestyle with 8-tracks and everything.)
Senator Jack said:Do you go to work or attend functions in modern clothes because you're worried what other people think and want to fit in?
This seems much too narrow to be a valid test. Using myself as an example, I would be an [anachronist] based on the above, as I go to work and attend functions in vintage clothes, hats and what-have-you all the time. I relish it, in fact. I also love buildings, furnishings, transportation and guns from the first third of the last century.Senator Jack said:Thinking about the separation of the two, from those with an interest in the era and those that lead the life, I think it may come down to one question:
Do you go to work or attend functions in modern clothes because you're worried what other people think and want to fit in?