I missed this entire thread last month while crossing the Atlantic Ocean from Civitavecchia (Rome) to Fort Lauderdale. It appears the Aero Premier line works well with skinny guys like Sloan (and me): Higher armholes and skinny arms - less boxy fit as with the standard HWM and 50's HB designs. Anyhow, both of those jackets look great on Sloan if they were a size smaller - sort of like a junior high school kid trying on his dad's clothes.