Five Star Leather Jackets

[handymike]

I think it’s a good job by the builder! I agree that it lacks the taper and curves, but wow it’s still impressive. The collar is off- looks like the original was curved up at the tips, and 5* cut it at an angle (the 2d comment applies). The back curve isn’t a measurement thing so much as a direction and drawing thing. I like the length, but feel the front should drop another inch or 2.
Sleeves tapered, yes. They got the patchwork and pockets right though. My issue with 5* at the moment is that while they are competant at sewing and copying, there isn’t a creative force behind the scenes pushing designs to make them all they can be. It’s almost like a computer just outputting what we input...not a bad thing, but not insightful either. After all, it’s in their interest to have you order #2. It would really up their game to have a creative designer come in on their end to make suggestions we can trust and say “I didn’t think of that”, or who tells us “No, bad idea!”

 

[red devil]

Hmm... It is true that my other jackets have been made with input from the maker. While for this one only my ideas. It reminds me of when I was making leather jackets in Hong Kong years ago. You would come with a pic, get measured, go through a fitting then your jacket in a few days.

It was hit and miss but loads of fun. The one that came out best was blue with a greyish fur collar.

 

[Hobbes1]

Hey guys not sure if this has been brought up before. But can we set a range on cost for this 5* jackets give or take $$
If money is not to be spoken I understand.
Thanks.

My experience with pricing for leather jacket(s) is as costly as $330. Including shipping to US.
It's $30 for customizations of any sort that they have on offer and $30 for shipping via DHL, in a bag.
Therefore, you should be able to calculate a bit with that and your sizing as the larger the jacket the higher the base cost.
I don't have experience with shearling jackets.
HTH
@RILO

 

[torfjord]

I was charged 350 $ for my jacket which will hopefully be finished tomorrow (emailed Shawn first time Monday last week). He’s been easy to communicate with and has been quick to respond despite the 4 hour time difference. I hope the jacket is as good

 

[MrProper]

Mine was between $ 340 and $ 560 (shearling)

 

[MrProper]

I think it’s a good job by the builder! I agree that it lacks the taper and curves, but wow it’s still impressive. The collar is off- looks like the original was curved up at the tips, and 5* cut it at an angle (the 2d comment applies). The back curve isn’t a measurement thing so much as a direction and drawing thing. I like the length, but feel the front should drop another inch or 2.
Sleeves tapered, yes. They got the patchwork and pockets right though. My issue with 5* at the moment is that while they are competant at sewing and copying, there isn’t a creative force behind the scenes pushing designs to make them all they can be. It’s almost like a computer just outputting what we input...not a bad thing, but not insightful either. After all, it’s in their interest to have you order #2. It would really up their game to have a creative designer come in on their end to make suggestions we can trust and say “I didn’t think of that”, or who tells us “No, bad idea!”

Yes, I have thought that many times. Someone who challenges their own ideas and also makes suggestions on how something can be improved or which idea may be less good. But I could also imagine that this is perhaps such a cultural thing, according to the motto that a suggestion for improvement could be interpret as a criticism, so better not

 

[handymike]

It is the difference between a $370 maker and a $1000 maker.
Problem is that by the time you figure it out on your own it’s already at $740 (or more).

 

[red devil]

I think they don't want to be criticised for their advice? If they suggest something that the buyer ends up disliking? At the moment it is a very clear "you are choosing everything at your own risk" deal.

 

[handymike]

I think it’s an easy way to get out of a re-make...This is a choice perhaps, or a cultural difference, either way it leaves me waiting in the wings for the moment.

 

[MrProper]

How would I ask for the taper to be fixed for another jacket? He had good accuracy with the measurements provided, so I don't think it is something you can do with better numbers.

In terms of workmanship it is pretty competent, especially considering it was the first time the machinist was doing something like this. I need to take some more close ups to show some details

Edit: typo

I‘m not a tailor, but I think I would try like this:

 

[CRP]

The 5 star version looks like a 2D version of a leather jacket.
You can see nothing is designed to fit a human body, it's just a 2D assembly of leather pieces.
The sleeves, the shoulders, the body, nothing has any curve or shows any sign of being designed for a human to fit inside.

However, the workmanship (stitching, attention to detail, willingness to experiment with new designs...) is superb. Obviously the patterns need to mature, but considering this is a jacket made from pictures and email texts I consider it a great job. With the input from all the FL members and unique requests being fulfilled, it is only a matter of time before 5* patterns will begin to mature and match up with the workmanship.

 

[red devil]

I‘m not a tailor, but I think I would try like this:
View attachment 289813

Thanks! That could work, maybe I should try it with a denim version? Would this work in denim?

 

[Bahabp100]

It has arrived. so let's start with the pics as usual

This looks quite amazing to me . !!!

 

[ton312]

I would attach a measurement to each of mr propers lines in the pic above. That could correct the problem. As discussed the jacket needs to be hourglass shaped a bit and less uniform in measurement from pit to hem. Essentially a Halfbelt without the belt. Like mine:

 

[red devil]

I would attach a measurement to each of me propers lines in the pic above. That could correct the problem. As discussed the jacket needs to be hourglass shaped a bit and less uniform in measurement from pit to hem.

I get the feeling it would help to add measurements between the 2 vertical seams as well now that I think about it

 

[Marc mndt]

I‘m not a tailor, but I think I would try like this:
View attachment 289813

I would use clamps to 'pin down' the extra leather, following the seams. Then I would use chalk to mark where the seams should be and send a photo of it to Shawn. Best to measure that too. Otherwise you might end up with a jacket that is too tight or just out of shape.

Similar to how a suit jacket is pinned. (Don't use pins, use clamps )

 

[CRP]

Mine was $300 with custom sizing, additional inner pocket, elimination of upper two pockets, and addition of lower hand pockets. I took the basic cafe racer on his website and modified it, so just a modification of an existing design.

 

[handymike]

Your body is already making the jacket do the right thing. Just need to trim off the excess.

 

[red devil]

I would use clamps to 'pin down' the extra leather, following the seams. Then I would use chalk to mark where the seams should be and send a photo of it to Shawn. Best to measure that too. Otherwise you might end up with a jacket that is too tight or just out of shape.

Similar to how a suit jacket is pinned. (Don't use pins, use clamps ) View attachment 289821

That's how you did it with your mock up isn't it?

 

[red devil]

Your body is already making the jacket do the right thing. Just need to trim off the excess.
View attachment 289822

Good point, I hadn't figured it out. If you get rid of the excess, you indeed will get the curvy seems and a nice back