Owning more than a dozen pairs (in total) from both brands that you mentioned (plus a couple of Carmina's as well), I'd say that quality wise all three brands are indeed comparable (handgrade C&J is another story), with C&J being better in QC and finishing, attention to detail, while with Alden and Carmina quite often there are details that though not structural faults they are not expected at their price point.
I love both CJ's and Alden's.
Happy to echo that, I own two pairs of Alden boots at this point, a more rugged Indy on a lug sole and a cap toe on the Grant last, both Horween chamois (the former rough out, the latter smooth). Construction is perfect. Thinking of a black Cordovan cap toe next, Grant last again. Really nice last, versatile, can dress up or down a little.
I hear ya man. I had them send me a copy of my old orders last week. I bought a pair of farmer ranches from them 2016 cost about 450 new if I recall correctly.
I love the roughout / smoothout combo. Some nice graining going on already on those shafts. Imagine how they'll look with some patina on them. (My Bright engineers picked up patina fairly quickly).
John Lofgren Monkey Boots Shinki Horsebuttt - $1,136 The classic monkey boot silhouette in an incredibly rich Shinki russet horse leather. 
Grant Stone Diesel Boot Dark Olive Chromexcel - $395 Goodyear welted, Horween Chromexcel, classic good looks. 
Schott 568 Vandals Jacket - $1,250 The classic Perfecto motorcycle jacket, in a very special limited-edition Schott double rider style.
