Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Meltonian - is it "Kiwi Select"?

matei

One Too Many
Messages
1,022
Location
England
Hi All,

When I was in LA over the weekend I picked up a jar of neutral Meltonian creme for my my brown shoes. It is the best shoe creme/paste that I've ever used. However, it isn't available, as far as I've ascertained, here in London.

The word on the street is that it is marked here as "Kiwi Select". Is there any truth to that? The jars appear to be similar, and on the Meltonian label it says "Kiwi" in small print...
 

"Doc" Devereux

One Too Many
Messages
1,206
Location
London
I used to get Meltonian from a cobbler near the ancestral pile. Haven't seen it anywhere else, though, so I'd be curious to know the answer as well.

I agree, Matei. That stuff is excellent.
 

matei

One Too Many
Messages
1,022
Location
England
I had a problem with the neutral polish - the hard stuff in the tin. It would flake off into a white powder where the leather flexed, and it looked awful. If I melted the polish into the leather with me wife's blowdryer it was OK... just OK...

One go with the Meltonian and me shoes look like they're made out of burnished walnut! Excellent stuff indeed. I'd like to try the black as well, save the wear and tear on me elbow/wrist in getting that killer shine.
 

"Doc" Devereux

One Too Many
Messages
1,206
Location
London
The black was my weapon of choice: the only way to beat it was a full-on bulling. You should have seen what it did to my riding boots!
 

Alan Eardley

One Too Many
Messages
1,500
Location
Midlands, UK
Meltonian

Meltonian shoe cream is freely available in the UK but they don't seem to like selling through the high street 'Mr Minute' type shops. Good cobblers usually have a reasonable range. I find that hard polishes are OK for an everyday shine, but shoe cream is better for 'sweating' or 'spit polishing' to a very high shine. Remember that Kiwi was invented for use on military boots, by two Australians, paradoxically.

Alan
 

matei

One Too Many
Messages
1,022
Location
England
I found as well that the black Kiwi is fine for everyday shining. To get a mirror-like shine I'd have to sit around and do the spit shining routine, which isn't exactly practical for me.

The other Kiwi colours are OK, but I find their neutral or gloss (something like parade gloss - I can't recall the name) are flaky.

I'll do some research and see if I can't track down the elusive Meltonian...
 

Fleur De Guerre

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,056
Location
Walton on Thames, UK
While you chaps are having a discussion on this shoe polish, might I ask a quick, semi :eek:fftopic: question?

I haven't polished a shoe since I was about 10 years old, but I recently got a pair of leather heeled shoes. I foolishly drove in them a couple of times and some quite bad scuff marks have appeared on the backs and the heels. What can I do about this? Can they be polished out with normal polish? They are two tone black and white and I don't want to get black on the white so I am scared of even trying, but if I knew what to do I'm sure I could be careful.

I presume I would need to buy all the kit for polishing too, brushes and the like.
 

Kt Templar

One of the Regulars
Messages
289
Location
Nr Wimbledon, SW London. UK
This is the question I was asking a little while ago on COW. They are great fans of Meltonian over normal "tin" Kiwi. It is a brand name I've come across in th UK so you can buy it here, maybe in some of the older style department stores.

Matei, they might sell it in Johnson shoes in Wallington, but I suspect it's not that hard to find if you look in the right places.
 

"Doc" Devereux

One Too Many
Messages
1,206
Location
London
Fleur De Guerre said:
While you chaps are having a discussion on this shoe polish, might I ask a quick, semi :eek:fftopic: question?

I haven't polished a shoe since I was about 10 years old, but I recently got a pair of leather heeled shoes. I foolishly drove in them a couple of times and some quite bad scuff marks have appeared on the backs and the heels. What can I do about this? Can they be polished out with normal polish? They are two tone black and white and I don't want to get black on the white so I am scared of even trying, but if I knew what to do I'm sure I could be careful.

I presume I would need to buy all the kit for polishing too, brushes and the like.

It's certainly worth a try: I'd suggest Kiwi Parade Gloss and a soft cloth - much more precise than brushes - or some of that lovely Meltonian.
 

manton

A-List Customer
Messages
360
Location
New York
I believe they are made by the same company. Meltonian is cream, Kiwi is wax. Cream does a better job of nourishing and remoisturizing the leather. Wax polishes up to a higher shine and offers more protection against scuffs.
 

jml90

One of the Regulars
Messages
264
Location
NEPA
manton said:
I believe they are made by the same company. Meltonian is cream, Kiwi is wax. Cream does a better job of nourishing and remoisturizing the leather. Wax polishes up to a higher shine and offers more protection against scuffs.

They are indeed both made by Sara Lee
 
Messages
11,579
Location
Covina, Califonia 91722
Penetrating!

matei said:
I had a problem with the neutral polish - the hard stuff in the tin. It would flake off into a white powder where the leather flexed, and it looked awful. If I melted the polish into the leather with me wife's blowdryer it was OK... just OK...

*****
A friend of mine told me:
one problem is that many shoes when shipped new have a lacquer like coating on the outside that prevents polishes and cremes from penetrating into the leather.

That friend of mine used to use some stuff to wipe down new shoes to get the "lacquer" off before polishing them.

Otherwise the creme or polish did not penetrate and would sit above the lacquer and dry as its own layer of gunk.
 

carebear

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,220
Location
Anchorage, AK
http://www.valpo.edu/afrotc/Shoe_shining.htm#Strip off

Here's a good link to "how to" start a new pair of shoes. I kind of assume the higher grade of shoe is less likely to come with a protective lacquer but stripping what's on there shouldn't hurt in any event.

Fleur,

It is weird to me that many women buy so many shoes but put little to no effort into maintenance. I guess most aren't ever taught how and (if many of my friends are typical) just buy a new pair as older ones get worn.

One thing my ex (well, all of them) really appreciated was my love of polishing shoes (US citizens, that's your tax dollars at work :D ).

A little time and effort and they could wear the boots they loved but that just looked too bad now. I think Nordie's is the only store up here that does it but there are stores that have shoe shines in them who can do your shoes while you wait and might take in drop-off work. A real shine man can do magic things to shoes.
 
Messages
11,579
Location
Covina, Califonia 91722
Shine, lady?

I have done the shoe shine boy routine for a old girl friend of mine, and it is true many women don't seem to equate a good clean and polish with the long life of a shoe or boot.

Lincoln makes a good shoe polish too and their black seems to be one of the best going.

A top notch well stocked shoe shine kit is a thing of joy!
 

Fleur De Guerre

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,056
Location
Walton on Thames, UK
Thanks for the replies guys. I will give the polishing a whirl, and if the scuffs still look bad I may take them into a cobblers. They need resoling anyway, so perhaps if I go to a proper place they can sort the two things out for me together!
 

matei

One Too Many
Messages
1,022
Location
England
I do the shoe-shining (and dishwasing) in the house, for me & my wife.

When I was in the Army we actually were instructed to strip the "laquer" off of our class A shoes and put the polish on ourselves. That filled up a few good hours...

I did the same with my brown Tricker's brogues, but no matter what the clear polish I got (and I tried several brands) would always flake unless I melted it. No bother, switched to the Meltonian now and I'm very happy!
 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,640
Messages
3,085,597
Members
54,471
Latest member
rakib
Top