Want to buy or sell something? Check the classifieds
  • The Fedora Lounge is supported in part by commission earning affiliate links sitewide. Please support us by using them. You may learn more here.

Fit Check Thread for Jackets

L

LukeCham

New in Town
Messages
15
Location
Germany
Simlam said:
Hey guys, I have recently sold an M filson jacket I found too large for my liking and replaced it with a brand new size small I managed to grab.
im sharing my experiences because not being able to try one it took some trial and error.
first of all filson enthusiasts seem to have different standards when it comes to fit. They seem to be the type of people who like to wear oversized pieces so I first followed their statments That this model short cruiser runs small by opposed to some other models of the brand.
being 5.10, 165lbs, with a not so wide chest 38 inch and not so broad shoulders 45cm, the M with a 45inch chest was too roomy and didn’t like the drapes it made : few photos there https://www.thefedoralounge.com/threads/filson-roughout-fit-check.116696/
the sleeves where also too long, it made only sense when I layer a lot but it’s more a piece I intend to wear surin mid season. I’ve already got a schott b3 for winters, or other wool jackets.
so I pulled the trigger and bought a s without trying. At some point I was considering mine tailored but chickened out that I wouldn’t be done right, it was a lot of tailoring To be done.

so here is my new filson worn above a heavy flannel shirt From iron heart.
i can closed it easily and while it’s stiffer than the M one, it feels there is more room for a mid weight hoody.
its more fitted, shorter, I feel true to what a trucker jacket is like.
allow me to share a few pics.
oh and I forgot the chest is 21 inch and a quarter. So on the paper it leaves 42.5 minus 38 = 4.5 inch of room to layer a bit. what do you think of the fit?
donno if this helps anyone. Cheers
Click to expand...
Thanks for the comparison in regards to also your body measurements. The “s” looks good on you!
 
Herrvallmo

Herrvallmo

Practically Family
Messages
739
Location
Sweden
Simlam said:
Hey guys, I have recently sold an M filson jacket I found too large for my liking and replaced it with a brand new size small I managed to grab.
im sharing my experiences because not being able to try one it took some trial and error.
first of all filson enthusiasts seem to have different standards when it comes to fit. They seem to be the type of people who like to wear oversized pieces so I first followed their statments That this model short cruiser runs small by opposed to some other models of the brand.
being 5.10, 165lbs, with a not so wide chest 38 inch and not so broad shoulders 45cm, the M with a 45inch chest was too roomy and didn’t like the drapes it made : few photos there https://www.thefedoralounge.com/threads/filson-roughout-fit-check.116696/
the sleeves where also too long, it made only sense when I layer a lot but it’s more a piece I intend to wear surin mid season. I’ve already got a schott b3 for winters, or other wool jackets.
so I pulled the trigger and bought a s without trying. At some point I was considering mine tailored but chickened out that I wouldn’t be done right, it was a lot of tailoring To be done.

so here is my new filson worn above a heavy flannel shirt From iron heart.
i can closed it easily and while it’s stiffer than the M one, it feels there is more room for a mid weight hoody.
its more fitted, shorter, I feel true to what a trucker jacket is like.
allow me to share a few pics.
oh and I forgot the chest is 21 inch and a quarter. So on the paper it leaves 42.5 minus 38 = 4.5 inch of room to layer a bit. what do you think of the fit?
donno if this helps anyone. Cheers
Click to expand...
Great fit imo! and I love the Filson short cruiser so I say this is a winner :)
 
BernieH

BernieH

New in Town
Messages
23
Same jacket 3 weeks later with sensible eating and exercise!


IMG_5253.jpg
 
Eagledog

Eagledog

One of the Regulars
Messages
213
Location
Midwest
BernieH said:
I get that and what others are saying about the length, I just felt it needed a little bit more.
Click to expand...
I feel the same way about jackets with knit bottoms. Reach for anything and the jacket rides up above the belt and then you feel the chill on your lower back. Jacket tug of war all day long. The only way around it is to make sure you have 4 to 6 inches between you and the belly button area of the jacket whether sitting or standing. Then it doesnt climb up your back all the time.
I like a loose fit in this style. When I'm on the ground checking out the landing gear on my Mooney I need to be able to move and reach the landing gear doors and fittings. This Lost worlds has generous sizing for a 36 and enables me to complete any task without restrictions. Any shorter or tighter and it would be a nuisance.
20250318_143237.jpg
20250318_143223.jpg
 
Last edited:
El Marro

El Marro

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,806
Location
California

Featured products

El Marro

El Marro

My Mail is Forwarded Here
Messages
3,806
Location
California
Simlam said:
Hey guys, I have recently sold an M filson jacket I found too large for my liking and replaced it with a brand new size small I managed to grab.
im sharing my experiences because not being able to try one it took some trial and error.
first of all filson enthusiasts seem to have different standards when it comes to fit. They seem to be the type of people who like to wear oversized pieces so I first followed their statments That this model short cruiser runs small by opposed to some other models of the brand.
being 5.10, 165lbs, with a not so wide chest 38 inch and not so broad shoulders 45cm, the M with a 45inch chest was too roomy and didn’t like the drapes it made : few photos there https://www.thefedoralounge.com/threads/filson-roughout-fit-check.116696/
the sleeves where also too long, it made only sense when I layer a lot but it’s more a piece I intend to wear surin mid season. I’ve already got a schott b3 for winters, or other wool jackets.
so I pulled the trigger and bought a s without trying. At some point I was considering mine tailored but chickened out that I wouldn’t be done right, it was a lot of tailoring To be done.

so here is my new filson worn above a heavy flannel shirt From iron heart.
i can closed it easily and while it’s stiffer than the M one, it feels there is more room for a mid weight hoody.
its more fitted, shorter, I feel true to what a trucker jacket is like.
allow me to share a few pics.
oh and I forgot the chest is 21 inch and a quarter. So on the paper it leaves 42.5 minus 38 = 4.5 inch of room to layer a bit. what do you think of the fit?
donno if this helps anyone. Cheers
Click to expand...
That fit looks great to me and I agree that Filson runs big in almost everything they make.
 
P

Pkshfo74036

One of the Regulars
Messages
113
RMC Type 1 Size 40. I usually take a 42 or 44 but sized down for this one.

Shoulders overhang, sleeves shorter than I like, chest is perfect, but arm holes are higher than I like, waist length and width is good I think.

What do others think? Is this expected for a vintage denim type 1 cut? It's kind of boxy and short. It is comfortable.

mmexport1742350568611.jpg
mmexport1742350593072.jpg
mmexport1742350561770.jpg
mmexport1742350582617.jpg
 
MrProper

MrProper

I'll Lock Up
Messages
4,730
Location
Europe
Pkshfo74036 said:
RMC Type 1 Size 40. I usually take a 42 or 44 but sized down for this one.

Shoulders overhang, sleeves shorter than I like, chest is perfect, but arm holes are higher than I like, waist length and width is good I think.

What do others think? Is this expected for a vintage denim type 1 cut? It's kind of boxy and short. It is comfortable.

View attachment 690018 View attachment 690019 View attachment 690020 View attachment 690021
Click to expand...
For my taste: good length, sleeves borderline and very wide, back takes some getting used to with the pleats, but that's probably the way it should be. But definitely wearable and doesn't look bad.
 
Eagledog

Eagledog

One of the Regulars
Messages
213
Location
Midwest
Sleeves are too short. Looks like the back would feel lumpy when sitting in a car. Sleeves also look like they are bulky and bothersome. It just does not look flattering. The boxy cropped look reminds me more of a women's style.
 
Bennarion

Bennarion

Call Me a Cab
Messages
2,558
Pkshfo74036 said:
RMC Type 1 Size 40. I usually take a 42 or 44 but sized down for this one.

Shoulders overhang, sleeves shorter than I like, chest is perfect, but arm holes are higher than I like, waist length and width is good I think.

What do others think? Is this expected for a vintage denim type 1 cut? It's kind of boxy and short. It is comfortable.

View attachment 690018 View attachment 690019 View attachment 690020 View attachment 690021
Click to expand...
I think they follow the vintage cut in this jacket model.
 
W

WolfofStateSt

A-List Customer
Messages
486
I need a fit check on this Mister Freedom A-1 jacket, please.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3597.jpeg
    IMG_3597.jpeg
    1.5 MB · Views: 42
  • IMG_3598.jpeg
    IMG_3598.jpeg
    1.4 MB · Views: 41
  • IMG_3600.jpeg
    IMG_3600.jpeg
    1.1 MB · Views: 43
  • IMG_3601.jpeg
    IMG_3601.jpeg
    1.2 MB · Views: 42
  • IMG_3602.jpeg
    IMG_3602.jpeg
    1.3 MB · Views: 44
You must log in or register to reply here.

Members online

... and 46 more.
Total: 1,805 (members: 96, guests: 1,709)

Forum statistics

Threads
111,175
Messages
3,116,435
Members
55,498
Latest member
AmericanProBiss
Top