Babydoll
Call Me a Cab
- Messages
- 2,483
- Location
- The Emerald City
Blown capacitor. Now where to find a replacement and a soldering kit.
Blown capacitor. Now where to find a replacement and a soldering kit.
Best of WEC 2
Just watched all three episodes of the German miniseries, Generation War (Unsere Mütter, unsere Väter) about five German friends during World War II. Incredibly well done. It's on Netflix streaming.
Highly, highly recommend.
I'm so glad you enjoyed it. Good story / interesting to see a German perspective / well acted / beautifully filmed / gorgeous period sets.
Agreed on all counts. I'm writing up a review of it for my WW2 blog. I know it generated some controversy, and I wanted to address those points. Hope to have it up today or tomorrow.
Decided to finish it up while it's still fresh in my mind. It's on my blog now:
http://bestofww2.blogspot.com/2015/08/generation-war-unsere-mutter-unsere.html
Outstanding review. I couldn't agree more about the balanced view that did not - at all - whitewash out German atrocities, but did accurately show that not all Germans were true believers. And, yes, the transition of the characters was a triumph of acting skills. The five leads all went convincingly from youthful glow and optimism to worn-beyond-their-years physically and emotionally.
There is a lot of junk on TV (True TV, which, for some evil-cable reason I can't correct, comes up every time I turn on my Time Warner Cable box, is enough to cause one to almost lose faith in humanity), but every so often a quality piece of art like "Generation War" tumbles out and it makes one willing to keep looking for more.
Here's an example of a review I didn't quite agree with (from the NY Times, no less): http://www.nytimes.com/2014/01/15/movies/generation-war-adds-a-glow-to-a-german-era.html?_r=0
And here's one that I largely agree with:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/going...e69d4e-a92e-11e3-b61e-8051b8b52d06_story.html
The NYT review reads as if the author's opinion was formed before watching - this movie is not hard enough on the Germans, it softens historical atrocities to allow for modern German acceptance - and it wasn't going to be changed by the contradictory reality of the movie itself. Despite his intense desire to dislike it, you can feel the author slipping into admiration for the quality of the production in the middle of the review, only to force his "this movie is a whitewash" attitude to return later. It is a historical fact that not all Germans were ardent Nazis, that some Germans risked their lives to save Jews, that some were ambivalent to the war and some just went along with the tide. This reviewer seems scared that these facts might sneak out and break down the one sentence narrative that all Germans were bad Nazis in WWII.
While I could quibble here or there with it (when can't I), the Washington Post review is respectful of the limitations of a six hour movie that wants to succeed as entertainment and appreciates the thoughtful portrayal of the characters. Sure, it was an active, against-the-odds choice to highlight five not-Nazi youths in 1941 Germany, but as the reviewer notes, German atrocities aren't hidden and the intent of the film was to highlight those who didn't fit the mold. And it is a fair point to note that the Russians (who did, on the whole, engage in vicious, inhuman retribution on the Germans) get treated in the same two-dimensional way that Germans in WWII usually are. What I'd like to know - and am surprised I don't as I read regularly on WWII - is if the Polish resistance was as anti-Semetic in reality as they were portrayed?