Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Eastman Roadstar review

siddhartha

Familiar Face
Messages
63
Location
USA
I always wanted to try the Eastman Roadstar, and I decided not too long ago to give one a go. I contacted Eastman, gave them my measurements (5’9”, 176lbs, athletic build, with a 34” waist) and decided on a size 46...
About a month later, I decided a size 44 would probably be better. Even with the slimmer size, I think I’m somewhere between a true 42 and 44, so that size would probably work. Rob at Eastman thought so, too, so I waited my turn...
Total time from order to arrival was around 6 weeks. I chose the black “Warhorse” leather, and no customizations. Size 44 was entered. I got word from Rob/Eastman that the jacket shipped out, and within about 3 days, it arrived on the doorstep.
Opening the box, the fantastic smell of the leather greeted me. Now, I’m a pretty tactile person, and really get in to the details like leather feel, smell, etc. I’ve never had another jacket that smelled as nice as this one. I had a used RMCJP A-2 that similarly smelled wonderful, but this one trumps it!
At first, I was a little disappointed at the perceived thickness of the leather-it felt on the thinner side. (For reference, my Aero “King of the Road” jacket is approx. 6.5lbs in horsehide, and the Eastman “Roadstar” is about 4.5lbs in horsehide). It was quite stiff however, such that I initially thought I might have made a mistake on sizing. Within a few days, the leather started to relax a bit, and now, about a month or so later, the jacket fits like a glove. The leather too, gives me a much, much nicer impression-it is thick enough for the purpose, and molds quite well. The grain that you get with the leather is outstanding, and well worth the trouble of breaking it in. It reminds me of the high-quality leather shoes I’d get, that initially felt unforgiving, but soon became a favorite.


As you can see, the leather is already developing fantastic grain, and a beautiful wrinkling effect.

The Roadstar does not copy any one historic jacket 100%, but appears very similar to the traditional Buco D-pocket jackets. It does not have rear passenger pockets, for example. Also, it doesn’t have a full “bi-swing” back, it has the “action back” or shoulder gussets only. This is a feature I like: it keeps the clean lines of a non-gusseted back, but you have freedom of movement that the shoulder gussets offer.


It also does not have any decoration on the shoulder epaulets-they are simple in design. The one detail that shows a bit of decoration is the dice keychain attached to the pocket-easily removed if it’s not your thing. All zippers are Talons, in contrast to what’s listed on Eastman’s site-a quick email to Rob, and he explained the Kwik zips offered on the description weren’t as accurate for the time period intended for the Roadstar. In any case, they look great, and operate beautifully.



The liner is wool plaid, and is very pleasing to my eye. Not thick, but comfortable, and appealing. The sleeves are lined with simple cotton drill, in a brown color. All pockets are lined in heavy cotton drill.


I have worn the jacket a lot since receiving it, rotating it a bit with another jacket (which will follow in a later review). The more I wear it, the more I like it. It is definitely a different “feel” than any Aero jacket that I own, and it’s nice to have the option to choose among them.

So the “big question” for those fans of moto jackets out there-would I buy this one again? The answer is yes-it is a beautiful jacket. However, there are some things to note:
If you are all about thick, horsehide leather, there are other options out there that might work better. This one does not strike you as being as “bombproof” as the FQHH of the Aeros I have owned and seen. But, don’t let that be a strike against it-it is simply a different type of horsehide, and one that you’d probably be quite happy with.
Things I’d change? Not too much, really: I might like a tighter lining in the sleeves, a bit more thickness to the liner in the body (not really sure about this one-it’s nice as is, but would be a bit warmer with thicker lining...that said, it’d be a bit warm in warmer weather...hmmmm), maybe include the belt (which I’ve read is an option-I don’t use belts though on this type of jacket) for completeness. Some people might prefer a heavier-gauge zipper on the front, but this one works well, and is super-smooth in operation. I have no misgivings about the zippers.
I definitely recommend this one for people into the D-pocket style, and think it ranks right up there with the other premium makers. At that level, it’s mostly personal preference that will dictate your choice, which is what it’s really about anyways...
 

deluxestyling

One of the Regulars
Messages
217
Location
Suburbia. London
Wonderful jacket and thanks for the detailed write up. I was just saying to a friend the other night while talking about motorcycle jackets that for me the Eastman Roadstar would be my choice.

I believe that Eastman have plans to expand their motorcycle range with other items so hopefully some more top stuff to come.
 

Tomek

New in Town
Messages
11
Location
Warsaw
Thanks a lot for your detailed review !

I have ordered this same jacket one month ago, in walnut brown.

Being 5'11", 180lbs, 42' chest, 33.5 waist, I knew I was in between a 42 and 44 in size, but after a quick call to ELC, and couple of e-mails, I opted eventually for a size 42... Hopefully it won't be too snug... I intend to wear the jacket only with a T-shirt or a thin sweater, and since the Schott 689, known to be cut trim, fits me perfectly in size 42 (this is the only leather garment I could use as a benchmark), I thought it would be the case as well for the Eastman Roadstar.

Answer in 1 month I guess.

Siddhartha, how do you feel in your 44 jacket ? Is is really snug or do you still have room at the shoulders/chest/waist level ?
 

Fanch

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,490
Location
Texas
Very nice looking jacket and excellent review. You spent a great deal of time and thought in the process, which is reflected in your write up. I think that I recall seeing you on Tz in the past.
 

siddhartha

Familiar Face
Messages
63
Location
USA
Thanks a lot for your detailed review !

I have ordered this same jacket one month ago, in walnut brown.

Being 5'11", 180lbs, 42' chest, 33.5 waist, I knew I was in between a 42 and 44 in size, but after a quick call to ELC, and couple of e-mails, I opted eventually for a size 42... Hopefully it won't be too snug... I intend to wear the jacket only with a T-shirt or a thin sweater, and since the Schott 689, known to be cut trim, fits me perfectly in size 42 (this is the only leather garment I could use as a benchmark), I thought it would be the case as well for the Eastman Roadstar.

Answer in 1 month I guess.

Siddhartha, how do you feel in your 44 jacket ? Is is really snug or do you still have room at the shoulders/chest/waist level ?

Hi Tomek,

I find the jacket fits me snug, but not too tight. It's a different fit than the modern "baggy" fit that many of us grew up with. I prefer it to be more fitted. I think I'm not quite at the "leather shirt" fit preference yet, but I do prefer the more fitted jackets.

There's variety among the makers, too, so a 44 for me in this style might be a 46 in another maker, or a 42 (like I'm going with on the Aero J106).

Best,

Chris
 

siddhartha

Familiar Face
Messages
63
Location
USA
Very nice looking jacket and excellent review. You spent a great deal of time and thought in the process, which is reflected in your write up. I think that I recall seeing you on Tz in the past.

Hi Fanch,

Yes, I'm on there, too. Watches and leather jackets...seems like more than a couple of us have the same crossovers...
 

Edward

Bartender
Messages
25,066
Location
London, UK
Interesting review. I recently picked up on on eBay. I suspect mine is an earlier version, from back when Eastman did these originally (they were off the catalogue for a decade or so). Mine is also a 44. Good fit on me (comparable to my Aero MC in a 42). Only snag is just how snug the waist is (even tighter than an Aero 30s halfbelt!!, as the Aero MC is too). I'm in the process of losing some weight, though, so all being well it'll be grand. Pretty chunky zip on the main one - not sure if it has been replaced at a time (if so, it ha been very, very well done). The lining in mine is nylon - look quilted, but while it has the characteristic diamond patter stitching it doesn't feel like there is any 'stuffing' behind that. I must get some photos up soon...
 
Messages
10,181
Location
Pasadena, CA
Hi Fanch,Yes, I'm on there, too. Watches and leather jackets...seems like more than a couple of us have the same crossovers...
Worse than crack & coke I reckon. Those are markedly cheaper. Very nice jacket. I dig the lining a lot. Would like some,pics of it on when you can!
 

Fanch

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,490
Location
Texas
Hi Fanch,

Yes, I'm on there, too. Watches and leather jackets...seems like more than a couple of us have the same crossovers...

Yep, leather jackets and watches can be addicting. Although the particular style of jacket that you showed is not one that I would wear, the overall construction and design is outstanding. Again, I commend you on your fantastic review, one of the best that I have seen in quite awhile, and would love to see you do the same on the FL with other jackets that you own.
 

siddhartha

Familiar Face
Messages
63
Location
USA
Yep, leather jackets and watches can be addicting. Although the particular style of jacket that you showed is not one that I would wear, the overall construction and design is outstanding. Again, I commend you on your fantastic review, one of the best that I have seen in quite awhile, and would love to see you do the same on the FL with other jackets that you own.

Thanks for the kind words-I will do more reviews. In fact, I've been working on a couple, and once put together, they will be posted here, and over on VLJ.

Best,

Chris
 

siddhartha

Familiar Face
Messages
63
Location
USA
Interesting review. I recently picked up on on eBay. I suspect mine is an earlier version, from back when Eastman did these originally (they were off the catalogue for a decade or so). Mine is also a 44. Good fit on me (comparable to my Aero MC in a 42). Only snag is just how snug the waist is (even tighter than an Aero 30s halfbelt!!, as the Aero MC is too). I'm in the process of losing some weight, though, so all being well it'll be grand. Pretty chunky zip on the main one - not sure if it has been replaced at a time (if so, it ha been very, very well done). The lining in mine is nylon - look quilted, but while it has the characteristic diamond patter stitching it doesn't feel like there is any 'stuffing' behind that. I must get some photos up soon...

Please do!

Does yours have the belt, and does it have the rear passenger pockets?
 

tblay

One of the Regulars
Messages
167
Location
Bmore
Hi, siddhartha. I'm so glad to stumble onto your review. I've had my eye on this jacket for a while now. I'm trying to decide between a Belstaff Mojave (I appreciate the armor when I'm riding on the interstate, and it's of a proper thickness for a bike jacket, but I don't like having "Belstaff" plastered on the side, and I'm not sure the fit would be great), a custom Aero of some sort, and this Roadstar. Just a few quick questions:

I've heard from other people who ordered custom Aeros that their jacket didn't really fit that well. Was that your experience?

Also, the lining in this Roadstar is wool. Is it scratchy? Can you feel it through your shirt?

Do you ride in it? If so, is it generally comfortable?

I've also been thinking of something from Lewis Leathers. Any thoughts there?

Thanks so much for your time.
 
Last edited:

siddhartha

Familiar Face
Messages
63
Location
USA
Hi tblay,

I have an Aero J106 that I ordered through Insurrection. It is reviewed in the Insurrection thread-check it out! The fit on the Aero is actually better for me than the off-the-shelf Roadstar. Being in the US, I recommend Insurrection, as they are experts on fit, and handle all the details for the order through Aero. They even sent out a fit jacket for me to check size.

The wool on the Roadstar is thin, and not scratchy. I can wear it with a t-shirt, and the sleeves are actually lined in cotton, so even more comfy there.

I do not ride presently, with a almost 2-yr old daughter (my deal with my wife) and can only comment on both of these jackets in terms of day-to-day wear.

For me, I prefer the Aero. I like the weight of the leather better, the cut is better for me (shoulder gussets only, which are slimmer than the shoulder gussets on the Roadstar). I prefer the cotton drill lining on the Aero. The Roadstar is a bit more "refined" possibly, a bit lighter, and more of an exaggerated "V" shape. This fit works for me since losing weight/working out, but is a bit less forgiving than the Aero, which is a slightly straighter cut. The Roadstar is a larger tagged size, but the Aero fits a slight bit looser at the waist.

Having had them both for a bit now, I prefer the Aero, but the Roadstar is a fine jacket, too. It works better for me in warmer weather, as it is a bit thinner overall. If I was riding again, it would be the Aero, hands down

Chris

Hi, siddhartha. I'm so glad to stumble onto your review. I've had my eye on this jacket for a while now. I'm trying to decide between a Belstaff Mojave (I appreciate the armor when I'm riding on the interstate, and it's of a proper thickness for a bike jacket, but I don't like having "Belstaff" plastered on the side, and I'm not sure the fit would be great), a custom Aero of some sort, and this Roadstar. Just a few quick questions:

I've heard from other people who ordered custom Aeros that their jacket didn't really fit that well. Was that your experience?

Also, the lining in this Roadstar is wool. Is it scratchy? Can you feel it through your shirt?

Do you ride in it? If so, is it generally comfortable?

I've also been thinking of something from Lewis Leathers. Any thoughts there?

Thanks so much for your time.
 

tblay

One of the Regulars
Messages
167
Location
Bmore
Thanks so much, Chris. I appreciate you taking the time to answer my questions.

It sounds like Aero is the way to go. Though I'm a little concerned since I ride in Texas and, 10 months out of the year, it's warm enough to ride without a jacket, or with a really light one. That makes the Heavy FQHH seem pretty daunting. But I'm not really into the Mid-weight HH. I guess something's got to give here, and I'd rather be sweaty than scraped-up.

In terms of fit, I have a slim, athletic build, and I like a really tight fit in a leather jacket. I have an Eastman A-1 that fits me perfectly (why I was initially interested in the Roadstar). I've been looking at the Route 66 from Aero. Aside from its cheesy name, I think it would be pretty fantastic for me. It's quite a bit different from the "Perfecto" style, but I like how clean-cut and simple it looks. If I end up ordering one, I'll certainly go through Inception (which, I guess, has changed its name to Thurston Bros...?).

Thanks, again, for your help. I'll enjoy taking a look at your Aero J106 review too.

Glad to hear you're helping take care of your daughter, and yourself, too.

AT
 

siddhartha

Familiar Face
Messages
63
Location
USA
Hi AT,

If you think about it, the Roadstar is probably similiar in weight to the Aero midweight HH, so consider that in your decision.

They are very different jackets, and I really do like both of them. I could see someone's favorite being either, but for me, it's the Aero. I like the thicker leather, and can deal with being a little bit warmer-just unzip it when walking around, and perhaps unzip the top when riding? I also have a LW Easy Ryder (which I also reviewed here) which is heavier than the Eastman, and feels thicker than the Aero, but wears a bit cooler than either, so there's more going on than just leather weight.

I think you'd be happy with either. Keep in mind too that just because the Eastman A-1 fits well, does not mean you'll get the same exact fit with the Roadstar, as they're different patterns. I had a Hartmann that fit differently than the Roadstar, despite it being a smaller tagged size. I wear a 42, and took a 44 in the Roadstar.

The Route 66 is nice, reminds me of the Highwayman, which I do have too. I have a sz 46 Highwayman, but even if I had it in 42, it would be nowhere near the slim fit of the J106 or Roadstar. Different, more boxy cut.

Hope this helps

Chris

Thanks so much, Chris. I appreciate you taking the time to answer my questions.

It sounds like Aero is the way to go. Though I'm a little concerned since I ride in Texas and, 10 months out of the year, it's warm enough to ride without a jacket, or with a really light one. That makes the Heavy FQHH seem pretty daunting. But I'm not really into the Mid-weight HH. I guess something's got to give here, and I'd rather be sweaty than scraped-up.

In terms of fit, I have a slim, athletic build, and I like a really tight fit in a leather jacket. I have an Eastman A-1 that fits me perfectly (why I was initially interested in the Roadstar). I've been looking at the Route 66 from Aero. Aside from its cheesy name, I think it would be pretty fantastic for me. It's quite a bit different from the "Perfecto" style, but I like how clean-cut and simple it looks. If I end up ordering one, I'll certainly go through Inception (which, I guess, has changed its name to Thurston Bros...?).

Thanks, again, for your help. I'll enjoy taking a look at your Aero J106 review too.

Glad to hear you're helping take care of your daughter, and yourself, too.

AT
 

Forum statistics

Threads
108,998
Messages
3,072,386
Members
54,038
Latest member
GloriaJama
Top