Fit Check Thread for Jackets

[Canuck Panda]

I now own 2 cross zip aviator jackets. I can only keep 1 as my collection is spiraling out of control. Which one do you think fits better? Which would you keep?

Rainbow country:

View attachment 670096

Schott:
View attachment 670097

The rainbow country has the much nicer leather but the schott is cheaper (so would get more cash back if I sell the RC)

The Schott actually has more V shape when I look closely and not get blinded by the leather difference. The Rainbow obviously has better leather and the not often seen front design, but I had this jacket and I felt it could have a straight front hem instead of the front drop, given it’s half belt length. If I can find another brown ponyboy in a size up I would definitely get it altered in the front length.
Aviators, off rack ones are hard to get it perfect…

 

[newtojackets]

The Schott actually has more V shape when I look closely and not get blinded by the leather difference. The Rainbow obviously has better leather and the not often seen front design, but I had this jacket and I felt it could have a straight front hem instead of the front drop, given it’s half belt length. If I can find another brown ponyboy in a size up I would definitely get it altered in the front length.
Aviators, off rack ones are hard to get it perfect…

That’s what I thought, schott fits better but leather on it is quite mediocre. Agreed a slightly shorter front length would have been better

 

[Canuck Panda]

Hi Guys, new here and getting into the world of leather jackets. I just came back from Japan where I bought a Buzz Rickson Roughwear A2 in size 38. I'm about 5'8" fairly slim and 140lbs and I'm wondering if this looks too big? The arms are a bit roomy, torso feels snug when zipped up. My Buzz Rickson peacoat is a 36 that fits really nicely but when I tried on the A2 in size 36 I believe it was a bit too short. Any thoughts would be appreciated! Looking forward to learning


View attachment 670272 View attachment 670273 View attachment 670274 View attachment 670276 View attachment 670277

The current RMC house A2 is slim fit. Toys McCoy A2‘s are generally more V shape slim fit too. Rainbow Country A2 is also slimmer fit. Just compared the posted dimensions of the same tag size, the buzz will be one size narrower in the shoulder compared to these three other brands.

However, when it comes to A2 jackets, there is no good or bad fit imo. I had a Dubow repro A2 and it fitted exactly like your Buzz. And I have other contracts that’s literally fit like a wide box with elastic at the bottom. I like them all. A2 is not a cafe racer, as long as it’s comfortable to wear you’re ok.

 

[dudewuttheheck]

Depending on the A2, RMC makes a slim A2; as my limited understanding goes, the original A2s and one-to-one replicas are not the slimmest since these A2s are based on a pattern from the 30s-40s.

Edit: Then again, I just purchased a Monarch G-1 from the 50s, and it fits pretty trim.

Yes I've had the slimmer rmc a2. It's still not as slim as other jackets, but yes it's certainly slimmer than most A2 jackets.

@newb yeah a size down probably would be too short on you.

 

[LA23beswak]

Rainbow country highwayman size 40.

 

[Herrvallmo]

Rainbow country highwayman size 40.

Seems to fit you great!

 

[Bennarion]

Rainbow country highwayman size 40.

Perfect. Wear it with pleasure

 

[LA23beswak]

Seems to fit you great!

Seems to fit you great!

Thank you!