Fit Check Thread for Jackets

[4444Design]

Thank you! I've been having a hard time finding a World War II peacoat that fits me well. This is the largest size I've found, but most of them seem a bit too small. Maybe people were smaller back then? If I can’t find one that fits, I’m seriously considering the Real McCoys 1913 peacoat, which feels a bit crazy. I usually don’t think about buying anything other than a leather jacket from those high-end brands, but I really love the World War One peacoat design; it’s my favorite and quite hard to find.

I appreciate your opinion because that coat has always felt a bit awkward to wear. I can barely fit an L.L. Bean sweater underneath it, let alone a chunky wool sweater.

It is indeed difficult to find wartime peacoats in a larger size - i manged to get one in 46 which is pretty snug on me (1.90 / 100 kg) even though it is a larger size but as long as there is no other option i will definately keep ...

I own a cheaper repop from STURM as well which runs larger - see pics for comparison


Original size 46

STURM repop size "L"

 

[WolfofStateSt]

For sure the Billy Reid fits better, not solely because of the sleeve length.

Yeah, then I think I'll keep the Billy Reid and give the other Peacoat to my friend, who has been looking for one for a while. Having too many peacoats or coats in general will probably give me decision fatigue—the Billy Reid is by no means a bad coat, either.

It really ultimately comes down to what you're comfortable with in the end. They're shorter than I could live with, but that's me...




I'm not one for definitive statements on what is necessary at certain temperatures, as we're all different: you'll find plenty of folks will queue up to tell you an Irvin or a B3 is "overkill for London Winter", but both proved ideal for me. Some folks find a longer winter jacket preferable to keep the spine end warmer on the go, or because they're wearing a blazer underneath, so it's all relative really. If the IH N1 is a good length for you and is heavy enough for you in that cold, though, it's definitely a good option.

It is going to drop to -7 degrees this week. I’ll see how I feel in my Parka and my Deck Jacket. That will decide if I buy another Parka after retiring this one. There are plenty of vintage N3Bs at reasonable prices compared to the repro heritage market.

I bought a used Canada Goose jacket on eBay a while back for a couple of hundred dollars, but I couldn't even zip it up because it was too small. I returned it and thankfully received a full refund. Now that I've had one in hand, I can confidently say that I will never buy another Canada Goose jacket again, unless something unexpected occurs.

 

[handymike]

When I lived in NYC, the N3-B was my Winter coat- Spiewak Golden Fleece purchased at a military surplus store on Third (or Park Ave. S).

 

[Peter Mackin]

When I was in new York for a couple of days I went to the surplus store up near the bus station in hells kitchen looking for a N3-b,nothing doing unfortunately.

 

[WolfofStateSt]

When I was in new York for a couple of days I went to the surplus store up near the bus station in hells kitchen looking for a N3-b,nothing doing unfortunately.

I recently bought an M47 Army Parka from Queens. It was a big mistake; it smells interesting…

Reselling it.

 

[WolfofStateSt]

I am just going through my wardrobe deciding what to keep. Here are two RM jackets I think fit me great. Wonder what y’all think. Plus any more opinions on the Billy Reid Peacoat. I think these are all keepers, had these jackets for a few years.

 

[Will Zach]

I am just going through my wardrobe deciding what to keep. Here are two RM jackets I think fit me great. Wonder what y’all think. Plus any more opinions on the Billy Reid Peacoat. I think these are all keepers, had these jackets for a few years.

Nice wardrobe, dude. I like the shearling fit a lot, but maybe the sleeves are a bit short? Normally I would say these are okay on the shorter side, but in winter maybe you want your wrists covered... Check that, gloves will take care of that.

 

[WolfofStateSt]

Nice wardrobe, dude. I like the shearling fit a lot, but maybe the sleeves are a bit short? Normally I would say these are okay on the shorter side, but in winter maybe you want your wrists covered... Check that, gloves will take care of that.

Yeah, I think these all fit very well. Of the jackets I have posted, the shearling B3 sleeves are much better than the rest. I also have a Baracuta G9, but I know that fits fine.

I’m debating whether it is time to pass on the WW2 USN Peacoat. I have plenty of coats, and I’m unsure of the fit. It feels tighter than the Billy Reid. On the fence probably means it will go ngl.

@Peacoat I would consider you the expect, what be your final verdict on my WW2 Peacoat? Being that you said it is a size or two too small; I should probably get rid of it?

 

[newtojackets]

I am just going through my wardrobe deciding what to keep. Here are two RM jackets I think fit me great. Wonder what y’all think. Plus any more opinions on the Billy Reid Peacoat. I think these are all keepers, had these jackets for a few years.

Alll fit you great (though I’m of the personal view that A2s in general are unflattering).

The B-3 and pea coat look amazing

 

[WolfofStateSt]

Alll fit you great (though I’m of the personal view that A2s in general are unflattering).

The B-3 and pea coat look amazing

Luckily for me, the A2 is stuck in Japanese customs right now. I can see that view; A2s are generally boxy, although the RM pattern is a bit more modern cut. I think A2s look better than G-1s or any other leather flight jacket outside of the B3.

 

[newtojackets]

Luckily for me, the A2 is stuck in Japanese customs right now. I can see that view; A2s are generally boxy, although the RM pattern is a bit more modern cut. I think A2s look better than G-1s or any other leather flight jacket outside of the B3.

I actually think a well fitting G-1 can look quite good. I own a wool G-1 from schott and think it’s my best fitting jacket!

I think the B-3 would look amazing with slightly looser jeans (as B-3s are quite big), but like i said fits you great

 

[WolfofStateSt]

I actually think a well fitting G-1 can look quite good. I own a wool G-1 from schott and think it’s my best fitting jacket!

I think the B-3 would look amazing with slightly looser jeans (as B-3s are quite big), but like i said fits you great

Thank you for the compliment! It means a lot.

Is the G-1’s body made out of wool or just the collar? If the outer shell is wool and not leather, that is unique, and I would love to see a picture.

I had a Schott 594, an excellent jacket. I picked it up for $200, 80% off. It was built like a tank, had a superb fit, and was warm and cozy. I gave it to a friend because I felt guilty for hoarding so many cool leather jackets.

 

[newtojackets]

Thank you for the compliment! It means a lot.

Is the G-1’s body made out of wool or just the collar? If the outer shell is wool and not leather, that is unique, and I would love to see a picture.

I had a Schott 594, an excellent jacket. I picked it up for $200, 80% off. It was built like a tank, had a superb fit, and was warm and cozy. I gave it to a friend because I felt guilty for hoarding so many cool leather jackets.

The body is actually made of wool, which I love!

(This is an old photo, I don’t wear jeans this skinny anymore)

 

[Herrvallmo]

I am just going through my wardrobe deciding what to keep. Here are two RM jackets I think fit me great. Wonder what y’all think. Plus any more opinions on the Billy Reid Peacoat. I think these are all keepers, had these jackets for a few years.

All looks good! keepers in my eyes at least


Cheers!

 

[WolfofStateSt]

The body is actually made of wool, which I love!

(This is an old photo, I don’t wear jeans this skinny anymore)

View attachment 674207 View attachment 674208

That is a great looking jacket, almost looks like something Pendleton would put out, but without the loud patterns. Fits you well too, Schott never disappoints.

 

[WolfofStateSt]

I think the fit on this French Peacoat I bought near Amsterdam is also better than the USN Peacoat I posted a few days ago:

 

[Liam_Og]

This

looks nice!

 

[WolfofStateSt]

People here were mentioning that Iron Heart would be a good brand for my body. Any here have any experience with their L2B jacket?

 

[OldManFung]

I just got this Flat Head Double Rider and I'm torn on whether the shoulders are too broad for my body. Thoughts?

 

[Herrvallmo]

I just got this Flat Head Double Rider and I'm torn on whether the shoulders are too broad for my body. Thoughts?

View attachment 675744 View attachment 675745 View attachment 675746 View attachment 675747

Looks great in my eyes! wouldn't say the shoulders are to broad at all!

Cheers!