Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

jlee562

I'll Lock Up
Messages
5,103
Location
San Francisco, CA
I've got a quick question (I hope). I want a 40's style fedora. The Stetson Whippet is just the style I'm looking for but I want dark gray. The Whippet only comes in light gray. Can you recommend a similar style fedora that I can get in dark gray? Thanks.

I assume you're referencing the modern Stetson Whippet only coming in grey? The Akubra Fed IV from hatsdirect.com is a 30's styled fedora which is similar to the modern whippet, but without the brim binding, and comes in carbon grey, which I would say is a dark grey.
 

zetwal

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,343
Location
Texas
I've got a quick question (I hope). I want a 40's style fedora. The Stetson Whippet is just the style I'm looking for but I want dark gray. The Whippet only comes in light gray. Can you recommend a similar style fedora that I can get in dark gray? Thanks.

Have you considered custom or vintage?
 

m0nk

One Too Many
Messages
1,004
Location
Camp Hill, Pa
Hey, I want to get a first hat, and am looking for branding suggestions. I want a Fedora with a relatively short brim (probably around the stingy borderline, 2" or so) and for the sake of versatility will probably get something in a medium grey. I cannot afford to spend a lot on this, so I don't think I can do fur, probably wool for this "can I wear a hat consistently" experiment. I also don't know hats well enough to do online - I want to be able to put it on and look in a mirror before plunking down any money - so I guess I'm limited to new. What are some quality brands that I should look into? I know Stetson, and I know a shop in town that stocks Dobbs. I see some other brand names, but I have no idea which represent good value.

Thanks - I'm sure the wealth of knowledge around here will steer me straight.

-Mike
There are some issues with wool, which I'm sure you've read about by this time. They don't hold their shape as well and have a tendancy to shrink, however there are some nice wool hats to start you off. Stetson has one called the Pisa which is like the Saxon, but wool instead of fur. However if you want to go much less expensive than that one (I believe it's pushing $90-100) you can try the Crushable Wool hats by Jaxon over at the Village Hat Shop website. There is a c-crown fedora and a center-dent, with the latter looking more like the Stetson Saxon and Pisa hats. The brim width on these are a little wider, 2 1/4 and 2 1/2 respectively. You may find something on the site with a 2 inch brim, though, perhaps the Blues fedora....
 

1961MJS

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,370
Location
Norman Oklahoma
Hi

Before I'd buy a wool hat, I'd buy a Panama hat or a Sun Body (woven grass or something like that). Dobbs, Biltmore, and even Stetson make decent, inexpensive felt hats. Akubra's also have a great reputation. I have a wool hat that shrunk in the rain. It looks REALLY bad now.

Later
 

mikeh

New in Town
Messages
18
Location
Milwaukee
Hi

I have a wool hat that shrunk in the rain. It looks REALLY bad now.

Later

Thanks to m0nk for his recommendations - I'll start checking into them. As for the wool warnings from both, here's a followup. Once a wool hat shrinks is it done shrinking? If I go to an antique or other resale shop and run across a vintage wool felt hat that fits, it would seem it did its shrinking years ago, right?

Mike
 

1961MJS

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,370
Location
Norman Oklahoma
Hi

Wool shrinks A LOT, think grown woman's sweater to a Barbie sweater. This hat was a wool What Price Glory (WPG) British Bush hat (WW2). It shrunk about a half inch in crown and quite a bit in brim. If you plan on going inexpensive as a starter hat, get a Sun Body, or get a middle of the road styled Rabbit Felt hat, ask before you buy it. Akubra's are a good buy.

Later
 

scottyrocks

I'll Lock Up
Messages
9,178
Location
Isle of Langerhan, NY
Thanks to m0nk for his recommendations - I'll start checking into them. As for the wool warnings from both, here's a followup. Once a wool hat shrinks is it done shrinking? If I go to an antique or other resale shop and run across a vintage wool felt hat that fits, it would seem it did its shrinking years ago, right?

Mike

Probably, but chances are the vintage wool stingy brim porkpie you're lookng at in the antique store was once a ten gallon cowboy hat.
 

scooter

Practically Family
Messages
905
Location
Arizona
Ok, I'm gonna take a chance here and open myself up to look a fool, but we all live and learn right. How is a sweatband attached to a hat? I was under the impression that it is sewn in, but is it actually glued. Or is another piece glued in, then the actual sweat sewn to that. Seriously here folks, if glue is the answer, I may have a little crow to munch on.
 

monbla256

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,239
Location
DFW Metroplex, Texas
Ok, I'm gonna take a chance here and open myself up to look a fool, but we all live and learn right. How is a sweatband attached to a hat? I was under the impression that it is sewn in, but is it actually glued. Or is another piece glued in, then the actual sweat sewn to that. Seriously here folks, if glue is the answer, I may have a little crow to munch on.

On all good quality fur felt and straw hats it is sewn in. Can't say as to wool felt hats and less expensive straws.
 

DJH

I'll Lock Up
Messages
6,355
Location
Ft Worth, TX
Ok, I'm gonna take a chance here and open myself up to look a fool, but we all live and learn right. How is a sweatband attached to a hat? I was under the impression that it is sewn in, but is it actually glued. Or is another piece glued in, then the actual sweat sewn to that. Seriously here folks, if glue is the answer, I may have a little crow to munch on.

Scooter, you'll find a lot of sweatband related info in this thread.
 

bowlerman

I'll Lock Up
Messages
6,294
Location
South Dakota
Are flat caps sized differently than fedoras?
I've come across two 7 3/8 flat caps recently-- one was too snug for comfort and the other fir just right, where I normally wear a 7 1/8.
I don't usually pay any mind to these, but being right in front of me they pretty much forced themselves onto my head.
 

paulrichard

New in Town
Messages
4
Location
Scotts Valley, CA
Thanks. Yeah, I mean the modern Stetson. I'm a newbie and don't know much about hats in general, much less history. I checked out the Fed IV and it comes without the tear drop crown. I'm not sure I want to try shaping a hat just yet. Thanks for the suggestion, though.
 
Messages
15,083
Location
Buffalo, NY
Are flat caps sized differently than fedoras?
I've come across two 7 3/8 flat caps recently-- one was too snug for comfort and the other fir just right, where I normally wear a 7 1/8.
I don't usually pay any mind to these, but being right in front of me they pretty much forced themselves onto my head.

I don't think so, but I've experienced the same. It may be that many of the hats are wool and have shrunk. It may also be the style of construction... the narrow head band (compared to the wide leather sweat on a fedora) might require a little more room for comfort. I tend to find the same thing with berets. Too tight and they make headlines... kinda like corduroy pillows.
 

jlee562

I'll Lock Up
Messages
5,103
Location
San Francisco, CA
Thanks. Yeah, I mean the modern Stetson. I'm a newbie and don't know much about hats in general, much less history. I checked out the Fed IV and it comes without the tear drop crown. I'm not sure I want to try shaping a hat just yet. Thanks for the suggestion, though.

Shaping a hat is really not that hard and there are plenty of guides here on TFL. The thing is, there's not a whole lot of modern hats which really capture the vintage vibe of a 40's hat. The best other option would be to look for a vintage hat on ebay. Otherwise all your new hat options have lower, tapered crowns.
 

scottyrocks

I'll Lock Up
Messages
9,178
Location
Isle of Langerhan, NY
Thanks. Yeah, I mean the modern Stetson. I'm a newbie and don't know much about hats in general, much less history. I checked out the Fed IV and it comes without the tear drop crown. I'm not sure I want to try shaping a hat just yet. Thanks for the suggestion, though.

Shaping a hat is one of things that is much easier than it sounds. Don't let it stop you from buying an open crowned hat such s a Fed IV if that is what you really want.
 

randooch

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,869
Location
Ukiah, California
Is there still an active "Women In Hats" thread?

il_fullxfull.263701865.jpg
 

Forum statistics

Threads
109,256
Messages
3,077,416
Members
54,183
Latest member
UrbanGraveDave
Top