Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Is that a fake Belstaff Trialmaster?

Marc mndt

I'll Lock Up
Messages
7,315
With a fashion brand. the brand itself seems to be what pulls in the money - most consumers, I think, don't really care where something is made.
I'm not sure I agree on this. I used to work as a sales associate for Ralph Lauren, which is a fashion brand imo. RL had clothing produced in England, Italy, USA, China and low wage countries like Pakistan, India and others.

Most of RL's customers were very educated and knew exactly what they were buying and where and by whom it was produced. If they bought a cashmere sweater which was made in Italy, they knew it was produced by Loro Piana. If they bought a Polo suit made in Italy they knew it was produced by Corneliani. Purple label shoes were made by Edward Green and most customers knew.

I had customers who were ready to buy some jacket but changed their mind when they saw it was made in China. Most sensitive to country of origin were the Chinese. Chinese did not want to buy anything made in China.

I guess this awareness is stronger amongst buyers of high end fashion.
 

Edward

Bartender
Messages
25,078
Location
London, UK
I'm not sure I agree on this. I used to work as a sales associate for Ralph Lauren, which is a fashion brand imo. RL had clothing produced in England, Italy, USA, China and low wage countries like Pakistan, India and others.

Most of RL's customers were very educated and knew exactly what they were buying and where and by whom it was produced. If they bought a cashmere sweater which was made in Italy, they knew it was produced by Loro Piana. If they bought a Polo suit made in Italy they knew it was produced by Corneliani. Purple label shoes were made by Edward Green and most customers knew.

I had customers who were ready to buy some jacket but changed their mind when they saw it was made in China. Most sensitive to country of origin were the Chinese. Chinese did not want to buy anything made in China.

I guess this awareness is stronger amongst buyers of high end fashion.

Higher end stuff it may well make a difference, to be fair. The Chinese are a canny lot - you'll not as a rule catch them spending big money abroad on things that they can buy much more cheaply at home. I suspect they're also well aware of the mark-up a designer name has against even a very fair local wage.
 

Marc mndt

I'll Lock Up
Messages
7,315
you'll not as a rule catch them spending big money abroad on things that they can buy much more cheaply at home. I suspect they're also well aware of the mark-up a designer name has against even a very fair local wage.
I actually asked a couple of them why they're not interested in 'made in china' clothing. They see the 'made in China' label as a signifier for inferior quality.
 

robrinay

One Too Many
Messages
1,490
Location
Sheffield UK
Slightly off (the topic of the), thread - but I’ve got a Barbour To Ki To hunting jacket labelled ‘Made in China it’s absolutely identical apart from the colour to another my son has which has no country of origin label. I’m pretty sure both are genuine. Ps neither is waxed cotton. I believe the waxed cotton garments are made in the U.K. factory.
 
Last edited:

Edward

Bartender
Messages
25,078
Location
London, UK
Slightly off (the topic of the), thread - but I’ve got a Barbour To Ki To hunting jacket labelled ‘Made in China it’s absolutely identical apart from the colour to another my son has which has no country of origin label. I’m pretty sure both are genuine. Ps neither is waxed cotton. I believe the waxed cotton garments are made in the U.K. factory.

Barbour's International was always every bit as good as the Belstaff Trialmaster, and generally markedly cheaper. Some debate about who came up with the design first of course, but then it might not even have been either. This is a style which pretty much every British motorcycle clothing company did a version of back in the day, whether waxed cotton or leather or both. Unlike Belstaff, however, I don't think Barbour ever 'modernised' theirs to include armour, which is likely why Belstaff have continued to be thought of as producing serious motorcycle gear and Barbour have been relegated more to the fashion market.
 

Leyomi

New in Town
Messages
25
I just got the jacket so here are some pictures: some details are very odd, the interior of the tag for instance, or even the inner part of the pockets, I think the leather isn't genuine, could you help me?


Iiiiiii.jpg
image000000.jpg
Iii.jpg
image00000.jpg
image00.jpg
 

Mich486

One Too Many
Messages
1,690
If you can’t tell it apart from an original then it means it’s good enough :p honestly looks legit but if I had so many doubts I’ll just move on.
 

Doctor Damage

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,321
Location
Ontario
If you can’t tell it apart from an original then it means it’s good enough
This is a point I always make in another forum whenever someone asks about fake Burberry trench coats, etc. There's a belief that if you buy a used Burberry coat then of course it's fake. Except Burberry has been a popular brand for 40 or 50 years and have sold gawd knows how many coats, in fact they've probably sold more coats than there's been fakes made of them. And if the questionable coat you're looking at is made of high quality materials, has the right silhouette, the patterns/lining all line up, and the stitching is perfect, then it's just as good as the real thing so who cares?
 

Seb Lucas

I'll Lock Up
Messages
7,562
Location
Australia
I'm not sure I agree on this. I used to work as a sales associate for Ralph Lauren, which is a fashion brand imo. RL had clothing produced in England, Italy, USA, China and low wage countries like Pakistan, India and others.

I had customers who were ready to buy some jacket but changed their mind when they saw it was made in China. Most sensitive to country of origin were the Chinese. Chinese did not want to buy anything made in China.

I guess this awareness is stronger amongst buyers of high end fashion.

I guess this is too small a sample to base a worldview on but I hear you. Some people just buy a brand and don't look further. They may well be disappointed to find 'China' printed there as this doesn't seem special or exclusive - if that's what they are going for. I wonder too if RL shoppers tend to be a particular group.

I am interested in the changing nature of 'fashion'. Do you have a working definition for what this means these days? What makes something a fashion brand? I tend to use it as a put down - something brand based and fashionable in a mainstream subculture (if you can find them still).
I just got the jacket so here are some pictures: some details are very odd, the interior of the tag for instance, or even the inner part of the pockets, I think the leather isn't genuine, could you help me?


Iiiiiii.jpg
image000000.jpg
Iii.jpg
image00000.jpg
image00.jpg

Take a deep breath, L, real leather, totally fine.
 

Marc mndt

I'll Lock Up
Messages
7,315
I guess this is too small a sample to base a worldview
I've worked for three other high end luxury brands. Same story, customers don't want something that is produced in a low wage country. If you're buying Hermès or Louis Vuitton, you want it to be made in France. Prada, made in Italy. Etc.
 

Marc mndt

I'll Lock Up
Messages
7,315
One of the brands I worked for once experimented with having some suits produced in China. Although less expensive, they were clearly better constructed than the ones made in Italy. And even though I could easily point this out to customers, the suits didn't sell too well and the China made product line was discontinued after one season.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,144
Messages
3,075,068
Members
54,124
Latest member
usedxPielt
Top