Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

If you only had one old rifle, which?

carebear

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,220
Location
Anchorage, AK
jamespowers said:
Aw come on. A few miles radius isn't long range enough for you? :p The 460 is a beast but it doesn't kick that much. The spitting fire and smoke.....well, you might have something there. :p

Regards,

J

I'll trade the extra rifle weight, recoil, smoke/noise/flash and yes, even energy for a darn near 500 yd point blank range over a 6' and rapidly increasing drop at 500.

The 168 gr .30 cal round doesn't drop that much until it's out at about 800 and is a proven 1000 yard cartridge.
 

Fatdutchman

Practically Family
Messages
559
Location
Kentucky
If one is really looking for a "do all" rifle (which doesn't really exist), my own thought is this: A Marlin 1894 in .44 magnum. Plenty good for deer sized game, but not ridiculously overpowered for small game, rabbits and squirrels. Pretty much a modern-caliber equivalent of a .44-40 lever rifle, which was once, THE popular choice. I intend to get one of these myself...eventually.
 
Fatdutchman said:
If one is really looking for a "do all" rifle (which doesn't really exist), my own thought is this: A Marlin 1894 in .44 magnum. Plenty good for deer sized game, but not ridiculously overpowered for small game, rabbits and squirrels. Pretty much a modern-caliber equivalent of a .44-40 lever rifle, which was once, THE popular choice. I intend to get one of these myself...eventually.

That sounds like a good choice now that you mention it. I just hope you don't have to stone the action to get the lever to operate smoothly like you have to with the Winchesters---til this day. :eusa_doh:

Regards,

J
 
carebear said:
To quote Bart Simpson, "Who wants to build character? Let's quit!".
jamespowers said:
Ok, ok. We'll leave character and muscle out of it. :D
Who has time for building character and muscle when the ChiComs are invading, or the Mutant Zombie MallNinja hordes are loose? Gimme a proven, rapidly-repeatable, long-range reach-out-and-touch-someone one-shot-stop every time, personally...:D

Oh, and a belt-fed buzzsaw for close-in defense.
 

The Wingnut

One Too Many
Messages
1,711
Location
.
Coming in late in this conversation, there is no ONE rifle that can do it all. You're better off having a few for various purposes.

If I was FORCED to choose just one, it would likely be something bolt or lever action in a common military cartridge with a sizable magazine, such as my father's converted .30-06 K98.
 

Mark G

A-List Customer
Messages
342
Location
Camel, California
I agree with Carebear and others on the board that 30-06 would be a good choice for a single rifle as it will take any game in North America. It comes in a myriad of load choices including a sabot .22, and you can buy ammo in any K-Mart.

It also comes in so many choices of guns, new or used. From single shots, bolt, and even lever (Win model '95) For a new gun, I'd probably go with a Remington 700, as for an older gun, if you can afford it, a pre-'64 Winchester 70 or a Belgian made FN 98. You would probably want to scope it but that's a whole other hornets nest.
 

Fatdutchman

Practically Family
Messages
559
Location
Kentucky
jamespowers said:
That sounds like a good choice now that you mention it. I just hope you don't have to stone the action to get the lever to operate smoothly like you have to with the Winchesters---til this day. :eusa_doh:

Regards,

J

The Winchester '94 is like a Rube Goldberg device. Twice as many parts as really required. It functions, and is reliable, I suppose, but that's about all I can say about them (now I've made somebody mad! :p )
I am a major Marlin fan. Ten times the gun a Winchester is. Smooth, slick, and lock up like a bank vault.
 

Rooster

Practically Family
Messages
917
Location
Iowa
One gun I've always wanted but never had. I'd like a WWI 8mm mauser that was profesionally sporterized between the wars. I've seen some really nice ones that have some classic lines. I'd prefere something with high quality peep sights instead of a scope, a scope really clutters up the lines of a rifle.
 

Fletch

I'll Lock Up
Messages
8,865
Location
Iowa - The Land That Stuff Forgot
Harp said:
The bayonet stub on the M16A1 can be used to open a cold bottle of Miller Lite Beer. :D
That's another thing I notice about you firearms loyalists...poor taste in adult beverages (not to mention poor timing of same).

If I had to own a rifle it would be my dad's .22, because I wouldn't shoot at anything bigger than a river rat (at least not with intent to hit it). Besides, if you accidentally peg a human being in the butt, the round can be dug out with a pocketknife.

Ouch.
 

Fatdutchman

Practically Family
Messages
559
Location
Kentucky
I've been wanting an 88-type sporter rifle, like was made by Haenel and others. 8mm Normal. Pretty things.

I'm not a scope fan, either. Maybe it's just because you don't see scopes on 18th century rifles!
 

Rooster

Practically Family
Messages
917
Location
Iowa
I've had a couple military configuration M88's in the past. Very smooth actions and very accurate rifles. there again, I've seen some early made sportered 88's that were extreamly cool.
Fletch. I don't drink, with or with out rifles. Booze and guns never mix. When they do, you usually hear something like "what do you think will happen if I do this?" Yep, it's all fun and games till somebody gets an eye poked out.;)
It isn't guns that make people stupid, it's the booze... or, more than likely, some people are just naturally stupid, not much can be done about that.[huh]
 

Harp

I'll Lock Up
Messages
8,508
Location
Chicago, IL US
Fletch said:
That's another thing I notice about you firearms loyalists...poor taste in adult beverages (not to mention poor timing of same).


Ex-Special Forces, and previous comment about opening a beer against an M16 stub was made in jest, from past professional and responsible usage. Did not intend to advocate irresponsible conduct. :rolleyes:
 

Story

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,056
Location
Home
Fatdutchman said:
I've been wanting an 88-type sporter rifle, like was made by Haenel and others. 8mm Normal. Pretty things.

I'm not a scope fan, either. Maybe it's just because you don't see scopes on 18th century rifles!

Since the man is too modest:

For those wanting a custom-built Germanic/Germanic-influenced muzzleloader, Fatdutchman is the man to see.

His work is truely old world magic & his rates quite reasonable.


eg
Twolocks.jpg
 

Story

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,056
Location
Home
Doug C said:
Anyone have suggestions or just advice in general for a complete newb?
Doug C

Doug,
You can learn alot in the presence of local shooting folks, most of whom are quite friendly and will let you try their weapons.

PM me with your locality, and I'll innundate you with links.

As a follow-on question, what do you want to do with your rifle?
Target shoot?
Hunt?
Protection?

General P.S.A. - the OCM has stopped selling Garands for the rest of the year. Looks like they're sinking their available man-hours into blowing out the M-1 Carbines.
 
Messages
11,579
Location
Covina, Califonia 91722
Sub gun ammo

Diamondback said:
(NATO ammo is generally hotter-loaded than the civilian market--DO NOT put 9mm NATO through something only rated for Parabellum/Luger, unlesss you wanna spend a while picking shrapnel outta your face!)...:D
******
Actually this is a bit of a misnomer. There is / was 9mm that was hot loaded for use in submachine guns and machine pistols and would drive the heavier bolt. It was hot but in a well made pistol it was just a bit hotter than plusP. I seem to recall that the Israelis make some for use in the Uzi. Put a few boxes thru the Taurus 92 some years back and it barked and snarled like a pissed off Rottwieler. You'd know the difference between regular ball and it but again very similar to plusP.
 

Duck

Practically Family
Messages
751
Location
Arkansas
30-06

Remington 700 in 30-06. It can take anything in North America and has taken quite a bit in Africa.
Best all-around caliber. IMHO
 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,000
Messages
3,072,423
Members
54,038
Latest member
GloriaJama
Top